So, you’ve got a great CCW or home-defense pistol. How well does it work in the dark?
I consider a pistol light just about essential for defensive purposes, because threats don’t disappear when the sun goes down. There are a lot of lights to choose from, though, so picking the best pistol light can be tricky.
Luckily for you, I put some of the top contenders through a gauntlet of testing to find out where they shine, where they struggle, and who each one is for.
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Overall
-
Best Compact
-
Best Value
-
Best Budget Full-Size
-
Best Budget Compact
Table of Contents
Loading…
Pistol Light Comparison Chart
| Power | Intensity | Battery | Waterproof | Price | |
| Fenix GL19R V2.0 | 1,200 lumens | 44,300 candela | 18350 | IP66 | $99 |
| Olight PL-MINI 3 Valkyrie | 600 lumens | 2,500 candela | Proprietary rechargeable | IPX6 | $99 |
| Streamlight TLR-1 HL | 1,000 lumens | 20,000 candela | 2 x CR123A | IPX7 | $167 |
| Streamlight TLR-7X | 500 lumens | 5,000 candela | SL-B9/CR123A | IPX7 | $139 |
| SureFire X300T | 650 lumens | 66,000 candela | 2 x CR123A/SFLFP123 | IPX7 | $341 |
How We Tested the Best Pistol Lights
This list is the result of extensive hands-on testing. In some cases, that includes years of personal use. I set out to follow a thorough shakedown that replicates real-world use so you can buy your next pistol light with confidence.
Testing Protocol
To achieve an apples-to-apples comparison, I subjected each pistol light to the same testing protocol. This should give you a usable, real-world basis of comparison to help you make a buying decision.
Mounting: I kicked off testing by mounting each light on an appropriate pistol, taking note of any manufacturer-provided torque specs, rail adapters, and instructions.
Beam: I compared lighting performance in three ways. First, I placed each pistol light up against a textured wall to illustrate center hot spots, throw angle, and edge fall-off. Second, I measured each beam’s width at 15 feet to get a practical understanding of its ability to illuminate a target and its surroundings. Third, I used a rangefinder to measure the furthest object I could realistically expect to engage to find a working maximum reach for each light.
Ergonomics: This is subjective, but I manipulated the controls of each light with and without gloves to determine how easy they are to use, and how well they avoid a light negligent discharge, or light ND (turning the light on by accident).
Live-fire: I fired at least 200 rounds of ammunition with each light to assess its ability to activate on command, illuminate targets effectively, and survive the recoil of 9mm ammunition. I placed two small targets at 15 yards – one white, one dark gray. I placed a white C-zone target at 50 yards. This gave me an opportunity to test each light’s range and ability to pick up low-contrast targets. All three were high-quality steel from TA Targets.
Durability: The Streamlight and SureFire pistol lights you see here are rated for submersion of one meter for 30 minutes; the Fenix and Olight are rated for exposure to water jets, but not submersion. For the sake of fairness, I subjected all to sprayed water to simulate rain. Finally, I performed a drop test from 1 meter onto concrete.
Batteries: So many factors affect battery life that it’s hard to make a transferrable comparison. What I can compare is how easy it is to charge reusable batteries and source disposable ones. There are some clever power solutions in some of these lights, so I made special note of those.
Meet the Experts
This article comes to you from Pew Pew Tactical Editor & Senior Review Analyst Scott Murdock. In addition to personally testing and evaluating each pistol light you see here, Scott has used pistol lights extensively in various training environments, including CQB, vehicle combatives, and live-fire obstacle courses.
He also uses a pistol light on his home-defense and concealed-carry pistols. Some of those even appear in this guide!
Best Pistol Lights
1. SureFire X300T – Best Overall
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Excellent long-range performance
- Combat-proven durability
- Multiple mounting styles to choose from
Cons
- Bulky, especially for CCW
- Budget more for batteries
The Bottom Line
I get it, the SureFire X300T costs as much as some pistols. It can back up the price, though. This pistol light is perfectly dependable and lights up targets near and far. If you have the money, treat yourself.
Specs
- Power: 650 lumens
- Intensity: 11,300 candela
- Battery: 2 x CR123A/SFLFP123
- Modes: Constant, momentary
- Waterproof: IPX7
- Length: 3.76”
- Weight: 4 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
If I could only own one pistol light, I’d take the SureFire X300T and learn to deal with its size for CCW duty. This is a rock-solid light that you can take to the ends of the earth and back.
Like the X300U, the X300T comes with one of two available mounting systems.
The A-model features a universal quick-release mechanism that makes it easy to move the light from one pistol to another, but it’s not always a tight fit; I don’t like the light rattling around. The B-model uses a screw and clamp to get a nice, tight fit on your pistol’s accessory rail.
Regardless of which model you choose, you’ll need to install the appropriate rail adapter. SureFire ships these lights with inserts for Glock and Picatinny accessory rails. These are available separately if (when) you lose one.
You might notice a small dab of green paint on mine. I use this as a witness mark to make sure the screw isn’t backing out. I do the same thing with my optic-mounting screws.
The X300T casts a narrower beam than some, with a hyper-focused hot spot in the center. In my experience, that gives me usable situational awareness with extra reach when I need it.
In close-quarters scenarios, the center portion of the beam is small and defined enough that it’s even possible to use it as an aiming reference.
Compared to the base model, the X300T kicks intensity up from 11,300 to a whopping 66,000 candela for those of you who want extra range. At the same time, SureFire dialed power down from 1,000 to 650 lumens.
More candela, fewer lumens — can that be right?
It is, and I love this configuration. Indoors, 650 lumens is more than adequate. Sometimes, a brighter light just leaves me blind after momentary use, which makes quick peeks while maneuvering in darkness out of the question.
But with 66,000 candela on tap, I don’t have to give up outdoor capability with this light. I get eyeball-friendly brightness with the ability to see deep into the darkness. It’s the best of both worlds.
SureFire is somewhat unique in terms of ergonomics because the controls are very stiff. That’s good for preventing accidental activation, but it also takes more effort to run the light. I have average-sized hands and have trouble activating constant-on mode with my index finger.
The solution is to use the thumb of my support hand, but that requires adjusting my grip (in the case of my hands and my PDP, anyway).
To activate constant-on, rotate the controls in either direction. For momentary-on, press either side forward. This approach makes it easy to remember which is which.
Live-fire training revealed the edge the X300T offers. The gradual fall-off from light to darkness subtly kept me aware of what I couldn’t see, rather than getting tunnel vision on what I could see. It’s hard to quantify, but the way light scatters is important.
The value of being able to see, identify, and engage targets out to 50 yards and beyond with a pistol in complete darkness cannot be understated.
I once participated in a winter night shoot that involved running between stations in complete darkness. If my pistol light had been overpowered, the light bouncing off the snow would have blown out my natural night vision instantly, leaving me stranded in the woods for several minutes.
The X300T didn’t subject me to such torture, and it still burned right through dense trees to locate and illuminate targets at distances most people never shoot with a pistol under the best conditions.
Controls that might normally feel stiff feel just right when adrenaline is pumping, and fine motor skills start to deteriorate. A lot of military and law enforcement types swear by the X300, and I can see why.
If you’ve heard lore about how tough SureFire weapon lights are, this one will live up to the hype.
Mine was unbothered by this test’s water and drop tests. At the cold-weather survival course I attended, freezing temperatures and deep snow didn’t faze it.
I’ve been using and abusing this particular X300T for a few years, and it’s as good as new (minus a few battle scars). The only things I’ve done to it are adding a witness mark and stocking up on rechargeable SureFire batteries and a charger.
2. Streamlight TLR-7X – Best Compact
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Huge selection of compatible holsters
- Very user-friendly controls
- Fits smaller carry guns well
Cons
- Starts to struggle as distance increases
- Outshined by the (more expensive) TLR-7 HL-X
Specs
- Power: 500 lumens
- Intensity: 5,000 candela
- Battery: CR123A/SL-B9
- Modes: Constant, momentary
- Waterproof: IPX7
- Length: 2.58”
- Weight: 2 oz
- Country of Origin: USA
I’m a huge proponent of putting a light on your carry pistol, and the Streamlight TLR-7X is my current go-to.
This time, the TLR-7 takes a rechargeable SL-B9 battery or a disposable CR123A. I appreciate the flexibility.
Streamlight ships the TLR-7 with a range of universal and Picatinny rail adapters. Check the compatibility chart to find the right fit for your pistol.
The spring-loaded, screw-down clamp makes installation fast and easy. I like to get it finger tight, then use a screwdriver to get it nice and snug.
Self-defense situations that involve a concealed pistol typically occur at very close distances. When that happens, you need situational awareness more than long-range illumination.
The TLR-7 throws a very wide beam that’s capable of lighting up an entire room. At close range, it does a fantastic job of spreading to the edges of my peripheral vision at a relatively close distance.
When you need to light up everything in your field of view right now, this is the light you want on your pistol.
The compromise is reach; the TLR-7’s 5,000 candela aren’t going to stab through the darkness outdoors like the larger pistol lights. I’m fine with that in this case, though, because the 500-lumen output is suitable for close-quarters work.
I find the TLR-7’s ambidextrous switches easy to activate. They don’t rotate; instead, tap for constant-on or press and hold for momentary-on.
Streamlight provides two sets of switches. This allows you to fine-tune the controls to match your grip. They don’t look that different, but the effect of ergonomics is noticeable. I really appreciate this customization.
Streamlight also built a safety into the bezel. Rotating it will disable the light, which I find handy when I’m transporting it in a case or storing it and don’t want the switches to get bumped and drain the battery by accident.
Live-fire testing validated my fondness for the TLR-7’s paddle switches. Even as temperatures dropped below freezing, I was able to quickly tap the right-side paddle with my trigger finger and shift to the trigger very quickly – without messing up my grip.
The wide beam and adequate light had no problem with either 15-yard target. I was even able to effectively reach out to the 50-yard target, albeit with less light than some of the more powerful alternatives.
I’d still feel comfortable with such distances – hence this being my current CCW light of choice.
The TLR-7X is rated for 30 minutes of submersion 1 meter deep, so I wasn’t surprised when it shrugged off my water test. It took the drop onto concrete like a champ, too.
I’ve also used this particular light on a bunch of different pistols, so it’s been installed and uninstalled more times than I can remember. The mounting system doesn’t show any signs of wear.
If you like this setup but want more power, grab the hot-rodded Streamlight TLR-7 HL-X and call it a day.
3. Streamlight TLR-1 HL – Best Value
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Great range
- Easy-to-access strobe function
- Duty-ready, but not priced like it
Cons
- Switch feels a little fragile
- I don't love the chrome accent
Specs
- Power: 1,000 lumens
- Intensity: 20,000 candela
- Battery: 2 x CR123A
- Modes: Constant, momentary
- Waterproof: IPX7
- Length: 3.39”
- Weight: 4 oz
- Country of Origin:
If the prospect of dropping new-pistol money on a light doesn’t sit well with you, fear not. The Streamlight TLR-1 HL provides lots of performance at a very reasonable price.
Due to its size, I recommend the TLR-1 series for full-size pistols like the Glock 17 or Glock 47, but it also works nicely on crossovers like the Glock 19X and Glock 45.
As with other weapon lights in the TLR family, Streamlight provides multiple rail adapters and the fitment guide I referenced with the TLR-1.
Raised studs on the spring-loaded thumb screw make it easy to get a fairly tight fit with your fingers, but I still recommend using a flathead screwdriver for that last bit of security.
Aside from installing the right adapter and getting adequate tightness, there really isn’t much involved with mounting this light.
The TLR-1’s 1,000-lumen power rating is nice, but the 20,000 candela is what puts light where you need it, especially in wide-open spaces (unsolicited Dixie Chicks reference).
What really impressed me during testing was the TLR-1’s ability to blast light at almost a 90-degree angle to the lens. No pistol light on this list demonstrated a wider beam. That’s critical if you’re concerned about lighting up large areas instead of waving a narrow beam around looking for your target.
Think of this as a floodlight rather than a spotlight.
The controls on the TLR-1 look similar to those on the X300 series, but they function differently. For constant-on, rotate the paddles clockwise until they click into place. For momentary-on, rotate them counter-clockwise.
This requires you to remember which is which, so training is key – especially if you run different lights on different pistols.
The TLR-1 also has a strobe function. Quickly double-tap and hold either switch counter-clockwise to activate it, and let go to turn it off. Of course, you’ll have to do with your support hand if you plan on shooting with the strobe.
There’s very little resistance, so activating either switch with one finger is relatively easy.
The TLR-1’s floodlight-style beam excelled in my live-fire testing. Once again, numbers don’t tell the whole story. The beam was so wide that it instantly illuminated all three targets. That let me plan ahead and move from one to the next without searching in the darkness.
Engaging the 50-yard target was no issue with this amount of power and intensity.
The skinny posts on the rotating switch weren’t quite as easy for me to find as the X300T’s chunky knobs, but less resistance made it easier for me to flick the light on with my trigger finger.
The TLR-1 HL is a large pistol light that doesn’t weigh very much – that could suggest that it’s not particularly strong. Fortunately, it aced my water ingress and drop tests.
While I still suspect the X300T is tougher, I don’t have any reservations about recommending the TLR-1 HL as a duty or home-defense pistol light.
4. Fenix GL19R V2.0 – Best Budget Full-Size
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Great quick-release system
- Sturdy construction
- Three sizes of switches included
Cons
- Switches don't feel as nice as the rest of the light
- Too long for a lot of pistols
Specs
- Power: 1,200 lumens
- Intensity: 44,300 candela
- Battery: 18350, USB-C charging port
- Modes: Constant, momentary
- Waterproof: IP66
- Length: 3.7”
- Weight: 4 oz
- Country of Origin: China
Can you really get a usable duty pistol light for less than $100? That’s what I wondered when I got my hands on the Fenix GL19R V2.0 when it first launched.
The aluminum body and tight tolerances are a good start. The paddle-style switches feel a little flimsy, but they work and require minimal effort. They’re not so light that I’m worried about accidental activation, though.
The battery is rechargeable via USB-C, or you can unscrew the bezel to replace it in seconds. An LED battery level indicator under the rubber dust cover will give you a heads-up when power runs low. I happen to like being able to charge the battery without removing it.
I’d recommend the GL19R for larger pistols simply because of its length. If you pair this with something like a Glock 19, it’s going to look like a Narwhal tusk.
Mounting this light is easy because the Glock and Picatinny rail adapters pop in and out with no tools. Just be careful not to drop them; these tiny discs could disappear in a hurry.
Rather than using a screw to fasten the light onto a pistol, Fenix opted for a lever-style latch that has really won me over during the past several months. It’s easy to move the light from one pistol to another in seconds, and it’s never failed on me. I actually think it might be less likely to lose grip than a screw, which could back out over time with enough recoil vibration.
Fenix might pitch the GL19R V2.0 as a budget pistol light, but the output certainly doesn’t look budget to me. The 1,200 lumens and 44,300 candela combine for a seriously bright spotlight that can go the distance.
Fall-off is very crisp. While that looks incredibly satisfying in my wall demonstration, it’s not ideal in the field.
That drastic of a contrast really encourages you to hyperfocus on the narrow spot of light and forget about what’s happening around it.
Could the switches be more tactile? Sure. But, for the money, I’m not going to whine about it. I do appreciate that Fenix provides three sets of switches so you can fine-tune the reach to your fingers.
Press either switch up to activate momentary-on, or flip them down to activate constant-on. Once depressed, they’ll stay there until you return them to the center position.
The narrow, sharp beam pattern became extra apparent during live-fire testing. It sort of felt like looking through a straw.
The power certainly wasn’t lacking, though. This was one of the best performers at 50 yards.
But would I bet my life on it? The controls don’t inspire as much confidence as I’d like, and the harsh fall-off isn’t my cup of tea. It works, though. For the price, you could do a whole lot less. Actually, there are pistol lights that cost more and don’t perform this well.
If money is tight, this is way, way better than taking a shot in the dark (unsolicited Ozzy reference; what a diverse musical diet we’re enjoying today).
Like other all-metal pistol lights, the GL19R V2.0 did well in my water and drop tests. I expected as much after using it for several months prior to testing.
The fact that you can get such a rugged light for such a reasonable price is encouraging. Just keep an eye on those switches; if this light has a weak point, I suspect they’re it.
5. Olight PL-MINI 3 Valkyrie – Best Budget Compact
(Editor’s Note: Pew Pew readers get 10% off at Olight with code PEWPEWTACTICAL)
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Flexible mounting system
- Replace the rechargeable battery quickly
- Constant-on strobe function
Cons
- Very limited range
- Proprietary battery
Specs
- Power: 600 lumens
- Intensity: 2,500 candela
- Battery: Proprietary rechargeable
- Modes: Constant, momentary
- Waterproof: IPX6
- Length: 2.07”
- Weight: 3 oz
- Country of Origin: China
I’m not sure that any lighting company has a starker contrast between a devoted fanbase and a mob of angry detractors than Olight. I’m all about testing and data, though, so I got busy with the Olight PL-MINI 3 Valkyrie.
This tiny pistol light is well-suited to CCW pistols like the smaller Glocks, the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, and Springfield Hellcat. With separately-sold adapters, it’ll also work with pistols like the Sig Sauer P365.
The battery is rechargeable via a proprietary charging dock, and you can swap it out for the spare in seconds – a big upgrade for this model. There is a charge status LED, but you have to remove the battery to see it.
There’s a module that sits between the light and the pistol’s accessory rail – that’s where you install the appropriate rail adapter.
This assembly slides forward and rearward on the light when it’s not screwed down, which means you can position it right where you want it.
The various rail adapters fasten in place with a pair of tiny set screws. Fortunately, Olight includes spares.
This many moving pieces seems like tempting fate, but the system worked for me once I tightened it down with a screwdriver.
The PL-MINI 3 throws a wide, full beam that’s useful in close-quarters situations. When you’re indoors, lighting up all corners of the room is more important than blasting an intense beam into the abyss.
There is some degree of hot-spotting in the center, where you want the most light and need to keep your eyes focused.
Thanks to the sliding interface, the buttons are always easy to reach. Tap for constant-on, press and hold for momentary-on.
The PL-MINI 3 also has the best strobe function because it stays on once you activate it. Some people like shooting with a strobe, some don’t; I’m glad the option exists so everyone gets what they want.
The tactile feel of these buttons is a little vague, and they didn’t always respond how I expected them to during my live-fire testing. Practice makes perfect, though. That’s true for all of these pistol lights.
My night shoot made it extremely clear where the PL-MINI 3 excels and where it struggles.
Up close, the wide beam was helpful when transitioning between my 15-yard targets. I could have used more power to separate the dark gray silhouette from the dark background, but it was usable.
The 50-yard target was a no-go with the PL-MINI 3. I could just make out the target – possibly because I set up the range and had shot on it moments before – but I did not consider it a safe engagement distance with this light. It just doesn’t have the intensity to reach that far.
Whenever I handled the PL-MINI 3, it didn’t give the impression that it thrives on abuse, like some of my other picks. There are too many moving parts and too much plastic for me to recommend it for hard use, but it did pass my durability tests.
That means it lives up to Olight’s promises. It’s an odd duck, but one that I think a lot of people would enjoy on a range toy or plinker.
(Remember, Pew Pew readers get 10% off with code PEWPEWTACTICAL)
How to Pick the Best Pistol Lights
While I recommend all these lights, some are better for certain situations than others. Here are some things you need to consider when you make your choice.
Size & Holster Compatibility
Pistol lights come in various sizes, so it’s important to pick one that’s appropriate for the host pistol you’ve chosen. A full-size light wouldn’t make much sense on a subcompact pistol, and a tiny light would produce a huge barrel shadow on a full-size pistol.
If you plan on using a holster, you’ll need to find one that works with your pistol light. That might be a holster that’s built specifically for your pistol/light combo, a light-specific holster that’s compatible with a range of pistols, or a pistol-specific holster that’s compatible with a range of lights.
Power & Intensity
Pistol light manufacturers measure performance in lumens and candela. Lumens tell us how bright the light is, while candela tell us how far we can expect it to reach into the darkness.
It’s important to get a light that’s powerful enough for your needs, but more isn’t always better. Using too much power in a small room with white walls is a recipe for temporary blindness. Likewise, using an underpowered pistol light outdoors might give your position away without giving you a chance to engage the threat.
Battery
Pistol lights don’t all use the same batteries, and there are some awfully strong opinions out there about which power source is best.
Disposable batteries let you swap in fresh ones in a hurry. Rechargeable batteries save money and let you start each day with maximum power. Removable, rechargeable batteries offer the best of both worlds.
Whichever power source you choose, make sure to stock up on batteries so your pistol light doesn’t leave you in the dark.
Durability
Finally, think about how much abuse your pistol light needs to stand up to.
If you’re outfitting a duty pistol that’s going to get knocked around all day, every day, spend the extra money to get something rugged.
If you’re setting up a range-day plinker, you might be able to get away with something less expensive.
Final Thoughts
Does spending more money necessarily get you a better product? When it comes to pistol lights, the answer is yes.
There’s a reason professionals stick to the same few weapon lights, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t times when something more affordable will do the trick.
If you’re going to be hard on your gear and put your life on the line, a SureFire or Streamlight will serve you well. If money is tight, a Fenix or Olight is way better than eating a few carrots and hoping you’ll develop superhuman night vision.
Whatever you choose, come on back and share your experiences in the comments!
What’s your go-to pistol light? Let us know below. Looking to set up all your guns with lights? Check out our guide to the Best AR-15 Flashlights!
Latest Updates
January 2026: Complete overhaul with new products, testing, and supporting content.
105 Leave a Reply
No doubt you are getting all sorts of suggestions on what lights to test, as the market has expanded considerably.
One to consider might be the HF light, and when in stock (somewhere) for $49 many would be interested to see how it fares. They sell quickly when in stock.
Thanks for the recommendation! Just having the option to get into a pistol light for that price is really exciting.
Some good lights, no doubt: your ease of operation once mounted on your pistol would likely be a factor for considering its utility, so I’d suggest taking your firearm to your favorite store, mounting the light, and trying it out.
Is brighter better? Maybe. Too much light will destroy your night vision. Consider that.
I prefer a light that is operated by a rotary switch so, in clearing a house, I can turn the light out rather than telegraph my every move to an intruder.
Take a class from a reputable school in how to clear a house at night. You might just save a life (yours).
Batteries: I much prefer a light powered by lithium batteries… as they last longer. Regular batteries will fail over time much more rapidly than lithium, so for those lights that use AA or AAA cells, change them twice a year. I’d suggest doing that when DST goes into effect or is cancelled — along with changing furnace filters, or smoke detector batteries. Get in the habit: worse come to worse, keep a record of changes.
Quote from this article: “Engaging the 50-yard target was no issue with this amount of power and intensity” Would engaging a 50-yard target at night be considered self-defense or murder? Think it over.
Last of all, when I pick up a firearm at home to check for an intruder, not only do I check that the pistol is loaded (press-check), check for a full magazine, check that my Holosun sight is working, but I also check that my light is working. Why? I don’t want any avoidable surprises.
For a house(hand) gun, I'm really loving my $30 Feyachi. On our ARs, we use Streamlight and Surefire tailcap activated lights.
Glad you found something you like. I don't have experience with Feyachi, but Streamlight has always done right by me in terms of providing a lot of performance at a very reasonable price, and SureFire is excellent.
What you call the Harries Method, has been called the Chapman Method for over 30 years. Not that it makes any difference. It is still the best way to navigate in the dark if your pistol dust cover doesn't have a mounting option.
If and/or when you update any of lights , you should add candela. Candela makes a huge difference performance not just lumens
Thanks for the suggestion!
Just wanted to mention Fenix for a future review. I have used the Fenix GL23R. It is very dependable. Please look at all the weapon lights, mounts and pressure switches that Fenix offers. Thank you for your time!
Being in my 60s with aging eyes, having a light/laser combo means that if something goes bump in the night, I don't need to be trying to put on glasses while at the same time grabbing my pistol from the nightstand. You don't need to have good vision or a perfect sight picture when all you need to do is flip the switch and put the little green dot on the intruder in your flashlight beam.
Sounds like you've thought it through, Thomas. That's a great setup!
Lasers are a personal choice. I like them, but others say they're pointless at best and a crutch at worst. Best suggestion I can give you is to get one with a laser. If you don't like it, don't use it.
What about the pistol light laser combos like the light & green laser rechargeable pistol lights from Viridian?
Rechargeable is great, but you can’t recharge them forever. Check the number of cycles of the light.
Time to add the TLR-7 HL-X! The higher performance upgrade gives you TLR-1 HL levels of performance with the smaller TLR-7 body (slightly longer head) and the option of the rechargeable SL-B9 and CR123 batteries (with different performance levels). Only downside is you will need a new holster (or modify your old one) if upgrading from the older TLR-7 versions. Add the TLR-7 sub for the sub-compact uses.
Also worth mentioning the X300 Turbo and Modlite PL350 in the X300 section.
Love you guys!! Keep up the good work!
Oh I forgot to mention the fellas over at Four Brothers Holsters have a good line up of holsters for handguns with lights. They were the only ones to have an IWB holster for my Sig P365 with a TLR-8 G Sub.
I have a Streamlight TLR-8G Sub for my Sig P365 and love it. 500 lumens is good for me, the laser doesn’t hold zero after a mag or two but I always zero back in after a day at the range. Mostly used for home Defence, at least that’s the intention.
I have a gen 2 Glock model 23 (no rail). Is there an option out there for my older Glock? I don’t want to modify the pistol.
Hi Norm,
I recommend Recover Tactical. I have had a rail adapter for about 10 years now on my Gen 1 G17 and it works great.
How about an article on light bearing holsters to fit these options. I always have a hard time finding holsters. I have a 229 elite I love with an olightPLPro I can’t find a holster for.
Great article.
Some of the lights specs are not correct. Mainly the advertising fluff from olight. You forgot to mention those "eye burning" lumens stated are only for seconds before the light drops to subpar lumens. Very misleading when you state a light has 1500 lumens and highest of all pistol lights test when in fact it 1500 lumens for 45 seconds then drops to 450 lumens which is far below other lights in this category.
In all honesty, he didn't even test the right models. The baldr models are better and will run longer on the brightest modes.
But I'm just realizing this is from 2yrs ago so those models might be new.
Just info Surefire does make nice lights formed fitted for certain EDC handguns. I have one for my Springfield Hellcat, 350 lumens rechargeable comes with a 2 battery charging cradle, only 1 battery included but can buy extra. The light barely passes the 3 inch barrel. Two years of charging same battery and still going strong so far worth the 300 bucks, worth looking into if they have one for your EDC.
I'm surprised the Surefire X400 didn't make the list. I think it's the best laser light combo out there. Pricey but excellent.
Can't simp for Streamlight if another combo is included...
Well, I guess I owe you guys a thanks. This article got me to finally buy a light. I always new I needed one. Something always seemed more necessary. I went with the TLR-2 HL G. From your writings it came across as the Mac daddy. I really like it. I’ve owned it for a couple months now. Put hundreds of rounds through the firearm it’s mounted on. I don’t find talking it off to change the battery a big deal. It’s almost too bright for indoor use. I really had to train to get used to it. I keep it on the nightstand and every night I point it down the hallway and activate it. The controls are almost automatic. Thumb on the safety, index finger on the light. Presto! Ready to go. I have the laser set to just below the sight picture. Thanks again.
Olight Buyer Beware RE: "Ordering direct"- Their free shipping on orders means you have to go to your post office to retrieve your full priced purchase. I will not order from this company or purchase their products again. it seems small, but it is a petty cost cutting game from their contracted logistics company. My time is worth easily the difference on higher priced products that have been on the market much longer. Olight please, please ship my order to "a post office". I hope I never have to deal with Olight warranty department with the only 2 products I will ever purchase.
I'm leary of Streamlight. I have a TLR-4 that is two years old with less than 500 rounds through my Sig P227 .45. The plastic on the rail mount broke recently. And of course, it was out of warranty by a few days. Either I attempt to fix it with Gorilla Glue, or spend more of my hard-earned cash on something that I shouldn't have to buy again.
I prefer the Olight PL-Mini 2 Valkyrie, over the Streamlight.
Light/laser combos though irritate the heck out of me for use on an AR-15 but its a personal choice thing. All (or at least most of whats worth having) of the light/laser combo's place their lasers in the unit where its farthest away from the rail when the unit is mounted. I like my lasers closer to the rail and thus the bore center line, I like an easy setup parallel zero for a laser. Its why I prefer my small 'mini' lasers like the Crimson Trace CMR-206 or the LaserMax Spartan.
Hey,
Awesome article. Very helpful information for deciding which light to out on my Polymer 80 build (I also used your article on building one to help guide me through the process...thanks again!). However I tried to use you discount code on Amazon for the pl-2 mini and Amazon said it was an invalid code. Maybe it expired? Just checking in to see if you know anything about it.
Thanks!
Hey Andrew, thanks for reading! The code only works at Olight -- not at Amazon.
coat your lens with chapstick before the range. it prevents carbon buildup and wipes off easily.
> complete writeup on pistol lights.
You did not mention the Glock GTL 10 which retails on a major online site for under $90.00. Is it good or bad? I would think Glock's light would be pretty good.
Guess I ain't been buying recently
Could have sworn I wrote something. Oh well. Later guys.
It's honestly difficult taking this comparison seriously when such favoritism is extended towards the Streamlight without mentioning one obvious shortcoming. Such as how difficult (and annoying) it can be to remove the lights from the weapon. You either need a coin or screwdriver permanently at hand or have really long nails to remove/install the screw system and insure a tight fit. The Olights on the other hand are as easy as pie, with the bar (shiny or not). As it relates to the comments I am getting the notion that the recharging system on the Olight is a shortcoming. That might be true for a night class but in any home defense situation you guys are fooling yourselves. I've had an Olight EDC S1R Turbo 2 in my rotation now for nearly a year and it's always had the right amount of juice when needed and has never died on me. One would think that in this smartphone generation we live in now, you would be able to mitigate a simple able charging procedure. On the other hand the Streamlight (and Surefire) have the time tested battery replacements, but keep in mind though that a battery swap is not as easy as a Magazine change. One you have to remove the damn the light, which mentioned above can be a chore in certain situations, and if it fails when in the middle of a class...in the dark...you are in the same situation as you would be with an OLight, only I have a much easier detaching and mounting system to install another full charged light. There is a shortcoming with the Olight (again more research would be beneficial), the battery is internal and not user replaceable, such as it is with my Baton 2. That is a shame, but still not enough for me to leave Team Olight.
Is there any reason to have both a laser and a red dot? Option to shut off laser and use red dot and vice versa?
Sure there is.
A light exists for you to identify a potential target. A laser exists to identify your point of aim.
Completely different, though complimentary, options.
So, if you want to be able to both ID a potential threat and know where your point of aim is (even if, for some reason, your weapon is not at eye level to use the sights), you would want both.
I've been quite impressed with the Tacticon BattleTorch V1. Sturdy, solid lockup, slick and among the lowest profile of lights. I have an Olight PL Mini 2 Valkyrie, and find them to be comparable in function. Especially helpful if you have several pistols to kit out with lights, helps the wallet.
Only complaint is holster compatibility, some holsters for the Olight MIGHT work, but I doubt I would feel comfortable with the probable sloppy retention. I've conversed with a few manufacturers, I'm hopeful options will grow in the coming months/yrs.
Having just come off a low light class with photonic barriers... every pistol light on the market today has huge weaknesses, but PID with a light between you and the target with anything but the 1k TLR1HL or X300U 1k is just not realistic. Candela matters, a lot.
Thank You, someone else who realizes that candela is more important than lumens
I have the Olight mini 1, PL Pro and BALDR Pro and all 3 are great and fit my Glock 19 Gen5 and Sig P220 Legion perfectly!, Yes Olight starts to lose lumens after a few minutes 1500-600 lumens but once you click off and on it resets, which isn’t a problem for 99.9% of situations. Plus both Pro’s have lower 300 lumen setting that will run for 90 minutes by double clicking the switch. They both have a blinding 1500 (PL Pro) 1350 (BALDR Pro) lumen strobe By clicking both levers. Highly recommend lights. Plenty of holsters out now for most Olights.
BALDR mini is next!!
Try the Baldr S
instead of the mini think you will like it better
I have the Olight PL-MINI 2 Valkyrie 600 Lumens running on a FN 509. Also bought a special holster from Hidden Hybrid Holsters. It has fallen off the gun while at target practice 3 times. Once it came off in pieces. Luckily I was able to find all the pieces, after an embarrassing range shut down, so I could put it back together. I'd take this light off your list if I was you. Got any better ideas for my gun and holster.
I completely agree with you... remove this light from your list. Mine fits securely, however it's battery Sucks... they claim 60 minutes... mine is basically unusable in 10 minutes... ok for a bump in the night gun, but why compromise. Get something you can swap batteries quickly if needed instead of waiting for it to recharge.
Great article buttttttt, I would have liked to see either the Olight baldr pro or the Olight baldr RL.All of the lights you chose are top of line for sure. Maybe next time. Anyway, thanks for the continuous good info!!
Great gunlight comparision, you really help me decided what I want to get. Thanks again
Please be more honest and clear about Olights. For example, the PL-MINI 2 Valkyrie does NOT run at 600 lumens for 1 hour. It runs at 600 lumens for ONE minute, then drops to 60 Lumens for 60 minutes. This is under Olight's technical details.
good point.
also, I ran mine in a test and it stayed lit for 1:53:00 minutes until the light went out. Almost 2 hours.
the last 30 minutes was dim but able to be used as a signal.
Recharge took about 45 minutes.
Are those times for the PL2 mini? Mine is so dim after 10 minutes, i wouldn't trust it to quickly identify someone across the room. I still like it because it's rechargable, but it's definitely a bump in the night light. Not something for a duty weapon.
I found a TLR2 at my favorite gun store as a police trade-in. It was brand new in the box. The box had never even been opened. Got it for $150! Check with your local gun stores who do business with the local police.
My TLR2 is mounted on my Springfield lightweight champion in .45 acp and kept by my bedside. I very much like the laser and light combo a feel comfortable that should I ever need it it will serve me well. I have owned it for 4 years and it still works fine.
I found a Streamlight TRL-4 combo that works great on my Sig P227 tactical model. I had an interesting situation the other night where I had to clear my front and back yards and it worked very well. My P227 has tall night sites and I'm having trouble finding a good OWB holster that will accommodate the tall sites and the TRL-4. Any suggestions on where to find a good holster?
Red River Tactical support pretty much every light. Just email their customer service if your particular gun/light combo isn't listed, they'll email you back with instructions. Really great quality and customer service.
Although you wrote this awhile ago I thought I'd mention Slim Fit Holsters.
Wide variety of guns with an impressive,l ability to customize for gun needs including light bearing, special cuts, etc.
Thoughts on the Olight PL-Pro 1500 lumens with pressure switch on an AR?
Was considering the Streamlight pro tac but at 625 lumens outdoors may leave a bit to be desired...
Olights suck... i own 2 and their run times are a complete lie... they are bright, but that does you NO good when you are waiting for it to recharge... buy something that you can swap batteries in if needed...
Klarus GL1 looks like a decent budget option at $69. Like a cheaper version of the Olight
Chris Bony swears by his TLR-1HL coz he's beaten the nuts out of it for about a decade. I'd honestly like to see a really beat up Olight. that will help a lot. thanks
I haven't used an olight for a weapon light until recently,, but I own several of their flashlights and have for years. Abused them and even used one as a pool light for a couple years and they all still work awesome. Hopefully the weapon light milage is similar.
O-lights are made in China
Not to mention that their run times are a complete lie. I tested mine, in less than 10 minutes it is so dim that it is basically worthless. Definitely a bump in the night light.
So are our phones but my phone works fine and I have had 2 pl valkyries fail. They replaced them under warranty. I sold them both. I only use surefire and stream light now. Not a fan of o-light.
So are Streamlights buddy
Glad you guys hopped onboard the Olight train. I have 3 of them on my weapons and several around the house for everyday use. I also have 2 of the Crimson Trace lights on pistols. I like them almost as well. The only downside to the Crimson Trace lights is that they don't quick detach like my Olights.
The APLc is discontinued. You need to update this list.
Everyone is dumping the TLR-7 for the TLR-7A with much better switching. You need to update this list.
You're not going to melt your face off with a 1000 lumen light. Get some training. We haven't gotten to "too many lumens."
My 1350 lumen, 54,000 candela PLHv2 Modlite is great indoors, and it's more powerful than any current production pistol light.
“The paddle activation system is also my favorite out of all the pistol lights. Easy to reach for both hands and perfectly textured.” Exactly why I started using Inforce APLc.
Any thoughts on the Olight baldr pro with green laser?
I bought it during Black Friday for 100 dollars. Honestly I’d skip the idea of a laser altogether. No matter who is making it. I thought it would make a big difference in aiming but I’m still way better with the sights. And I’m not that great anyway. Just get a rechargeable Valkyrie Pro. I have that and a mini Valkyrie and I love them.
One other thing. I’m a lefty and it has been harder to find holsters for Olights. They are out there and the market is starting to respond to demand but not everyone makes them yet.. So if you have anything less than a Glock or M&P it might be harder to find a holster. That being said I did find the two holsters I needed.
O light mini-2 Valkyrie on a Glock 17....Love it!!! Glad you finally added to your listings.
So some advise for practicing with your light on your weapon. Instead of using tape to cover the light just put a drop of oil on the lens and spread it out. When you are done shooting just wipe it off.
You recommend the APLc and you mention that a year ago Insight said they had fixed the problems with the APL (and that you would follow up with an update after trying the replacement they were sending you -- although I don't see any update).
My own experience is only with the APLc.... which has been an unmitigated disaster.
Feb 2, 2020, I bought my INFORCE APLc compact weapons light from a usually reliable vendor (NOT Amazon which seems to be flooded with fakes of this light). It arrived quickly, properly packaged, and in absolutely perfect condition except for one small problem, IT DOESN'T WORK. This light is definitely a real INFORCE light, with all proper markings and genuine INFORCE packaging and documentation. It is also very bright -- when it works, but that's where the problems come....
Constant mode does not work at all. To turn the light on in constant mode you are supposed to tap and release either paddle. When I tap and release either paddle this light does NOTHING.
Momentary mode works occasionally. To turn the light on in momentary mode you are supposed to press and hold either paddle for more than 1/2 second. The light should stay on as long as you press the paddle and go off when you release the paddle. My brand new APLc light does that - sometimes! Maybe half the time, momentary mode works as it should. The rest of the time it doesn't. Either the light flashes once for a very short time or it does nothing at all.
I called the vendor immediately. The gentleman who answered the phone listened to my description of the problem and agreed that it obviously wasn't supposed to do that. He asked if I wanted a refund or exchange, and I told him that I would try an exchange. He directed me to their website to submit a return request. I submitted the return request before going out to do some errands. By the time I got home, my return shipping label was waiting in my email. I will be mailing this light back tomorrow, and hopefully the replacement will work better. If this light had worked the way it is supposed to, it would definitely be a 5-star light, but for a weapon light it's pretty much all or nothing.
---
Here's the update after I returned the light reviewed above and received another one from the same seller (Primary Arms).
Again the light arrived quickly and well packaged. Again the light was in perfect condition with no hint of any sort of damage. Again, the light and all the packaging appear to be 100% genuine. AND AGAIN THE LIGHT DOES NOT WORK!
If anything, this one is even worse than the first one. Both modes at least do appear to work (somewhat) BUT once the light is on for more than about half a second it begins to flicker, sometimes it flickers brightly (almost like a strobe except that the flicker is uneven) other times it flickers very dimly, then it will go out completely, then flash a few times, then flicker some more.
This light will be going back too, but this time it will be for a refund. I'm not going to bother having them send me yet another of these garbage lights.
Bro, the Olight Pl-mini 1 needed to be on this list. The Pl-mini 2 needs to be on the updated list. I still love my Pl-mini. Having a magnetic charging capability adds to the "reliability" part of owning a WML; the battery is always topped off.
So true just got mine last week from big daddy unlimited for62 bucks and just got an email that they back in stock about to order 1 more lol can’t go wrong believe me
Yup, Olights added finally!
Olight. Hard to believe there could be a "BEST" list for 2019 without including them as anything more than a footnote. I have several and they've all been excellent, reliable and durable.
It's hard to include all the worthy competitors when you start your list with the entire Surefire catalog. But he certainly could have made room for Olight (or any other light) by dropping the worthless Insight light(s) from the list.
Olight FTW!
That magnetic recharging method is so convenient!
I'm rocking the PL-Mini Valkyrie 1 on my G19.
The TLR-2 HL is 800 lumens, not 300
I have a hard time understanding how you could review the TLR7/8 and not mention how difficult it is to reach the switch.
I wear size L to XL gloves and can not reach the switch from a natural shooting position on my G19. If you look at the photos and pay attention to where the toggle switches on the TLR 1 and the insight lights are compared to where they are on the TLR7, it becomes obvious.
The TLR7 / 8 are excellent quality lights that have ergonomics that won't work for 90% of shooters.
Definitely another vote for Olight. They really made a name for themselves with the Mini, and blew up. Solid pistol light, and at a great price. Plus good customer service. I'd love to see an article trying them all out.
I'm just going to add my 2¢. You really should try the offerings from olight, because they're all pretty great.
I just bought the Olight mini 2 with a holster that fits for glock 19 and my next purchase will be the rail by recover tactical that fits glock 26 and can take the olight mini 2 as well. So you see where my vote is going...
Another vote for olight mini here. Have it on my m&p 9 2.0 and love it.
Here one more thumbs up for the O-light Mini. It mostly lives on my Glock 30S but occasionally visits my 19. Easy on, easy off, very light, long battery life, easy magnetic recharge, which I had reservations about, but has worked really well. On top of that, it's inexpensive. Now if I could just get my holster company to make their "LightTuck" holster in Glock 30S with O-Light mini, I'd be in 'hog heaven".
Get a heatgun and reshape the "LightTuck" holster yourself. That's what I did.
you ever test out the inforce in the update?
Guys I think you may have missed a great option. O-Light Valkyrie Lite is a super little light that’s no-tool-required attached and detached from any Glock or Picatinny rail. Recharge by USB = no batteries! I have it on my Sig P320 and my wife has it on her Glock 19. Great add on for home defense.
The link for the SureFire X300 Ultra takes you to what appears to be a "knock off" or replica light based on the reviews.
What are the activation/toggle differences between Surefire and Streamlight?
Add another vote for the O-Light Mini Valkyrie, awesome little light
About the only negative I can think of is the quick detach pivot point sticks out a little bit more then it necessarily needs to, but that is a very minor negative!
Thanks Bobo, I'll chalk up another one to Olight.
I'm leaning towards getting the Olight Pl-Mini Valkyrie. Talon Sei just did a review of it on YouTube. It's small, easy detach, bright, and has a built in rechargeable battery.
Thanks, lots of love for Olight...I've added them to the honorable mentions and will be sure to check them out soon.
As far as cleaning the lens, I suggest using steel wool, it will not scratch or damage the lens.. The carbon comes off easily with next to no effort. I then place a drop of gun oil on the lens and rub it in. The next time you shoot you can use your finger to wipe the carbon off.
Thanks, Monica...will try soon!
Check out the Olight Valkyrie PL-2. 1200 lumens for $100. It's only 3 1/2 inches long. Fits my S&W Core and Sig P-320 nicely. Have about 400 rounds, so far no problems
Nice, another vote for Olight...I'll check them out soon.
Viridian CL5 light & green laser combo is still my choice.
Thanks for sharing, Chip!
Viridian on the kimber. Small reliable. Well worth the price.
Have you looked at the Olight brand lights? Such as the Olight PL-MINI, 400 lumens.
I've heard of them but haven't tried any of their pistol lights...will do for the update.