[Comparison] Single Action vs Double Action vs Striker

Still looking for the perfect holiday gift? Check out our Best Gifts for Gun Lovers [All Budgets]!

What Are Gun Actions?

Chances are you’ll see a bunch of lingo in gun descriptions about their action.

We’re here to help you figure everything out!

Simply put, a gun’s action is just how it works in relation to ammunition…how it loads, locks, fires, and extracts the casings.

Some of the most common actions in handguns are single action and double action.  We’ll start by describing these two in the world of revolvers before diving into the slightly more complicated world modern “autoloaders” or semi-automatic handguns.

Table of Contents

Loading...

Single Action Revolvers

Colt Single Action Army
Colt Single Action Army

The gun that won the West where good guys and bad guys had to cock the hammer back before they are able to fire each time.

Most of the time you would use your thumb, but we all know these scenes…

Get_three_coffins_ready_A_Fistful_of_Dollars_1964_full_scene
A Fistful of Dollars

I like to remember single action as pressing the trigger only does one action…release the hammer so the gun goes boom!  If you don’t cock the hammer manually and just press the trigger, nothing will happen.

Since the only action that happens is releasing the hammer, single action trigger pulls are usually smooth, crisp, and short with a weight of a few pounds.

One big downside is that unlike more modern revolvers, the cylinder that holds all the ammo is fixed so you can’t just swing it out and eject all the cartridges at once.  You have to eject one by one…and then load one by one.

Unloading Single Action Revolver, Hickok45
Unloading Single Action Revolver, Hickok45

Double Action Revolvers

Editor's Choice
Smith & Wesson Model 686+

Smith & Wesson Model 686+

Chances are unless you know a revolver is single action, it is likely double action.  So in this case, the trigger does two actions…cock the hammer back and also release it.

S&W .38 Slow Motion
S&W .38 Slow Motion

The trigger pull of a double action revolver is longer and heavier since you are moving the hammer back before firing and can be around the 10+ lb mark before it breaks.

Each subsequent pull of the trigger will be the same.

The great thing is most double action revolvers with the hammer exposed can be turned into single action by manually cocking the hammer before pressing the trigger.  This brings the trigger in line with single action standards of a crisp light pull.

Some concealed carry revolvers are double-action only since there is no exposed hammer to prevent snagging.

Still with me?

And double action revolvers also have the flip out chamber which enables much quicker reloads.  Blink and you’ll miss it with Jerry Miculek who shoots 12 with a reload in under 3 seconds.

Jerry Miculek 12 Shots
Jerry Miculek 12 Shots

Single Action Autoloaders

1911 Diagram of Parts
1911 Diagram of Parts

Now it’s diving into more modern territory.  An autoloader is exactly what it sounds like…it can automatically load the next round without the use of a revolver’s rotating cylinder.  This usually means the use of a magazine.

Now how can a regular handgun be single action?  You never see people in movies cocking modern looking handguns between each shot.  They only unnecessarily do it before for dramatic effect!

This is because when you load one round into the chamber by racking the slide, you also move back the hammer.  With each subsequent shot, the movement of the slide re-cocks the hammer again.  A good example of a single action autoloader is the 1911 which is known for its crisp light trigger.

1911 Action
1911 Action

Most often the 1911 is carried in “Condition 1” or “Cocked and Locked” since a round has been chambered, the hammer is cocked, and the safety has been engaged (locked).  To shoot, you only need to disengage the safety and pull the trigger.

Some may find this a little intimidating, when compared to double action or striker, fired autoloaders.  Which is why I recommend beginning shooters not start with a single action handgun until their skills improve.

Don’t forget to take a look at our top picks for the Best Affordable 1911s!

Double Action Autoloaders

Double Action / Single Action

Most double action autoloaders are actually merely double action for the first shot and single action afterward (DA/SA).

If you see an exposed hammer on a modern looking handgun, chances are it is DA/SA.  This hybrid action has the long trigger pull for the first shot while subsequent shots are single action as the movement of the slide automatically cocks the hammer.

Beretta M9 Double Action Single Action
Beretta M9 Double Action Single Action

Some of the best well-known DA/SA handguns are the Beretta M9 used by the US military, it’s 92FS civilian counterpart and most Sig Sauers.

Beretta 92FS Diagram of Parts
Beretta 92FS Diagram of Parts

For many, this is the perfect blend of preventing accidental discharges due to the heavy first pull and easier follow-up shots.  But always make sure to follow the 4 rules of firearms safety regardless!

Beretta 92FS

Beretta 92FS

Prices accurate at time of writing

Double Action Only

Now you run into more rare actions which include the double action only (DAO) which came about likely since law enforcement wanted something even “safer” for their officers.  Examples include Sig Sauers with DAK triggers (“Double Action Kellerman”) and some H&K variants.

You’ll see that even when the slide is racked to simulate a shot, the hammer still stays uncocked until the trigger is pulled again.

Sig Sauer DAK Trigger
Sig Sauer DAK Trigger

Only one trigger action needs to be learned but there’s a weird quirk of two reset points.  The first reset point has a ~8 lb trigger pull and allows for rapid fire, but the second reset point has a ~6.5 lb trigger pull.  Sig recommends that you allow full reset so you only use the ~6.5 pull.  My brain hurts a little from this…so let’s move onto my favorite action.

Striker Fired Autoloaders

Striker-fired autoloaders such as the Glock are easy to spot since they don’t have an exposed hammer…it is pretty much just flat in the back.

Glock 17 Diagram of Parts
Glock 17 Diagram of Parts

Striker-fired guns are a variation on the DAO theme but without two resets.

They have a long but pretty light (~5 lbs) take-up stage that increases in weight as you get closer to the break.  During this take-up stage, a spring is compressed and released at the break to propel a “striker” firing pin forward.  Each subsequent trigger pull is the same.

Glock Trigger
Glock Trigger

And let’s be honest, the break is nowhere close to a nice single action like the 1911 but is totally acceptable judging by the number of striker-fired fans.

There’s also no external safety to fiddle with except for a lever in the middle of the trigger that only allows the trigger to be depressed when a finger-like item is pressing…things that snag the trigger on the side should not affect it.

Glock Trigger Safety
Glock Trigger Safety

While striker fired guns will never have as good of triggers as a solid 1911, you can improve Glock triggers for competition, duty, and home defense use.

Conclusion

Hopefully, now you have a much better sense of the differences between single action vs double action for both old-school revolvers and modern autoloaders.

Since I know someone is going to ask…I prefer striker-fired pistols since they have the same trigger pull each time and do not have a manual safety you need to flip.  I’ve had several experiences during classes where when I was under stress and forgot to release the safety on my 1911.  Great trigger for competitions…but I’d rather have my Glock for home defense.

What do you prefer and why?  And if you’re new to guns…check out our Beginner’s Guide to Guns which goes over everything important you need to know.  

19
Leave a Reply

avatar
10 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
13 Comment authors
Omer CauseyEric HungDeltaBravoKSTomLarry Greenberg Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
DeltaBravoKS
Guest
DeltaBravoKS

Fantastic explanation. However, I find it interesting that at least in two of the videos, it appears the palm partially covers the barrel when racking the slide on the autos. The full hand is out of view, but by the placement of the fingers it looks like the base of the palm or at least the wrist would be directly in line with the barrel. I’m no expert in gun safety, but it seems dangerous to me to ever place a part of the body in front of the business end of a gun. It seems as though it would… Read more »

Tom
Guest
Tom

Great article!

Larry Greenberg
Guest
Larry Greenberg

I am going to buy my first firearm, and this article answered everything I was confused about..as a structural engineer, I’m now able to make a very precise purchase..thank you so much for sharing all of your experience Eric!

Stephen Burchett
Guest
Stephen Burchett

thank you for the information technology changes and you have covered all the bases. In my opinion there is no bad pistol, it boils down to affordability, preference, and which one you can shoot the best.. I prefer the Colt 1911 Gold Cup.

Joe
Guest
Joe

thanks i’ll stick with the striker fired action; I want to leave the chamber empty normally as a safety precaution, and slide the first round in when I may need the gun for protection,which I hope never happens. I know that takes some time but no more than having to cock a hammer or fumble for a safety switch.

Omer Causey
Guest
Omer Causey

A major disadvantage to having to rack the slide and chamber a round before being able to fire is that there may be times when you can’t get your weak-side hand to the gun. Driving, arm pinned, arm injured, etc.