Not sure what pistol to get for your first gun or for home defense?
We’ll cover all the important decision points, such as caliber, ammo, size, ergonomics, price, and safety.
And then end it with some in-depth info on our personal suggestions.
We also cover this topic ands more in our video course, Gun Noob to Gun Slinger. Only the most important handgun knowledge to get you competent in 2 hours.
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Overall Beginner Handgun
-
Best Trigger
-
Runner-Up Beginner Handgun
-
Easiest to Rack & Load
-
Best Higher-End Beginner Handgun
-
Best Beginner Revolver
Table of Contents
Loading…
How We Tested the Best Beginner & Home Defense Handguns
This article is a meta-analysis based on our experience with hundreds of handguns and tens of thousands of rounds over the years at Pew Pew Tactical.
We first chose our criteria for a “beginner” handgun that we expand upon in the How To Choose section.
- 9mm
- Full or Compact Size
- Striker-Fired
- Around $500
We then polled the editors and writers to see their top beginner handguns that met the criteria and that we have at least 2,500 rounds tested. However, you’ll see several have round counts even higher than that.
We also include a link to a full hands-on review of each handgun so you get all the details.
Best Beginner Home Defense Handguns
Best Overall 9mm Pistol – Glock 19, Gen 5
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Endlessly reliable and proven
- Great overall size
- Good capacity
- Lots of upgrades available
Cons
- Stock plastic sights
- Trigger could be better
- Ergonomics not for everyone
Everyone and their mom has heard of Glock.
It is a polymer gun, kind of boring but ultra-reliable. If I had the choice of only taking a random pistol into a situation…this would be it.
Lots of other people think the same way…that’s why the compact Glock 19 is their best-selling 9mm since it’s a Jack-of-All-Trades.
The newest Gen 5 Glocks are out.
For those of you in handgun-restricted states like California…Gen 3 is fine, too.
If you don’t plan on concealed carrying…I would opt for the Glock 17 full-size (which we’ve run over 10,000 rounds by this point).
But, if you are going to go the concealed carry weapon (CCW) route or want something slightly smaller…try out the Glock 19.
We now have a 3,500 round-count full review of the Glock 19 Gen 5…complete with shooting videos!
Again…if I had to recommend one beginner handgun…it’d be the Glock 19. Great for the range, your nightstand, and on your body for concealed carry.
What’s your take on the Glock 19?
Best Trigger – Walther PDP
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Best trigger for for the price
- Very reliable
- Very ergonomic
Cons
- Big hands can cause slide to not lock back
The Walther PDP might be our newest favorite striker-fired 9mm handgun with its exceptional trigger, ergonomics, and reliability.
You’ll have to take our word on the trigger…but it’s the nicest out-of-the-box striker-fired trigger we’ve ever felt.
For the ergonomics…Walther made it extra grippy with nice molding that fit the gamut of hand sizes on our team.
And since it’s red dot ready…there’s also a nice pinky extension that helps you grip a little downwards which makes it perfect for red dots.
And check out the chunky (but super effective) slide serrations. If you can’t get a grip on it for racking…it ain’t the slide’s problem!
There are also a couple of different grip sizes and barrel lengths…but we went with the popular combos of full size with a 4.5-inch barrel and a compact with a 4-inch barrel.
Reliability is awesome, with Sean having shot over 5,000+ rounds and carried it as his duty pistol as a peace officer before he joined Pew Pew Tactical.
However, if you have giant mitts like Sean, you might not get 100% slide lock-back on empty mags because your fingers hit the slide lock.
Threaded barrels are coming out now, and so far, we’ve had great success with a suppressed compact version.
Check out the full review.
As well as our YouTube video review:
Runner-Up Beginner Handgun – Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Very reliable and proven
- Good ergonomics
The latest version of the venerable M&P (military and police) is the M&P 2.0. If there’s a list of best 9mm handguns, this usually makes the top three.
I got the FDE color version…
It’s full-size, and here is the comparison of my 1.0 vs a full-size Glock 17.
The original version was rock solid but had a not-so-great trigger.
The M2.0 takes care of that and also adds a more aggressive texturing while still maintaining the ability to swap out palm swells to match your grip.
It fits very well in my hand, and although I currently have the model with the safety…it’s easy to take off and get some inserts for the holes (and makes it exactly like the non-safety version).
A good choice to see if you agree with my thoughts on safeties since you can choose either option.
I choose it as my runner-up best beginner 9mm handgun since it’s been super reliable and a joy to shoot. However, is edged out by the Glock for reputation.
Be sure to check out our full review of the M&P M2.0 as well.
Easiest to Rack & Load – Smith & Wesson M&P Shield EZ
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Great for weaker hands
- Also comes in softer shooting .380 ACP
Cons
- Lower capacity
Have a little trouble racking the slide on most handguns?
Check out the M&P Shield EZ line — “EZ” stands for easy racking and easy loading.
The 9mm version is very concealable and packs a decent punch with our favorite caliber.
But if you want the absolute easiest racking and easiest shooting…opt for the smaller caliber version in .380 ACP.
However, one big negative of the EZ series is the reduction in shooting capacity down to 8+1. Compare this to the 15+1 of the Glock 19.
Check out our full review, as well as our YouTube video, to really see the differences in racking and shooting vs. other pistols:
Best Higher-End Beginner Handgun – HK VP9
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
HK’s VP9 is a great alternative if you want a polymer pistol but don’t want the Glock look/feel. Or if you’re feeling a little fancy.
It used to be much more expensive but has recently gone down to only be slightly above Glock prices.
Chambered in 9mm, the VP9 is a striker-fired design measuring 7.34 inches in total length with a 4.09-inch barrel. It tips scales at around 25 ounces.
The VP9 ships with various backstraps and interchangeable side panels that should allow those with even the most atypical paws to find a combination that works for them.
It’s also endlessly reliable and proven.
This one is around the 3,000 round mark and now lives in a quick-access safe in the house.
Note that the standard model has a different magazine release location under the trigger. Get the B model for a more standard location.
For more details on the VP9, check out our full review or peep the video below.
That rounds out our 9mm suggestions for beginners, but you can check out our larger Best 9mm Pistols article for more.
Best Beginner Revolver – Smith & Wesson Model 686+
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Plus model has 7 round capacity
- Beefy build soaks up recoil
- More simple operation
Cons
- Much slower reloading
Here’s the revolver you’ve been waiting for…the S&W Model 686+.
The + means it holds 7 rounds instead of the standard 6 rounds you’ve come to expect from revolvers.
I like the 4-inch barrel since it’s the Goldilocks length…not so short that it’s difficult to control in firing, but not so long that it’s unwieldy.
A short “why revolvers?” They are dead simply. They don’t need magazines and if there’s a misfire you can just pull the trigger again to cycle to the next round.
Plus, it will shoot both .38 Special and the more powerful .357 Magnum rounds.
Here it is in .38 Special…very manageable with the barrel. Perfect for recoil-sensitive people and training.
And here it is in the .357 Magnum…more powerful but still not too bad with a good grip.
And now…a full review!
How to Choose a Beginner Handgun
9mm Caliber
There’s a lot of popular calibers including the 9mm and larger .45 ACP that you’ll see recommended for a beginner pistol.
However, we drill down and recommend getting a 9mm for your beginner handgun.
Why?
The 9mm is easier to find and cheaper to shoot when compared to other calibers.
Its smaller size means it has milder recoil and higher capacity magazines (usually 15+).
Here’s me shooting one of my top suggested handguns…the Glock 19.
Not too bad…right?
Plus, the majority of police forces use 9mm, and the FBI returned to the 9mm after finding that the current .40 S&W rounds were causing excessive wear on pistols and were less easily controlled by some agents.
Hollow Point Ammo for Self-Defense
For home defense purposes, we recommend hollow point bullets for their stopping power (and ability to stop in drywall).
Two of the most popular are Speer Gold Dot and Federal Hydrashok. We cover everything in our Best 9mm Ammo article.
Fit
The most important thing about choosing the best handgun is fit.
We recommend getting a “full size” handgun, which means close to 5-inch barrels.
Having a full-sized handgun makes it easier to shoot since there’s more mass to absorb recoil, a larger area to grip, and a longer sight radius from the front sight to the rear sight.
But…if you think you might do concealed carry in the future and don’t want to get another gun…you can try out the compact sizes too.
You lose a little sight radius but free up some grip space which helps a lot in concealing. But you don’t want to go so small that your pinkie is left hanging.
Safety
Here, we recommend a lack of an external safety.
WHAT?
We believe that the mind is the best safety and that in the heat of the moment, during a self-defense situation, you might forget to disengage the safety.
This takes out a couple of possibilities, including the venerable 1911, which we think is a little too complicated and finicky for the beginner shooter.
Sights
Easy…get the tritium night sights since most self-defense encounters occur in dimly lit locations.
There are usually night sight models for each of our recommended pistols. And they’ll look like regular white dot sights during the day.
Or you can always purchase aftermarket sights and have your gunsmith install them.
Action
We recommend a striker-fired handgun for the beginner and home defense since the trigger pull is nearly identical every time (at least when compared to a double-action).
An easy way to tell if a handgun is a striker is that the back of the slide is flat and has no exposed hammer.
Double-action pistols such as the Beretta 92FS have a heavy first shot since you are cocking back the hammer.
What about revolvers?
We love them for their reliability and ease of dealing with malfunctions (just press again), but we don’t like their low ammo capacity (5 or 6 compared to 15+ for our recommendations).
But we’ll be including one of our favorites that packs in seven rounds of .38 Special or .357 Magnum goodness.
Price
The prices are all pretty similar for the striker-fired pistols at around the $500 range. You’ll also be able to find some sales going on at your local gun store…but these are good starting prices.
Night sights will probably cost $50 to $100 more.
Best Handgun Accessories
Again, most encounters happen in dimly lit areas/times, and you wouldn’t want to shoot with just night sights without verifying your target.
So we use and recommend a light that attaches to the rail.
The one we recommend is the Streamlight TLR–1 HL which comes with a bright light and great value.
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
It’s survived thousands of rounds, being dropped on the ground numerous times, and full days of shooting in heavy rain.
You might see some cheaper lights here or there, but lights are not the place to cheap out on.
And for the person who wants the best of the best light only…the Surefire X300.
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
We go over all these lights and more in our Best Pistol Lights article.
I’m also a fan of lots of grip on your gun. Talon Grips is the perfect non-permanent solution.
And of course…besides your gun and ammo you’ll need some eye and ear protection.
We at Pew Pew Tactical have spec-ed and sourced our own that we believe are the pinnacle of comfort and protection…enter ShellShock Protection.
If you’re looking for an upgraded kit with electronic ear protection that amplifies sounds you want to hear (like people talking) while cutting off gun shots…check out the Premium Combo. Also comes with switchable lens ballistic eye glasses.
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Check out more of our favorites in Best Shooting Hearing Protection and Best Shooting Glasses.
Final Thoughts
- 9mm
- Hollowpoint defensive ammo
- Full-size frame
- Striker fired
- Night sights
- Rail mounted light
- Try out the feel of the Glock 17/19, M&P9, and PDP
Of course, there are a bazillion pistols that I left out…but the above specs are what we at Pew Pew Tactical recommend.
Already got a self-defense pistol? Learn how to become a crack shot. Or ready to check out our Beginner Handgun Course? Not sure if pistols are right for you? Check out our Best Home Defense Gun article where we go over the pros and cons of Handguns vs Shotguns vs Rifles.
LATEST UPDATES
April 14, 2024 – Added How We Test and additional information for each choice.
October 26, 2023 – Cleaned up list, added galleries, and added specific categories.
412 Leave a Reply
Too big, for a beginner. .22LR, preferably a revolver, unless you only want to hit the target once. Shoot that for a year, then move up to bigger calibres. A .32 calibre semi-auto is good, if they have some understanding of weapon functions. It's best to get 6 on-target than just fling 'em nearby. After they start complaining "I need more power", then go to .38 or 9mm. I think the best solution is a loaded Taurus 85, you don't have to think about anything; just pick it up, aim and pull the trigger.
you are all wrong, its a 22LR, if they never shot before and how much have they shot before and with what. my go to pistol is a 45acp shot from a Caspipara double stack, used in competition for 12 years. so as a trainer the 22LR it the best. 9 is ok but when i got my first 9 a EMP, when i shot it i was surprised it had a bite to it, for a beginner it might be a little maybe to much, if you use the 147 gr bullet it will have less felt recoil. if they have some experience the Glock 19 is a good choice
Sorry, Babe,
CZ P10-C all day long !
I like your choices but a better runner up would be the S&W M&P 2.0 Compact because it's better than the Block 19 Gen 5.
CZ P10-C is favored by experts over the Glock alternatives. You should try one.
why not the springfield armory 9mm echelon?
I think you forgot all about all the slim line guns that are out now Smith & Wesson shield 365 Glock 43X 48 You did get the shield easy in there. But you missed Ruger. Canik the Walther PP. Those guns you mentioned to me are more duty guns to be worn in holsters by law-enforcement. Thanks for creating pew pew tactical.
Most self defense situations come as a complete surprise and are usually over in 15 seconds. And at less than 20 feet.
If you're not a daily user/handler of your weapon of choice that you keep on your nightstand, you hear a noise, grab your pistol , all the while your mind is racing, what did I hear?, where was it?, what could cause it?. It's a lot to process. All the while trying to remember if the SA pistol that you haven't held in 2 weeks is loaded, is the safety on, is there a round in the chamber?, is the magazine in all the way?, is it full?
Now, on the other hand when you grab your revolver, all you have to think about is the immediate situation ( if you don't know if your revolver is loaded you shouldn't have a pistol). I keep a Taurus 85 next to my bed. If I haven't resolved the situation with five rounds, eleven more aren't going to help.
I don't know I think the mp shield plus is a really good gun...
Which pistol do you recommend for a beginner living in California?
Glock gen 3,..9 ml.
It depends on your hand size and what do you want to do with the pistol? I recommend you go to a gun show and pick up and feel every gun that you like and stick with the big or the big five. Good luck.
Well done list, y'all are living my dream job!
My $0.02?
My ex wife loved my cz-75 p01 so much she tried to get it in the divorce!
Better luck getting my pick up truck...
She's a dinky Lil thang with weak-ish hands that didnt grow up with handguns but she could run that CZ like an bottomless bank account.
I miss her, my truck and my dog but my cz-75 will always be at my side.
I am guessing none of the people in the article are approaching 80 or have hand issues like arthritis or other disabilities. I would simply suggest that people look closely at their physical abilities and do some real thinking about what they need not what some vendor thinks they need.
Issues like how to break contact and how to fortify your home are going to be more important that having newest whiz-bang gun. For instance compare your shooting budget to the price of ammo. You do realize you need to practice. The difference between ammo prices and getting enough practice might be an economic factor that would influence your choice. Life isn't simple and there is no easy button, but making Glock's or Smith & Wesson's bottom line better is not going to make you safer.
Ruger makes some nice revolvers. Period. LCR. They have one in 327 that hold 6 rounds They’re a little pricey, but you only buy it once. Also Smith and Wesson and Taurus has some nice revolvers even charter arms. Just depends on your price range.
You know, I got the impression from this writing that this discussion about a home defense firearm was all about the writer and their preference! It had nothing to do with a person's ability to manipulate a semi- auto pistol, how much practice they will put in to get to know how to use it then religiously continue that all the time. I don't think that someone will care if they have 15 rounds of ammunition if they can't even manipulate the firearm when needed in their fear of an intruder. You showed no basic interest or even really bothered to give a revolver justice as even though it may only have 5 or six or seven rounds, however if it works can be manipulated and fired when needed then that's what counts. Article could have been less biased toward revolvers and I feel more thought put into all those looking for a home self defense firearm that may only pick it up once or twice a year. I could go on and on but unnecessary. I think you get my drift.......
I exclusively carry and use Double action/Single Action (DA/SA) pistols, but I have nothing against striker fired guns.
However, I want beginners to beaware of the safety issues with most striker fires pistols: There are virtually no safety features on most striker guns. And, unlike DA guns, most striker guns have a pre-cocked striker. This means that if anything causes the striker to fall, it will cause the weapon to fire. The only exception to this is Glock, because Glock strikers are only partially cocked (this is why they are 100% drop safe). Glocks are the only striker gun I'd ever carry.
Full agreement on all! I have a Glock 27 for backup. But I usually carry a Sig P239 in 357 Sig for backup or if the attire limits me from carrying my P226.
The "Best Handgun for Beginners & Home Defense" is the one in your hand when you need it the most for defense. If the gun is suitable for the defense or you, or not, is another question.
But there is no doubt that when you stop the threat with what ever handgun you have available at the time, no matter if its the latest-n-greatest on the market, no matter if its decked out with accessories or not, no matter if its one of the better known handguns or not, there is no doubt that if you stop the threat with it then it will be the best handgun there ever was.
Which gun had the best trigger, (aka the Walther or the H&K)?
Canik also has great triggers. You can probably find less expensive Canik models vs. the Walther, but either are really good guns. I have both and they are reliable and shoot well.
I have 2 of the models listed, M&P2, and 686 plus, and they are excellent. Relatively new shooter, and left handed, but very happy with these recommendations.
Haven't seen much reviewing of Springfield lines. I have a XDM in .45, and it makes a real improvement in my range scores.
I’ve been around a long time and have had a CCW for years. I’ve tried numerous guns from numerous manufacturers. I’ve gone with expensive and middle of the road. My two favorites are the Glock 43x and the Glock 19 Gen 5. I did a couple upgrades that I think are extremely important. First, I chose Glock because I pull the trigger and it works every time with any manufacturers ammo. I replaced the the triggers on both. I put a Timney trigger kit on my 19 and an Apex trigger on my 43x . I upgraded the recoil spring in both guns. The factory sites on Glocks I think need to be upgraded as well. I use a Holosun Red Dot on my 19. I did the upgrades myself but there are plenty of gunsmiths out there that can do them.
I bought my S&W 686+ just before the 2016 election. Since then, I have called it my "Hillary gun", for obvious reasons. Regardless of my timing, it is just about the best firearm buy I have ever made. I chose to "split the baby" by purchasing in 3" bbl. It is satisfactorily accurate, while still adequately absorbing recoil. Plus (as in +), at my size (XL) I can effectively conceal it unaffected by its weight.
I really like the M&P 2.0 series, especially with the new trigger that comes with the optics ready version. I have a 5” full size for HD, and a 4” compact for carry. Saving up for a Shield plus for EDC, since the compact is a bit large for carrying in the Summer months. I think it’s a big benefit to have the same (or similar) platform for HD and carry, since the ergonomics, grip angle, and trigger will be very similar.
Honestly you need to forget about these cheap guns. Save your money and get a Sig Sauer. P365, P320, or the best gun ever , the P226 Navy. You will thank me for the rest of your life. No BS.
I agree that that “cheap” guns are not usually the best (i.e. Hi-point, SCCY, etc.) But I would not categorize brands in this article as “cheap”. I would maintain that Glock and S&W have reputations that are as good (and sometimes better) than Sig Sauer. It’s not like Sig hasn’t had some issues with some models. I would say that all these brands are in the mid to upper range of handguns, and all are very reliable. It’s really just a matter of finding what works best for you.
Eric, try out some Fort Scott TUI sometime. Personally I prefer it but I’d like your opinions as well. Good article as always!
The chances of a negligent discharge with a striker fired pistol for a new shooter are greater due to the absence of a fail safe mechanism (manual safety) and the very light trigger pull (5.6 ft lbs, where a single action 1911 is about 4.5). I have seen negligent discharges from numerous striker fired pistols in my training classes. Sig P320 and Glock primarily, likely because they are the most commonly recommended for new shooters. I train my new shooters on DA/SA pistols else a striker fired with a manual safety. Learning the discipline of the third rule of gun safety: always keep your finger off the trigger until you are ready to shoot takes practice and in a stressed situation may be forgotten. Training the draw and presentation as well as shooting is very important. With 29 states now allowing carry without a permit or training (in some states) the likelihood of a negligent discharge increases. The responsibility lies with the shooter to control the firearm. Training and repetition to build muscle memory are sadly not prioritized by new shooters. With proper, consistent and ongoing training any striker fired pistol can be safe and effective in self defense.
I left a reply saying the same thing. I believe new shooters, especially new concealed carriers, are better off with DA/SA. Any striker gun, other than Glock, has a fully-charged striker that is just waiting to go off . . . . DA may take a little longer to learn, but its far safer. Once you learn DA, you'll be a master of any trigger.
Heritage Rough Rider .22 LR and .22 WMR Combo
After less than 2 years, noticed it shooting left, 3" at 20 feet, Sent it back (they charged $50 just to look at it), said "the firearm frame is out of specs."
Said they could replace it - " the cost would be $150.35." So we wd be then up to $400, for a piece of junk - I said "no thanks, just send it back." I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS REVOLVER.
BEST HANDGUN FOR BEGINNERS ? A BLUE GUN.
BEST 1ST GUN:
ACTUALLY, NOT A REAL GUN
"BLUE GUN" - A SOLID PLASTIC, NON-OPERATIONAL, TRAINING GUN.
A BLUE GUN. OR ORANGE - WHATEVER COLOR.
TEACH MOST ALL FUNDAMENTALS - STANCE, DRAW, GRIP, RETENTION POSITIONS, SIGHT ALIGNMENT, USE OF GUN MOUNTED LIGHT, ETC
"BEST" - 1ST "ACTUAL" GUN - A FULL SIZE, MAJOR MFG GUN : SMITH, SPRINGFIELD, SIG, ETC. DEPENDS ON INTENDED USE - HOME DEFENSE, COMPETITION, CONCEAL CARRY, ETC
Well done, and without any of Pew Pew’s BRAVO SIERRA. A blue gun is the only way to go from “Gun Noob to Gun Slinger in 2 hours.”
As much as I detest saying this, I truly hope that some attorney sees this statement and shuts Eric up for life. What arrogance!
Good list! I just bought a first gun for my daughter, age 54. It's a Kimber 357 Combat with a 4 inch barrel. She's shot my Kimber, my 380 EZ, a variety of my 22s, both semi and revolvers, lr and mag, and her brother's 9mm 1911.
She prefers revolvers and the Kimber da trigger is the best I've ever seen on any stock revolver. The gun weighs 29 oz, so 38 spl ammo is a breeze to shoot. It fits her hand like a glove and the balance is perfect.
Don't poo poo the revolvers. The full-sized da ones are not the most difficult guns to learn to shoot anymore.
“We recommend a lack of a safety”.
We bought a Glock 26, because the gun store clerk recommended it. That gun has sat in a drawer at home because it has no external safety. We since bought other guns that have safeties, and they are part of our EDC rotation.
It’s a matter of training.
Dealing with a majority of people who likely to be fairly new to firearms, Eric and his mob make all sorts of glib statements.
Fifty-five years ago, my first handgun was a Colt Model 1911 — equipped with an external safety: I have trained with one ever since, and my training includes “safety off” just after the pistol is pulled up from the holster and rotated to the horizontal: I’m ready to shoot at that point, about .6 seconds after beginning. My first shot is aimed vertically next to my chest, and my adjustment of horizontal aim is controlled by rotating my body: from this “close-quarters” position, I can get my first shot off under 1 second… without shooting myself because I have no external safety (my pistol is safely pointed down range when the safety comes off).
Perhaps some of Pew Pew’s bravado would be silenced if the statistics were published about how many people shoot themselves or others with a pistol NOT equipped with an external safety versus those that happen with firearm equipped with an external safety… or the statistics are revealed from those studies.
I train with hundreds of others every year that have pistols equipped either no-external safety or with eternal safety: I’ve never noticed any difference in the cadence of gunfire between those two different types of weapons. It’s a matter of habit and proper training, not some BRAVO SIERRA opinion of one of the Pew Pew’s mob: you fight like you train, and train like you fight. Establish the habit and it stays with you if you are current in your training proficiency.
Personal note: I prefer carrying cocked-and-locked, one in the pipe and safety engaged. In this condition, I can draw and fire my pistol accurately with a head shot a 21 feet in under 1.6 seconds. For those that carry a pistol with no external safety, you have a choice as to whether or not to carry with one-in-the-pipe: a number of police departments have purchased Glocks — only to divest themselves due to negligent discharges coming out of the holster with a pistol carrying one-in-the-pipe; in two cases recently, the police officer died of a fatal leg wound (in one case, on the scene; in the other, the officer reached the hospital in time to be treated but died of successive organ failure due to exsanguination).
The easiest personal protection gun to teach a woman who has never shot a pistol before is the Glock 17. That opinion is from teaching a great many to shoot. The easiest pistol to teach a more experienced shooter to shoot during combat traing is guess what? A Glock 17! The handgun or other firearm that has the greatest probability of failing when it is most needed is one with a "safety". I can not tell you how many times I have had a student fail the first shot in training due to having the safety engaged, but it is many hundreds of times. I can also tell you from actual experience that under real stress (EVEN less than than actual combat) many supposed highly trained soldiers and police people fail to disengage their safety for several seconds when attempting to fire them. But in the end, if the weapon is for self-defence the best one to have is the one that is with you when you NEED it. And sometimes that is something small such as a glock 43X or the Kahr P9! While Im carry a Glock 17 when expecting real danger (I believe it is the finest combat pistol still after more than 30 years of carrying one!) but often still carry either the G43X OR the P9 when concealment is necessary. Such as when it is really hot and light clothes are needed. That means that the best pistol to train someone to shoot well is a Glock17 and after that, a Glock 43X is a good one to follow due to its familiar sight, feel, and trigger. Small people and women love that G43. My 12-year-old grandson shoots one in an unbelievable way when I allow him to come play with the big boys.
There is little difference in the grip size of Glocks, and — while I appreciate that perhaps your experience has varied from mine — I’ve found since the late 1980s (when Glocks in my experience began becoming popular) that many women simply had too much trouble getting their index finger properly positioned on the trigger.
I started teaching 1975 with a Colt Mk IV Srs 70 — and found that the majority of my students were able to handle the pistol without problem. You’re no doubt going to take that as a challenge and will no matter what I write.
With regard to problems with a firearm’s external safety (if equipped), I’ve found that’s more a symptom of instructor inexperience, ignorance, and/or incompetence: students revert to their earliest training when facing significant duress; from a human factors standpoint, they freeze due to the “NUT” factor of confrontations… it’s something that is New, Unfamiliar, and Threatening, and training out these factors is the responsibility of a competent instructor. Training a student to take the safety OFF during a firearm’s presentation, done with thousands of repetitions beginning with their very first experience eliminates future problems. While I appreciate that you have a brand loyalty to Glock, I’ve found in 49 years of experience teaching that starting my students with a firearm equipped with an external safety doesn't cause problems if they should subsequently choose to purchase one (like a Glock) that doesn’t… however, the reverse is usually not true. (There are volumes written about this process in industrial psychology, so if you want to look up the process, there’s s lifetime of reading about a principle written in blood, so to speak.)
I'm a little puzzled of the relationship of buying a gun, hand gun or rifle, by mail order. I understand that it has to be shipped to a FFL dealer, but how do dealers feel about a mail order gun? What do they get out of it? Do you need to clear the background check and have an arrangement before placing a mail order? Thanks, Mel
l
You pay a fee to the FFL for the service. You do your background check when you pick up your gun at the FFL, which means that if you fail the background check, the gun you have bought and paid for sits in limbo at the FFL.
I guess I'm speaking out of turn since I didn't see the weapons but the Ruger LCP Max 380 and Max 9 are excellent choices. The 380 12 shot for the ladies and the 12 shot Max9 for the Gents. The Max 9 and 380 both come in at less than 20 ounces fully loaded. The 380 slips easily into your pocket, the max 9 a little tighter but not bad. Anyway, something to consider.
For home defense, I would like to have a Smith and Wesson 686+ or a Ruger GP 100. A big stainless steel revolver is pretty scary looking to a home invader. I would also like to have a pocket gun in my pants pocket, along with some extra ammo for the revolver, so that if I happen to run out of ammo from shooting the revolver, I will still be in the fight.
I have the GP100, but was looking at the Redhawk, too, which has 8 rounds.
I’m no beginner but an excellent run down. My duty gun is the M&P with sure fire light and serves double duty at home.
I am a 64 yr old woman. I have a 9mm automatic luger. I can barely pull the slide back. I need a small gun (I live in a state that you can open carry without a permit). I am thinking a revolver possibly? I am not sure. Any ideas.
Sig P238. Small gun, very easy to load and pull the slide back. Lots of women rave about this gun. It's a .380, not a 9mm. See if you can rent one at a local range, to try it out.
I have also read that the Smith and Wesson EZ series is just that -- Easy to manipulate. It's also said to be very accurate.
M&p - Shield - EZ - Smith & Wesson
The Ruger Security .308 is an excellent weapon for much easier racking of the slide and .308 ammo has less recoil than a 9mm. It is a great weapon for women and people with arthritic hands. Also, you will be more likely to hit what you point at than when using a 9mm. It is an excellent defensive weapon but not one you will use to hit targets at 100 yards.
Just to clarify, .308 above should read .380. And I fully agree, I have one and like it very much. I recommend others try the Ruger Security 380 literack AND the S&W 380 EZ, one of them will fit your hand great and shoot better for you. Each has its pros and cons (mostly pro's) but one or the other does fit better for some than the other.
I think your selections are reasonable. I have an early Glock 22 (.40 S&W) which is reliable but I don't like its ergonomics. The grip angle is too steep and the Glock points high with my regular hold. If I close my eyes and bring a Sig P226, CZ-85 or S&W 686 to shooting position, when I open my eyes, the sights are very close to proper registry. The Glock 22 invariably points high. In addition, the Glock grip feels like a block in my hand. Consequently, I never bought a Glock 17, although the grip on later generation Glocks fit my hand a bit better. Thanks for the article. Joe
Glock Glock gloooooooock. If you’re beginning in this day and age, go a Ruger Security 9 or Taurus G series. Both are cheap enough that if you don’t like That gun you feel bent over, but yet they’re tough enough- and each has a lifetime warranty to keep them if you like. Plus you can get them in compact for CC also. Aaaaaand, like I said half the price of Glock. Whoever has had a bad Ruger? And now that Taurus has that ex Walther executive, he’s turning them around.
Didn't know about Taurus. Thanks for the tip ànd thanks for the article from a newbie.
Ive been shooting pistols/revolvers for 5 decades... tried many just to be trying them. In the last few years I bit it and tried Glock.. the lack of a safety took some getting used to but I've learned caution and carry only in trigger-protective holsters. My latest is a G19 and it has pretty much replaced my Browning HP (not an easy thing to do!) as my carry piece... After a lifetime of all steel/metal pistols the plastic takes a bit of getting used to but so far no complaints and the G19 is THE world's most popular pistol for law enforcement and civilian carry... There are others of course and it doesnt fit some of the niches a revolver does, (woods carry and wild animal defense is still a revolver's job) but for me the G19 does what I
need in a semi-auto pistol.
the walther pdp is so much better than the glock 19 that until glock can make a pistol that shoots like the pdp i will never own another one.
I might be old school but hammer fired handguns are better for beginners. They give new shooters better clues as to the safe condition of the gun. It’s easier to feel and see the hammer something not readily apparent with a striker fired handgun. Remember we are discussing beginners.
I'm a beginner and for my first gun I went with a revolver, a .357 Ruger GP100. I love it. So much fun to shoot and being able to use .38 ammo for practice is great. I also have a Glock 9mm and I don't find it nearly as fun to shoot. I have a concealed carry permit but don't carry yet. Still learning to get comfortable with guns.
I'm the same as you. I have a glock 43 9mm. Have my concealed carry and also took a tactical class. I still don't carry yet as I want to be more comfortable with the gun. Anyone have any suggestions on what would halo me with that. It would be appreciated.
Carry it empty when you are at home. That will get you accustomed to carrying it. At some point you will feel comfortable enough to carry it outside your home, and loaded. Carry it without a round in the chamber if that helps. Perhaps the lack of a thumb safety makes you uncomfortable. If so, get a gun with a thumb safety.
It just takes time. You will get comfortable carrying. At some point you will be uncomfortable not carrying!
“At some point you will be uncomfortable not carrying”! Boy howdy, if this isn’t true then I don’t know what is!
Glock Glock Glock Glock Glock! I don’t get the whole Glock thing. I’m sorry.
Dito...
a glock 9mm for a first gun for beginers? sorry but I take exception. The glock is a far more advanced pistol due to it's safetys. I own 4 so i know about the safe action BS. I gotta go witha revolver, 32-38 or a 1911 due to its better trigger, beter safety's more weight to handle recoil.
I agree with you except the 1911 for beginners part. For many would-be shooters the 1911 in .45acp might be a bridge too far as a first gun (recoil/noise, size/weight... I gotta go with either a .22 or .38/.357 as a firstie...
Eric I’m surprised you did not include the Beretta 92FS . I used this gun as my service weapon while in the US Coast Guard. The Beretta is very accurate and holds 18 rounds, 19 if you keep one in the chamber. My Beretta 92FS has the safety/decocker. I have added a TDI accessory rail and an Olight 800 lumen light with green laser. Given the option of your recommendations I will still take my Beretta for home defense. I have a Ruger Max 9 with a Holosun 407k green dot. Just curious why you did not include the Beretta 92FS??
Hey Joel! The Bereta 92FS is a great gun, no doubt, unfortunately, we only have so much room for guns in these articles and we can't include every model we like. So, some models don't make the cut. It doesn't mean they aren't great, though. Thanks for reading!
Ty
I’ve been reading this article, and many others, for a few weeks. Finally, decided on the m&p 2.0 full size! Thanks for the content and the articles!
Due to laws in my previous state only pistol I was allowed to own and perhaps even that was illegal a bb and pellet guns. Pistols self defense even with stand your ground laws and castle laws we none criminals need to be sure you will fire or not own a gun. At the same time shoot to kill. Today, in my state a warning shot is illegal. Having said that I just bought the S&W 686 plus. Your suggested dealer shows they are out of stock. I paid 849 plus shipping plus ffl net delivered cost roughly $900 OUCH. Compared to the cheaper, more common and due to lower cost PLASTIC guns it is different. Due to weight, recoil is less than my 380. Pretty guns seem to be the current rage. Hum color of your choice. My view, you do not want to need to prove your sky blue pink pistol is not a water gun. Ammo choices which does our military use. Again LAWS. I was surprised to read that self defense ammo that we debate and many, including me buy, is outlawed by the Geneva convention. Sights? I WON a S&W 380 EZ. Sights STINK as on most shrunk down pistols. Reality, a home invasion, a justified self defense shooting will be close not at 25 feet. My opinion I now have two 380's ammo costs more than 9mm and is hard to find. Not the S&W the other one a Taurus, is very particular on what you feed it.
What did I just read?
I own 6 of the 8 guns listed in the article, and I think the VP9 got a little shortchanged in this article. "Like a Glock, but not" is a gross understatement of the difference. The VP9 is far superior to the Glock - Glock isn't even in the same league in comparison to the VP9's trigger, the VP9 has fully ambidextrous controls right out of the box, and the balance on the VP9 are a few examples.
Agreed. .40 S&W on up.
I really wish new owners would consider going straight to more of a PCC/PDW-type firearm. Those with braces are so easy to shoot with accuracy and are manageable with little to no recoil because of the added barrel length and weight. You essentially get the same benefits as an AR, but without the deafness or the risk of overpenetration.
Handguns are notoriously difficulty for beginners to master by comparison.
Yes, there is a price difference (sometimes...) and yes, newbies are likely more familiar with handguns than something that looks "more intimidating," but boy are they easier to shoot, clean and maintain.
Try and hide one or get a CCW for one. Can't in Commiefornia.
Which is why I will never live in that God-forsaken state...
Not true. I live in Orange county California and have a CCW. I carry my Glock 30 every day. (Been carrying for 6 years.)I have what the Clock Store in San Diego calls the "$35.00" holster. Works great for IWB carry. No print and the most comfortable holster I have found to date.
I am an ex-New Yorker. Concealed carry Calif? The details will I expect explain.
Depends which county you live in in CA, Orange county (where I live) you need a good cause statement the OCSD likes. LA county and San Francisco county, Good luck. Most other counties are pretty easy, just fill out the forms, background check, finger prints, and pay the fees. You, also have to qualify with the exact weapon you plan to carry and complete a required training class.
Attend a training class?? Listen to an out of work cop or lawyer run his mouth for what $125.00 or more,
Buy the gun, read the manual, be done with the BS.
Also buy a good holster, keep the damned thing covered, good to go.
What is this $35 holster you speak of? I am interested.
The Glock Store in CA sells a holster they cal the $35.00 holster. Not much bigger than the gun. If you use it for IWB you need to get the opposite side holster. I carry on the right side so I bought a left hand holster. They are Model specific. So I have three of them; G21, G30, and G36. The G21 prints a little so I just wear a baggier shirt. Hope this helps.
Any updated comments on M&P's given they have had a trigger redesign?
How much is Glock paying you? You're doing beginners a big disservice with your worship of a handgun manufacturer that has been left in the dust. The firearms further down your list are far superior, like Sig, HK and Walther. There is simply no comparison.
Hey there! Thanks for reading. Just wanted to clarify that we don't get paid by manufacturers to include products in articles and that the list is in no specific order. Thanks for the feedback though!
It, helps to have thick skin. People, no shortage of opinions. We used to be told not to talk about politics or religion. Around here that has been replaced by pet dogs, lawns and for some guns. PAID? I used to be in the photo equipment industry. So much is the same. A service issue, stuff to try, free ammo? We common folk do not get that. Ammo, 357, 38.380 is like $1.00 a round for full metal jacket. Defense ammo is roughly twice that. Forgive me but.
I have been able to buy 9 mm and .40 cal for under $0.40 per round, some as low as $.30 per round on occasion. It is weird to me that .380 cal costs more than either of these but it does. You do have to shop for good prices though local box stores and Pawn Shops sell the 9 & 40 ammo for less than 50 cents per round in my area.
I am confused by the "Conclusion Statement".
"Try out the feel of the Glock 17/19, M&P9, XD, and the new P320"
I didn't see anything about an "XD" until this statement. ??? Am I blind?
Good catch. We swapped out the XD for another gun but must have overlooked that. It's been updated. Thanks for reading!
Not to mention only one Beretta firearm? And the 92 at that, which is just a bit big for many people.
Aw, c'mon. I built an AR arm pistol for the wife, modeled on the old Bushmaster. Sure, I needed to make a new forend with grip and remote trigger, but she's got thirty rounds of 556 on tap.
Used the Strike short buffer, and a 5" barrel from Hitman. Runs like a champ.
So for a beginner, I would recommend a Self-Defense / Concealed Carry Class and a good range that rents handguns. Trying them out as rentals and seeing what you like beats anybody’s recommendation on what’s the best gun for beginners.
I own a lot of these guns on the list, and I like different guns for different purposes. I love my Beretta 92X, but my son couldn’t hit the broadside of a barn with it. But with my P320, he was hitting center of mass and nailing tacks very quickly.
The BEST gun for beginners is the Staccato XC. That will make you love shooting, but the second mortgage you had to take out to get it is a showstopper.
So I recommend get some training, rent a lot, and buy what feels good - handling, recoil, etc. That will then be the best gun for you.
I believe the "Best Gun" for anyone, is one that they can afford to buy and practice with. As far as a recommendation, I would suggest a revolver or a striker fire pistol with a 4 inch +/- barrel. This is for people who are not comfortable or experienced so to speak. And for home defense, it should be on a nightstand within reach as soon as you are aware of any danger at home. I don't think that anyone without sufficient experience should be carrying a weapon of any kind until they take some safety courses or get proper training AND become comfortable with their firearm.
For a “Beginner” I would recommend a .22lr pistol, (imho .22lr Walther PPQ) to learn the fundamentals of shooting, without worrying about the bang and recoil. Get proficient in the basics, And then pick a goodly sized 9mm. It’s just ma 2 cents.
But I am biased towards Sigs, oh baby come to papa :):) p365s all day long and twice on sundays!!
I do like the Walther PPQ .22 lr. It’s a sweet little shooter and makes for a great boat gun.
If we are talking about *beginners* and first handguns, then I would not recommend any on this list. A beginner needs to enjoy shooting as much as possible. They can use their first handgun for the range and home defense; it won't be a carry piece. It needs to control recoil as much as possible until they learn good recoil control.
That all adds up to a Beretta 92, Sig P226, or CZ-75. The weight and size of the gun will help control recoil more than the popular polymer, striker-fired options. These also give beginners the option of using a manual safety or double-action trigger pull. Both could help beginners feel more comfortable with a firearm.
Since the firearm will be used for practicing on the range and for home defense, the size and weight are not an issue. Someone who has never fired a gun before will feel a massive difference between firing a Glock 17 and a CZ-75. That doesn't mean Glocks are worse than CZs. It just means absolute beginners don't necessarily need the lightest or smallest handguns as their first weapons. They don't need the benefits that come with a polymer pistol. They won't be carrying it on duty for eight hours a day.
Once they pass the beginner stage, learn good recoil control, and feel comfortable with a handgun, they can get something smaller and lighter for a potential carry gun.
I'm a lady and carry a small .380, very comfortable with it. My back-up is a Walther .380.
I really enjoyed the research and presentation/format of all the information provided. I was very thought out.
One of the articles I love to pick apart because inevitably "Glock" always ends up at the top of the list. I'm not a Glock fan for one reason, 5 Generations of improvements and the trigger is still s**t. Sure, you can install an aftermarket trigger, but when you're plunking down 5 bills, that sticks in my craw.
The Walther PPQ and PDP kick the Glock's *ss, hands down every day of the week and twice on Sundays. It's superior to every gun on the author's list. Only the SIG P320 comes close to the Walther's performance. That's 40+ years of experience talking.
PPQ VS PDP.... Which do you choose and why? I was going to buy one of them until H&Ks show up.
From what I have read in an article at "usacarry" the PDP is going to replace the PPQ, but both the PPQ and PDP are excellent and reliable pistols with great triggers, accuracies, ergonomics, and features. The PPQ may be a better buy for you although the PDP will have more features and modularity at a higher cost.
Not an argument here but wondering about the Sig P320 series. What is the deal with the claims of "Accidental Fires"? "Going off while in a holster or pocket during concealed carry"
... I am not against Glock , but I also don't think a Glock should be anyone's 1st pistol. I am told by my gunsmith that more Glocks are traded back in right away because people without experience either do not like them or are afraid of them. My thought is that the Glock is too expensive for most people as a 1st to buy and without practice with a pistol, none are much better than the other. If you invest all of your allowable income to buy the pistol, and if the ammo costs too much to shoot and practice with it, how is that a good thing. S & W pistols are generally much less money to purchase, as are several other brands, and are proven reliable firearms as well as a Glock. My research has revealed that all Glocks are not perfect either. Some have failures and some particular models more than others. And of course, this is just my opinion.
Very surprised you did not reccomend any of the Viridian products, laser or laser/light. They are and have been my go to and the instant on is an unbeatable feature. Most holsters are available or can be modified by the manufacturer to work with this system.
I agree on the S&W M&P choices. Great handguns for the money. I would never buy a Glock. Glock is great for cops where the city buys your ammo, but I am not made of money so I reload. Glock uses an "unsupported chamber" design which can deform brass and render it unable to be reloaded. Too rich for my blood. And speaking of "too rich", anything with a Sig Sauer label is a great weapon, but just too much of a Cadillac for the budgets of us mere mortals (the military can afford it). H&K is the same way.
I'm also a fan of the Ruger SR40 (including the compact 40c) and the Beretta 96D (40 S&W) despite its price.
The military abandoned the old M1911 45 cal because it was ergonomically unsuited for the smaller hands of a woman (don't shoot the messenger... it was an analysis conducted by Picatinny Arsenal), as women began to join the military in bigger numbers . The 9mm replacement was considered to have inferior stopping power by the FBI, so they adopted the 40 S&W round. I agree with the FBI. The 40 S&W round is the way to go. Its worth noting that the military is banned from using hollow point rounds by international agreement and it does just fine without them. I agree with the author here though, hollow point is best to have in your personal defense weapon.
Having said all that... if money is no object, keep an eye out for the new Kel Tec P50. They are pricey with an MSRP of $950. They are still very scarce and asking prices now range up to $1600. Prices will return to normal as production increases. But the 5.7 round is the wave of the future. Very flat trajectory means increased accuracy at improved ranges. And it has a standard 50 round magazine mounted parallel to the barrel. 50 rounds! 'Nuff said.
A mí no me convence el polímero he visto en perfectas condiciones y funcionando taurus pt92, Beretta 92, CZ 75, etc, pero armas de polímero con más de 30 años encima no he visto aunque tengo una Glock 19 gen 5 y una Glock 17 gen 5, pero para defensa uso algo viejo y confiable toda de metal una Taurus pt92 AF d, cuenta con 17 disparos en el cargador y tiene riel para accesorios y es muy parecida a la Beretta 92a1 que tengo... Y en caso de usarla me duele menos $$$ porque su precio es inferior que mis otras pistolas 9 mm.
Lot of talk lot of details now put the gun in their hand and see if they can rack it.
Grip safeties are a 110 year old Army requirement for the 1911. Now it is a marketing gimmick. Better to find a pistol with a thumb safety that will go a very long ways to preventing a holstering accident.
As far as missing the thumb safety on the draw training can fix that. Missing the grip safety can mean losing the contest which, depending on the contest, can be final.
How does one "miss" the grip safety on a 1911?
You guys are always my "go-to" for info and reviews, but for the first time, I'm going to disagree with a point. Just my opinion, but I'm a firm believer in a thumb safety for noob Shooters, especially if they're using it for CC. When the adrenaline hits, you don't need someone who is instinctively going to put their finger on the trigger.,... no matter where they're pointing it. Once they get comfortable shooting, then maybe a Glock. Remember your early years of shooting.
EXACTLY that was the first thing that came to my mind safety required for new shooters !
I can see the "Good and the Bad" of a thumb safety, especially for a concealed carry Newbie. I also think a true "Newbie" should not carry a firearm until they are no longer a "Newbie".
Hollowpoints stopping in drywall is a myth. Box 'o Truth disproved that years ago.
Wow… sadly I made some of the bad choices in the beginning. As a petite woman I was advised to purchase a revolver that I hated…and testing the cc small handguns … excessive flip and jamming. So I tried the Glock 29 and was in heaven. It was heavy enough not to flip or jam and I easily learned to deal with the simple “push” recoil. I used this Glock in all my classes and to become more proficient. Then moved to the Glock 19….then the concealed carry.
Yes and someone convinced me to purchase a shotgun… that’s another story.
Now I’m looking for a rifle that can give me the same confidence
AR 15 carbine style chambered in 300 Blackout. Shoot sub sonic ammo. It will get the job done and will have less penetration than supersonic ammo.
Ruger P C Carbine. Shoots 9mm ammo. Very soft shooter. Looks like a traditional rifle, not an AR 15, something important to me. You can use 33 round Glock magazines, giving you a huge amount of ammo.
I would also add the Walther PPQ and PK380. Both pistols have excellent ergonomics and phenomenal triggers. These guns make you look like a better shooter just due to the ease of the trigger pull.
I realize that money doesn't grow on trees. But, for beginning shooters, I recommend a .22lr revolver. Simple; Fun; Inexpensive to shoot. They're easy to shoot while learning and mastering a lot of the basics of shooting a hand gun. Then try a .22lr semi-auto. I recommend NOT getting the cheapest one - they can be a lot more trouble than it's worth. Again, master the function and mal-function of a semi-auto. From there on - Size; Fit and Function have a lot of possibilities. Those with less hand strength may benefit from a small frame 'wheel gun' vs. a semi-auto. Women with concealed carry purses could use a small frame revolver easier than anyone using the "Abdominal" carry inside the waste band, which is easier using a small frame, single stack semi-auto.
It's important to choose a style and size handgun that is Fun and Inexpensive to shoot because regardless of what you settle on, PRACTICE is extremely important. Dry-fire with snap caps has advantages for certain aspects of practice, but NOTHING beats shooting lots and lots of ammo. And, it's something that one must do on a consistent basis. It's a skill you use or lose.
I agree with the article on the selection of ammo concerning type, size, and bullet weight.
For actual defensive "carry" purposes, I recommend using Quality Factory Loads vs. hand loads for legal reasons (that's a complete subject all it's own).
I think the best handgun for a beginner is a revolver. (The marketing problem is they don’t look like the sexy semi-autos people see in action movies.) As you note, if there’s a misfire with a revolver you just pull the trigger again. No stove-piping to deal with -ever. Also, it’s easier to tell if a revolver is loaded and read to fire. There’s no need to rack the slide to put a round in the chamber or to check that there’s a round in the chamber. No safety. Yes, you can only fire 5 to 7 rounds ( depending on the revolver) without reloading, but in my opinion you’re in REAL trouble if you need more than that! Some military assassination team after you, rather than an armed burglar. And 357 magnum (125 grain jacketed hollow point is my choice) is a much more effective round than 9 mm. Maybe even 38 special + P is better or equal to 9 mm; I don’t know.
And I’ve had trouble when my hands are cold cycling the action on my Glocks. (I’m no body builder but I’m probably stronger than many women.) Maybe some striker fired pistols are easier to cycle than a Glock, but on a 1911 and other exposed hammer pistols you can cock the hammer and the slide is easy to pull back. So, no more striker fired pistols for me.
I agree totally with David above. The statistics are that in an average home defence encounter, 2-3 shots are fired, so you don't need 20 round mags. Remember, the other guy will be shooting back, so you'll be lucky to get three shots off!
Here is the problem. You assume there will be only one person attacking you. If there are more than one person you need that extra ammo. You can't assume you are going to hit, even with 2-3 rounds, as even police accuracy is less than 25%. I advocate using an automatic with 15+rounds and PRACTICE, PRACTICE, PRATICE. 9MM is plenty of stopping power and ALWAYS keep your gun loaded with a round in the chamber. If you have to pick it up it should be ready for combat!
Absolutely agree….practice practice practice… not like riding a bicycle… muscle memory …
Personally I don’t like the “fire” of a revolver and a 22 is good for plunking but unless you are a sharpshooter it will do little to stop an intruder especially if they are drug influenced. Yes have it ready with one in the chamber and accessible
Thank God someone with some common sense.
Eric, what do you think about the Taurus G3 as a beginners’ pistol?
Why in every one of these posts is the IWI Masada not mentioned? It's cheaper than alot of these firearms and is the same if not better for quality and reliability as these weapons
Because it's rare, and not very popular. But think how much that gun really costs after you take away from the price for import taxes. Not saying a cheap pistol is bad but the savings acount for something. Plus IWI is not the great company it once was. It's best to sick with American manufactured fire arms. Yes I know they are foreign company's but glock and sig are manufactured in the US for our market
Article helped a lot and I tried most of the firearms you mentioned before buying and went with the SIG P320F with Romeo 1 Pro and love it. Fired off rounds with it this weekend and handles so well. Love shooting it !!!!!!!!!!!
Eric what do you think of the Glock 48 for CC
I’m sorry but I have a very different view. I own a p320 and a beretta 92 fs compact. For a beginner the sig would be a heck of a lot easier for them to shoot themselves. In fact I don’t recommend a striker fired pistol at all. I’d recommend a revolver. Before you criticize, a family member who happened to be a 30 year police veteran, shot himself in the leg while drawing his Glock. Weird things can happen under stress. And a beginner isn’t a professional.
Iam looking for a first gun now for home and you just post this. Interesting.
Thanks.
Agree 100% plus I might add some of the new 1911s in 9 mm beats most of these quality and shooting wise add to that the safety & your choice is made. Spend a little more for a quality gun – it's your life!
Training and regular practice are the keys to safety. Muscle memory will enable you to draw and fire safely. What happens under stress is that you revert to your least level of training and practice. Sadly, cops are generally lousy shots. They don't practice enough! Stop believing cop shows are anything more than fiction!
I have to agree. You have to train like you would fight (20+ years mikitary). First time I realized how true this was we were going through MOUT training. I had a jam, and true to my normal range training I dropped to a knee to clear it (team kept moving). The OPFOR hit me four times on my groin protector and inner thigh before I could even react. Now with my P365XL I practice with snapcaps to get used to the motion of pulling and firing. Repetitions (using correct technique) are critical to reaction in bad times.