Buying a handgun in California isn’t easy, but it’s possible.
One of the biggest challenges is understanding why almost all of the guns you see online are illegal for you, but fine for everyone else. I feel your pain!
Today, I’ll walk you through some of the legal hurdles, explain some general firearm-selecting criteria, and recommend what I consider to be the best California-compliant handguns you can buy right now.
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Overall
-
Best Budget
-
Best Premium
Table of Contents
Loading…
California-Compliant Pistol Comparison Chart
| Caliber | Action | Capacity | Optic Ready | Price | |
| Springfield Echelon | 9mm | Semi-automatic, striker | 10+1 | Yes | $650 |
| Sig Sauer P365-XMacro | 9mm | Semi-automatic, striker | 10+1 | Yes | $799 |
| Walther PDP | 9mm | Semi-automatic, striker | 10+1 | Yes | $699 |
| Rost Martin RM1C | 9mm | Semi-automatic, striker | 10+1 | Yes | $459 |
| Staccato HD P4 | 9mm | Semi-automatic, single action | 10+1 | Yes | $2,699 |
| Springfield 1911 Loaded | .45 ACP | Semi-automatic, single action | 7+1 | No | $858 |
| Henry Golden Boy Revolver | .22 S/L/LR | Revolver, double action/single action | 10 | No | $692 |
| S&W PC Model 19 Carry Comp | .38 Spl/.357 Mag | Revolver, double action/single action | 6 | No | $1,299 |
How I Chose the Best California-Compliant Pistols
Curious how we picked these handguns – and how we know you won’t land yourself in jail by owning one? Let’s break it all down.
Know the Law
When it comes to legal matters, I always recommend going straight to the source. In this case, that’s the State of California Department of Justice.
“As of January 1, 2001, no handgun may be manufactured within California, imported into California for sale, lent, given, kept for sale, or offered/exposed for sale unless that handgun model has passed firing, safety, and drop tests and is certified for sale in California by the Department of Justice,” the attorney general’s website reads. “Private party transfers, curio/relic handguns, certain single-action revolvers, and pawn/consignment returns are exempt from this requirement.”
Even though the law took effect in 2001, manufacturers have successfully gotten new pistols added to the list of California-legal handguns in recent years. In fact, the California DOJ maintains a list of recently added models.
The Usual Suspects
There was a time when recommending handguns to Californians felt like dusting off historic artifacts. The handgun roster was full of outdated and discontinued models.
These days, things are looking a lot better. Many of the handguns in this article appear in our recommendations for every other state. They’re some of the Best Handguns for Beginners & Home defense, Best Concealed Carry Guns, and Best Tactical Pistols – just with reduced-capacity magazines and other features to satisfy California requirements.
Meet the Experts
Editing this article is Scott Murdock. Scott spent several years living in California while on active duty in the Marine Corps. Now, he lives just across the state line and frequently visits the Golden State. He’s owned, reviewed, or shot nearly every firearm on this list. For those he doesn’t have personal experience with, Scott tapped into the collective experience of the Pew Pew Tactical team — some of whom also lived in California — to bring you the best handguns you can legally own in California.
Editor-in-Chief Jacki Billings runs our experienced team of reviewers. Jacki has a bachelor’s degree in journalism and has worked as a media professional for close to 20 years, specializing in gun media for almost 10 years. With 2,000+ articles to her name, she uses her professional journalism and editing experience to set testing protocols and editorial standards for Pew Pew Tactical. Jacki’s writing specialty is legislative news, and she brings that experience to fact-checking these types of articles.
Best California-Compliant Handguns
1. Springfield Echelon – Best Overall
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Wide selection of California-compliant models
- Industry-leading optic-mounting system
- Great grip shape, texture, and features
Cons
- Basic-feeling trigger
- Gas pedal takedown lever isn't ambidextrous
The Bottom Line
The more I shoot the Springfield Echelon, the more I like it. Springfield has leaned into its flagship pistol with a slew of models, options, and upgrades. Many of these are available in California; it's nice to see a manufacturer embracing the California market instead of ignoring it. It doesn't matter if you're looking for a nightstand gun or concealed carry pistol; compensated or uncompensated; there's a California-compliant Echelon for you!
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-automatic, striker
- Capacity: 10+1
- Optic Footprint: Variable Interface System
- Barrel Length: 4” (ported or non-ported), 4.5” (ported or non-ported)
- Overall Length: 7.25” (4.0C, 4.0C Comp), 8” (4.5F, 4.5F Comp)
- Weight: 24 oz
- Country of Origin: Croatia
The Springfield Echelon started strong and keeps getting better with every addition to the lineup – many of which are legal in California. If you want a feature-rich pistol that doesn’t break the bank, it’s hard to do better.
I’ve reviewed several Echelon models, and they all fit my hands well. The grip shape is comfortable, the texture gets more aggressive as pressure increases, and integrating a thumb shelf into the takedown lever for recoil control was a pro move by the designers.
Springfield includes three sizes of backstrap inserts so you can fine-tune how it fits your hands. Ergonomically, it’s a home run.
The trigger is decent, if a little unremarkable in the striker-fire category. The main thing is that the fire control group is serialized. That lets you swap it over to a different grip module down the road with no background checks or driving to the nearest FFL to pick up your order.
If you want to add a red dot (and I highly recommend it), nobody makes life easier than Springfield. The Variable Interface System provides almost universal optic compatibility with an assortment of included drop-in pins. No adapter plates, no limitations, no additional torque specs.
In its standard form, the Echelon’s high bore axis keeps recoil fairly tame. That means less fatigue at the range, and faster follow-up shots everywhere.
The ported Comp versions are even smoother. I was pleasantly surprised when I shot the Echelon 4.0C Comp left-handed during testing.
In addition to all that goodness, the Echelon tops this list because Springfield offers more California-compliant variants than the closest direct competitor, the Walther PDP.
These include several pistols we’ve reviewed: the compact Echelon 4.0C and Echelon 4.0C Comp, and the full-size Echelon 4.5F and Echelon 4.5F Comp. According to Springfield, the category-blurring Echelon 4.0FC (full-size grip, compact slide) is coming to California soon.
Watch the Echelon keep up with some pretty sporty company in our comped pistol roundup!
There are lots of holster options for the Echelon, including my current favorite. Check out my Tenicor Velo Lux review if you want a great IWB holster for concealed cary.
What do you think of the Echelon? Rate it below!
2. Sig Sauer P365-XMacro Comp – Best CCW
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Full-size performance in a compact package
- Serialized trigger makes customization easy
- Huge aftermarket support
Cons
- Slightly vague trigger feel
- Magazine restrictions hamstring this excellent design
The Bottom Line
There are a few pistols that are as good for concealed carry as the Sig Sauer P365-XMacro, but it's hard to argue that any are better outright. This compact pistol's compensator helps it shoot flatter than its direct competitors. Aftermarket support is incredible. It's truly a one-pistol solution (if you want such a thing). And yes, this one is legal in California!
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-automatic, striker
- Capacity: 10+1
- Optic Footprint: RMSc
- Barrel Length: 3.1”
- Overall Length: 6.6”
- Weight: 22 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
The Sig Sauer P365-XMacro is one of the most popular pistols in the U.S., and that’s largely due to two things: magazine capacity and relatively soft recoil. Californians can’t take advantage of Sig’s magazine wizardry, but you can get a compact carry pistol that shoots more like a full-size duty gun.
The magic is in the ported slide. Holes in the top redirect some gas upward to reduce muzzle rise. Inside, the barrel stops short of the expansion chamber so there’s no risk of getting clothing or anything else snagged and inducing a malfunction.
The P365-XMacro isn’t recoil-free by any stretch, but it’s noticeably less snappy than uncompensated pistols of the same size. To me, it feels more like a full-size pistol than another polymer carry gun.
If there’s anything you want to upgrade or modify, Sig Sauer and aftermarket manufacturers have you covered. The trigger group is serialized, which means you can swap out any other component without paying for another background check at your FFL.
Mounting a red dot or pistol light is a piece of cake with the P365-XMacro. There are more holster options than I know what to do with. You’ll definitely have a reassuring level of support with this pistol.
This is a great pick for anyone who wants a one-gun solution. It’s small enough to carry concealed, but controllable enough to serve as a home-defense pistol. It’s fun to shoot, too, so you’re probably going to become a regular at your local shooting range.
Now, who else did I hear has one of these?
But wait, there’s more! Check out our full Sig Sauer P365-XMacro Comp review.
3. Walther PDP – Best Duty
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Outstanding trigger feel
- Duty-worthy oversized controls
- Comfy, effective ergonomics
Cons
- High bore axis
- Plate-based optic-mounting system
The Bottom Line
The Walther PDP is one of the best pistols I've gotten my hands on. It wins shooters over with great ergonomics and one of the best triggers in the world of striker-fire handguns. It's as accurate as a lot of competition guns, but as reliable as battle-hardened Glocks. If Walther offered more California-compliant models, it would give the Springfield Echelon a real run for its money.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-automatic, striker
- Capacity: 10+1
- Optic Footprint: Adapter plates
- Barrel Length: 4” (Compact), 4.5” (Full-Size)
- Overall Length: 7.5” (Compact), 8” (Full-Size)
- Weight: 24 oz
- Country of Origin: Germany
The Walther PDP is one of the most popular pistols around here, and I have one on home-defense duty as I write this. It’s one of the best pistols on the market – I just wish Walther made more California-compliant models.
Ergonomics are a strong point for the PDP. The grip texture somehow feels padded and rock-solid at the same time, and the subtle curves fit my hand perfectly. Laugh at those exaggerated slide serrations if you want, but they’ve given me total control in all kinds of nasty weather. I’m a fan.
Then there’s the PDP’s trigger – easily one of the best striker triggers in the business. It annoys me that neither California-compliant PDP comes with Walther’s superb Dynamic Performance Trigger out of the box, but you can buy it separately.
Walther uses adapter plates for red dots. That gives you lots of options, but it’s another piece of hardware you’ll have to install. At least adding a light on the Picatinny rail is easy.
Californians can get the PDP with a compact grip and a 4-inch barrel, or a full-size grip and a 4.5-inch barrel. Both are pretty chunky pistols, but the PDP Compact is reasonably easy to carry concealed.
I really wish Walther would offer the PDP F-Series in California because it’s arguably the best pistol for shooters with small hands. Maybe someday.
Of course, we have a Walther PDP review where you can read even more about this awesome pistol.
4. Rost Martin RM1C – Best Budget
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Surprisingly feature-rich for the price
- Nicer-than-average trigger feel
- Available with or without a compensator
Cons
- Only comes with an RMR adapter plate
- Trigger shoe requires proper finger placement
The Bottom Line
Every time I read the Rost Martin RM1C spec sheet, I'm surprised by how affordable it is. This American-made pistol delivers lots of performance in a CCW-friendly package. If you want something a little more sporty, the compensated version is also on the California handgun roster.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-automatic, striker
- Capacity: 10+1
- Optic Footprint: Adapter plates (RMR included)
- Barrel Length: 4”
- Overall Length: 7.1”
- Weight: 21 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
Sunshine tax got you down? Fear not; there are still great bargains out there, and the Rost Martin RM1C is one of my favorites. Rost Martin took design cues from all over the industry to create a pistol that’s intuitive and user-friendly.
During testing, the RM1C’s ergonomics shined. It has generous grip texture, including indexing points on the forend of the frame that help you establish a proper grip consistently. Deep slide serrations and easy-to-reach controls round out a very well-designed pistol.
The bore axis sits nice and low, like a Glock, which facilitates good recoil management. At the same time, an elongated beavertail protects the webbing of your shooting hand better than a Glock, so you’ll have less of an issue with slide bite when you get a high, firm grip on the pistol.
The sights are basic, but at least they’re metal. I won’t complain.
A clean, crisp trigger and quality manufacturing combine to give the RM1C better accuracy than you might expect from such an affordable pistol. If you do your job, it’ll take care of the rest.
One caveat is that if you place your trigger finger only on the very bottom of the trigger, it’s possible that you won’t disengage the blade-style safety. Fortunately, Rost Martin sells a performance trigger that solves this problem. You can also solve the issue with training.
The Rost Martin store also has a bunch of upgrades and accessories, so you have options even without waiting for aftermarket support to ramp up for this relatively new company.
Rost Martin ships the RM1C with an RMR adapter plate, and other footprints are available. I’ve also seen retailers offer bundles with a red dot and several magazines included for surprisingly low prices.
If you want a compensated version, that’s available, too. See it in action and read our Rost Martin RM1C review!
5. Staccato HD P4 – Best Premium
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Top-shelf build quality
- Beefed up for duty-grade durability and reliability
- Takes more affordable Glock magazines
Cons
- You could buy several pistols or cases of ammo for this price
- Grip texture is very aggressive for concealed carry
The Bottom Line
Shooting a Staccato will spoil you, and the duty-grade Staccato HD P4 is no exception. This pistol runs as smoothly as a Swiss watch, and as reliably as a Toyota Hilux. It's still expensive, but feeding it from Glock mags will take some of the financial sting out of ownership.
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-automatic, single action
- Capacity: 10+1
- Optic Footprint: HOST
- Barrel Length: 4”
- Overall Length: 7.6”
- Weight: 32 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
Allow me to give some attention to our readers of means for a moment. If you have serious cash to spend, and you want an uncompromising premium pistol, cut to the chase and treat yourself to a Staccato HD P4. Staccato’s relatively recent addition to the lineup is excellent, and it’s already legal in California.
Yes, this is the one that takes Glock magazines. That’s a huge advantage when it comes to buying extra mags (which you will need to do, especially when you’re capped at 10 rounds each). I have medium-sized hands, and I find the HD P4 easier to shoot than a 2011-style pistol. That’s a function of magazine shape.
There are few other key differences between the HD P4 and older Staccato models.
Staccato ditched the 1911-style grip safety for the HD family. Instead, it has an internal firing pin block that adds a layer of safety that you don’t have to manually deactivate to fire.
Ergonomics are updated for HD pistols, the controls are fully ambidextrous (the magazine release is reversible), and the HOST mounting system gives you options when it comes to picking an optic.
You’ll have plenty of control with this pistol, because the grip texture is about as gentle as skateboard tape. That’s awesome on the range or in an OWB holster, but less so if an IWB holster is rubbing it against your skin all day.
The trigger is as good as ever. You can expect a short, impeccably clean break with 4 to 4.5 pounds of pressure. Accuracy results were excellent during our testing of the HD P4.
Staccato will even sell you an optic, mount it, and sight it in for you at the factory. Now that’s service!
Yes, the Staccato HD P4 is expensive. We’re talking about thousands of dollars, here. But I’d be lying if I said Staccato’s fit and finish weren’t a step above what other manufacturers offer. This is an extremely refined and accurate pistol that’s still durable and reliable.
It’s designed specifically for law enforcement personnel who need a relentlessly reliable sidearm, so many of the reliability issues that come with Staccato’s more competition-oriented pistols don’t affect the HD P4.
Read our full Staccato HD P4 review for all the details!
6. Springfield Armory 1911 Loaded – Best .45 ACP
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Excellent single-action trigger
- Tritium night sights
- Classic style with a touch of history
Cons
- Limited capacity
- No ability to add an optic or light
The Bottom Line
Call me old fashioned, but I consider the Springfield 1911 Loaded a fine defensive pistol in the right circumstances. If the state is going to limit you to 10-round magazines, stepping down from 10 rounds of 9mm to seven rounds of .45 ACP doesn't seem like such a bad trade. Throw in a fantastic trigger and up-spec night sights, and you've got a winner on your hands.
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Action: Semi-automatic, single action
- Capacity: 7+1
- Optic Footprint: None
- Barrel Length: 5”
- Overall Length: 8.6”
- Weight: 40 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
You can measure firepower in two ways: ballistic performance and round count. California limits you to 10 rounds, so one way to increase your stopping power is by choosing a bigger cartridge. In this case, I’m going with America’s pistol and America’s pistol cartridge: the Springfield 1911 Loaded chambered for .45 ACP.
The 1911 traces its military history back to before World War I. It served as the U.S. military’s official sidearm until the Beretta M9 replaced it in 1985, and some elite units held onto it even longer than that.
Hallmarks of the platform include a delightfully short, clean trigger pull with a sharp break; intuitive pointability; and inherently good accuracy.
This pistol is not compatible with red dots, but it does have tritium night sights that are vastly superior to basic irons for defensive purposes.
Springfield’s 1911 Loaded also comes with a forged frame and slide; front and rear slide serrations, an ambidextrous thumb safety, real Cocobolo (a naturally rot- and insect-resistant wood) grips, and a full-length guide rod.
I love how Springfield sprinkled the 1911 Loaded with enough modern features to make it a viable defensive pistol without ruining its classic lines. Take your pick from a world of 1911 holsters, ranging from modern duty holsters with active retention to classic leather ones.
Not into 1911s? That’s ok, I have an alternate pick for you: the Sig Sauer P220.
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
This heavy-metal Sig may not have two world wars under its belt, but it’s still a proven design that has a cult following in the gun community. It’s one of the best .45 ACP pistols that isn’t a 1911.
The double-action/single-action trigger may not be as satisfying as what you’d get from a 1911, but it’s still very refined and nice to shoot. All-metal construction helps tame .45 ACP recoil and makes it feel like a much nicer firearm than your average polymer pistol.
In short, this is a true gun enthusiast’s gun. Maybe you should add it to your wishlist regardless of what you buy right now.
7. Henry Golden Boy Revolver – Best .22 LR
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Much better built than most .22 LR handguns
- Cylinder holds 10 rounds
- Great single-action trigger pull
Cons
- Heavy double-action trigger pull
- Tiny rear sights aren't ideal
The Bottom Line
The Henry Golden Boy Revolver may shoot cheap ammo, but it's a high-end revolver that you can be proud to own and pass on to the next generation. This rock-solid wheel gun shares many components with its .357 Mag sibling, so it shoots like a dream. I love the 10-shot cylinder, which keeps it competitive with semi-automatic pistols in the sunshine state.
Specs
- Caliber: .22 S/L/LR
- Action: Single action/double action
- Capacity: 10
- Optic Footprint: None
- Barrel Length: 4”
- Overall Length: 9”
- Weight: 36 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
Hold your horses, partner. I know that this is a lot of money to spend on a .22 LR handgun, but I’ll level with you: most rimfire pistols are kind of lousy to shoot. Many are glitchy, cheap-feeling, and not particularly accurate. That’s not the case with the Henry Golden Boy Revolver.
The bones of this pistol (basically everything except the barrel and cylinder) come straight from the .357 Mag Henry Big Boy Revolver we reviewed.
That means you’ll get a smooth-cycling action, clean trigger pull, and a high degree of craftsmanship. Just look at that brass grip frame and trigger guard – gorgeous!
Normally, you could choose from either the full gunfighter grip or a more CCW-friendly birdshead grip. The birdshead profile reminds me of Doc Holliday’s Colt Lightning in “Tombstone,” but it’s not on the California roster. Gunfighter it is, then.
The rimfire Golden Boy Revolver features a ten-shot cylinder that maxes out California’s capacity restriction. You don’t even have to sacrifice round count to switch from a semi-automatic pistol to this wheel gun.
What you will have to do without is a red dot and weapon light. The Golden Boy Revolver is old-school in that regard. The sights are very basic, but you can install one of three included front sights to dial in a little more accuracy.
I’ve always felt that there is nothing worse than a revolver’s double-action trigger, and nothing better than a revolver’s single-action trigger. This one plummets from about 10 pounds when you make the trigger cock the hammer for you to about 3 pounds when you cock it with your thumb. Either way, training makes all the difference.
All too often, .22 LR pistols end up in the back of the gun safe once the novelty wears off. This is one that you’ll be itching to take to the range, share with friends, and strap to your chest for a day of fly fishing.
8. Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 19 Carry Comp – Best Revolver
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Shoots .38 Spl and .357 Mag
- Ported barrel reduces recoil
- Performance Center-upgraded trigger
Cons
- An expensive way to carry six rounds
- No option to add a red dot or weapon light
The Bottom Line
The Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 19 Carry Comp combines decades of history and proven reliability with modern technology to create one of the best concealed carry revolvers you can get. Take reassurance from six doses of potent .357 Mag, and take comfort in the recoil-reducing ported barrel. This high-dollar revolver is one for the ages.
Specs
- Caliber: .38 Spl/.357 Mag
- Action: Single action/double action
- Capacity: 6
- Optic Footprint: None
- Barrel Length: 3”
- Overall Length: 8”
- Weight: 35 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
Last but certainly not least, here’s one for the big-bore wheel-gun crowd: the Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 19 Carry Comp (sorry, Smith & Wesson has a “more is better” approach when it comes to naming products).
The Model 19 dates back decades, as does the hefty .357 Magnum cartridge. Put the two together, and you have a timeless defensive handgun.
Smith & Wesson’s Performance Center hot-rodded this classic K-frame revolver with a tritium night sight, a refined action, and reduced trigger overtravel.
They also ported the barrel to knock down some of that magnum muzzle flip – a welcome feature when you’re sending such a powerful round down a 3-inch barrel.
This is a hefty handgun with a price tag to match. It isn’t priced like a polymer-framed, striker-fire pistol; but it doesn’t shoot like one, either. This is an heirloom-quality revolver that’s suitable for everything from home defense to backcountry predator deterrence. Buy once, cry once, as they say.
For those of you who aren’t familiar with straight-walled cartridges, there are certain instances where a given firearm will actually accept multiple cartridges.
In this case, you can safely fire .38 Special in addition to .357 Mag. One popular trick is to do most of your training with the cheaper and softer-recoiling .38 Spl, then switch to .357 Mag for everyday carry. Just make sure to get enough reps with the heavy hitter to be proficient with it.
How to Pick the Best California-Compliant Pistol
Legal requirements aside, deciding which handgun to buy in California is very similar to picking one in the other 49 states. Here’s what you need to know.
That Pesky Handgun Roster
The first stop for anyone looking to buy a handgun in California – well, aside from this article – is the state Department of Justice. That’s where you’ll find the most up-to-date and official information on what you’re allowed to buy.
The California Safe Handgun Roster is very specific. For example, don’t think that because you can own a Walther PDP in California every PDP is legal. Only the specific SKUs approved by the California DOJ are authorized.
When in doubt, verify with your FFL before going hot with your credit card.
What About Glock?
I know many of you have heard about Glock and want one of your own, but it’s a whole thing right now (pardon the legal jargon).
At the time of writing, a search for Glock on the California handgun roster prompts the following response in no uncertain terms:
That means you’re limited to six Austrian-made Gen3 models. Glock currently lists two commercially available Gen3 models on the company website (the Glock 42 and Glock 43), and neither of them are on California’s list of approved models.
If you can find one of the approved pistols for sale, you should be in the clear. There are other (and, in my opinion, better) options, though.
Intended Use
As always, it’s important to think about why you want to buy a handgun in the first place.
Just looking for a fun, new hobby? That’s great! Something inexpensive and affordable to shoot is all you need. Buy whatever will encourage you to hit the range more often.
If you’re concerned about self defense, prioritize stopping power, ease of use, and the availability of accessories. Many people like to add a pistol light and red dot to their defensive handguns; if that’s you, a modern, striker-fired pistol will do the trick nicely.
Whatever you buy, seek professional instruction, dry-fire at home, and train at the range regularly. Concealed carry insurance might be a wise investment.
Cartridge Selection
When it comes to selecting a cartridge for a self-defense pistol, 9mm is my default starting point. It’s the preferred cartridge of the U.S. military and almost every U.S. law enforcement entity. The balance of power, recoil, and capacity is tough to argue with.
But, as you know, California takes one of those advantages off the table. If you’re limited to 10 rounds, why not carry 10 whoppers? In that context, .45 ACP, 10mm, and .357 Mag start to make a lot of sense.
It’s ultimately your decision. Pick what you can shoot effectively, afford to train with, and reliably buy.
Accessories & Aftermarket Support
Buying a handgun is one thing; buying everything else you need to maximize its effectiveness (and fun) is another.
Before you buy a quirky dark horse pistol or revolver as your primary firearm, think about how easy it will be to find compatible lights, red dots, and holsters.
The picks on this list have healthy manufacturer and aftermarket support.
Final Thoughts
There’s a lot to love about California, but the state sure does make gun ownership difficult.
With more and more manufacturers gaining a foothold in the safe handgun roster, there’s actually some room for optimism. You’re no longer relegated to the dustbin of the firearm industry, and can instead get something modern, effective, and fun.
If you live in California, let us know what you shoot in the comments!
Which pistol would you most like to see added to the California handgun roster? Cast your vote in the comments. Ready to make a purchase? Check out our article on How To Buy A Gun In California!
Latest Updates
- February 2026: Complete re-write with new products and supporting content.
- August 2024: Updated with new models
44 Leave a Reply
Liking the Smith M&P, but a Kimber Carbon Compact R7 Mako would be SO SWEET. What's the hangup, a 10-round mag? Really think I'd love one even with that limitation.
Getting pretty 9mm-curious after my .45-chambered 1911, so I may go with that S&W if there's no R7 on the CA horizon...
(and no Glocks need apply)
Thank you
Going to buy a handgun tomorrow so I can get some fuc@#$& ammo.
Pleasantly surprised to see the Beretta PX4 Storm on the approved list!
What the CA DOJ will allow you to purchase is up for grabs.
Yes, they publish a list, but everything the do is subject to whatever whim of the day they imagine.
There are restrictions of what you can purchase in the state, but whether it’s new or used is a matter of their opinion of the day — and those opinions are very subjective. California losses one battle after another in the CA and US Supreme Courts, but California continues to act in contravention of the law, The limits of magazine capacity is a good example of that.
Firearms dealers are subject to these whims and the DOJ regularly confiscates “legal” firearms that someone in Sacramento decides that shouldn’t be sold. They have a list of firearms you can’t own as per their whims, their statute dujours, They run their state in contempt of the laws, subjectively and without accountability — and don’t mind confiscation of an individual’s firearms knowing that many people don’t have the money to fight them in court. They’ll keep doing this as long as gun owners don’t fight them.
This is probably an over asked question, but can I legally own a handgun that is not on the CA roster? I currently have a Savage 1911, Kimber Ultra Carry II, and a Walter 1911 in .22. Only one of those is on the roster, but all of them meet the requirements. Less than ten rounds and no threaded barrel. Is there an exception for Military? It looks like I’ll end up stationed at Pendleton sooner or later.
Yes you can own handguns that aren't on the roster. The roster only applies to new handguns for sale. There are registration requirements for people moving into ca, suggest you google ca. dept of justice, subsection firearms. This section also covers members of the military being stationed in ca. Due to ever changing political landscape here in ca, I'd try and leave my guns with someone out of state.
So I can’t buy those guns new? What if I were to bring them in from my current home state of VA?
If the handguns you currently have are on the ca. roster then yes you could buy new ones here in ca. Again check the ca. doj website for a list of what's available. Also you can bring your guns with you if moving into ca, just be aware that ca. law requires you to register them with the state. Again the doj website will have the full particulars regarding registration.
You reviewed the Bersa Firestorm, but you put an ad up for the Bersa Thunder.
To see the Firestorm, go to Palmetto State Armory's website and search for this:
Bersa Firestorm 3.5" .380 ACP 7 Round Pistol, Black - FS380M
Then click on the gun that doesn't have the trigger lock on the side.
Curious about the “there are only a couple not great 1911 in 9mm” comment - could you say more about that? I was looking for a 1911 in 9mm and finding myself frustrated by the lack of options
I love my HK P2000.
Thanks for giving the Bersa some love. I have a Firestorm and it is a tack driver, no joke. All the haters talk about metallurgy issues, well Bersa was founded by 3 Italian engineers from Berreta who immigrated to Argentina. I trust them more than some rich kid YouTube Glock boys.
This list is definitely out of date now. With the S&W Sd9ve off the list, only the sd40ve remains. The M&P 2.0’s are now on the list with a new Sig and a version of the Ruger Max 9.
We're working on an update to this as we speak!
Can we show some love to those stuck in Cali and have that updated list? It would be nice to have to something to reference for showing friends. Because the anti-roster lawsuit is never ending.
Just got a rewrite in from our CA writer and I am working on editing it as we speak! Should have it rolled out on the site by the end of this week. Thanks for the patience!
HK P30L , hands down. Oh wait a minute, hands up.
This article is only half useful. Top ten? It should be about three. What about the carrying rig? A great gun is essentially useless for concealed carry if you can't find a practical carry holster that suits your needs. Very few of the guns on this list have any substantial market for concealed carry holsters. Outside of the top 3 or 4 most popular ones, you can just forget about choices like kydex or leather, IWB/OWB, left hand/right hand, light/no light, active/passive retention, etc. You'll be lucky just to find ANY holster that fits well. Really, there are only a handful of practical carry combinations of gun and holster - definitely not 10.
Ruger EC9S? 7+1 single stack, inexpensive, and reliable.
Beretta PX4 should also be on the list. Great quality polymer hammer fired in 9mm, 40sw and 45 acp.
All that money being saved not being able to buy what the rest of the nation can buy is going into the CA government's pocket. So, we're not really saving anything.
The CA roster of approved handgun is a joke. The state claimed it’s for safety but it’s an underhanded way the state of California disarmed its citizens through legislation. One of the safety requirements for a handgun to be on the roster is microstamping which is a technology which does not exist. Anyway, this law and several others are being challenged in federal courts for being unconstitutional thanks to a recent landmark SCOTUS decision in Bruen.
What is the difference between a handgun and a hammer
My EDC is a S&W shield 40 with the Apex trigger and the duty/carry upgrade kit, an aftermarket barrel and trijicon night sights. Now that I've upgraded it pretty much as much as I can, I love it! I could have just saved up and got a Sig or a CZ but I'm happy with what I have. It's accurate and dependable and now has a great trigger. And it fits in my pocket, if I want to pocket carry.
The Shield + Apex combo is a good one!
My CA roster EDC is a Sig SP2022. I think if it as my DA/SA hammer fired P320. They have very similar dimensions, it works for a left handed shooter and it's lighter than a P226. European military and LE tested and proven.
Thank you for posting! Im picking up my G34 Gen 3 this Friday. Im excited to finally be able to shoot in California… been a long time coming.
P229 and any S&W J frame should be at the top of this list.
I know it must be very hard to get this list down to 10, BUT, by not having the H&K P2000/P2000sk (the only other other sub compact next to the Shield that superior quality) as one of the top picks is sin-full. I would take the Bersa/S&W SD off and put the P2000/P2000sk as one of the top, as well as, the Springfield XD line. As well, within the Sig part where you have the P220/226, why not include the P229? Make the Bersa and SD a special mentioned, budget friendly category after the top 10.
FYI, the Bersa Firestorm .380 came off the roster this year.
I bought the SD9VE for my first gun in early 2021. Yeah, the trigger sucks, but it's otherwise a great gun. Accurate, reliable, feels good in the hand, and I personally find the two-tone look sexy.
Its back on. The back story to that was the morons at the CA DOJ didn't process the annual payment in time that Bersa is forced to pay annually. Same happened with H&K at the beginning of the year. Every HK fell off roster for about a week before someone decided to accept payment.
The USP series is still off the roster. Only HK’s available are the p2000/k’s unfortunately
I'm getting frustrated... I had my Walther PPKS stolen about 2 years ago...my best carry pistol. But the PPKS was heavy and I am older so I need a lighter weight small pistol .380...since I have a quantity of .380 ammo left over. Bursa...Tarus... springfield... all would be excellent! But living in CA... I am running into a brick wall...even to find any of these even AVAILABLE from Dealers. Any suggestions??? Kirt Salisbury Livermore, ca
Don't overlook Kahr Arms. As small as they come and their whole line designed for CCW. And, made in Nevada! It's a little surprising that one of their models wasn't among the top 10 list here.
Yeah. I own the CW9. It's incredibly comfortable in the hand and has magazines with an extension that gives it a longer grip. Very smooth double action trigger and well priced for California. Kahr has plenty of other choices as well. And while some might argue the single stack magazine is inferior to the double stack, the arbitrary magazine ammo limit and the shrinking list of options for CCW pistols make it an excellent contender for quality carry pistol selections.
Late response but when I was still living in the People's Republic of Commiefornia I picked up a Springfield EMP. It's a compact, 9mm 1911 that's on the roster. Kind of expensive but it's been reliable so far and it's small enough to be concealed with no problems, other than it's relative heft (get a good belt and holster to support it). The light trigger lends itself to good accuracy from such a small pistol and it's pretty good looking - doesn't mean much but it is very eye catching when I'm with friends or family at the range.
Where are all of the revolvers on the list? S&W 627 pro series, Ruger GP100 and so on
I couldn’t live there. Period.
Other Gen 3 GLOCKS available include the 36 and 30SF
We have both the 226 and 19. both are really good guns. but we also have a fmk and that is almost as good as the glock for about $200 less.
"The only way around the roster is to find a California resident that owns the gun you want and make a private sale for it, or be exempt yourself from the roster — and that’s LEO only." --you failed to mention an interstate, intra-familial transfer (e.g. have a parent in another state gift you a non-CA roster handgun). Pretty close family ties are required - has to be parent or grandparent I think, I seem to remember aunts/uncles are excluded. Internet search will give you all the specifics.
I’m going to add HK USPs. I know their design is a bit dated, but they great shooters!
It really is a fine gun. One of the best first time guns you can get really, and good for many years after into intermediate and advanced.
You should also mention the Springfield XD Gen 1 series of handguns. They are usually less expensive than the Glock models, and if your like me and don't care for the finger grooves and grip angle on the Glock Gen 3's, they're a solid alternative. They are available in 3" compact, 4" service, and 5" tactical models.