How to Estimate The Trade-In Value of a Gun

You know, it wasn’t until relatively recently that I came to fully understand how to find quality guns.

Throughout my life, I’ve purchased some real pigs.

I remember thinking “hey, here’s a pocket pistol for under $100!  That’s perfect for carrying!”

Yeah, it wasn’t.

The bright side of the gun world is that only a bit of your money was flushed down the toilet.  Just about every gun dealer will take trades so that festering pile of crap that you bought can get you at least a small discount on a better one.

GunStore

This, however, also opens up a can of worms.

Just because the gun is crap doesn’t mean you shouldn’t get its full trade-in value.

The dude at the gun store is going to try to give you as little for your gun as possible.  That doesn’t mean he’s unscrupulous, mind you.  The nature of business is to make money and losing money on trade-ins isn’t a very good long term business solution.

Think about it, this guy is buying something from you with the hope that he can sell it later at a price that will recoup the money he spent buying it from you in the first place.  He knows what he can get for the guns as he’s probably sold a bunch like it before.

That doesn’t mean you have to roll over and take it.  There are some things you can do to increase your chances of getting the best price possible for your gun.

Private vs Trade-In Sale

First off, throw away any sentimental value.

The dude behind the counter isn’t going to care if it was your first gun ever or your grandfather’s gun.

Now, if it was a gun that was documented as owned by someone really famous then, and I can’t stress this enough, SELL IT THROUGH A PRIVATE SALE!  Those kinds of guns are not the ones to trade in.

I should note, by the way, that you will almost always get more money for your gun through a private sale than trading it in.

The difference is convenience and effort.

By taking a lower price for the trade-in, you’re essentially paying a fee for the other person to eventually sell it for you.

Anyway, the best thing you can be is informed.

When the guy behind the counter looks at your gun then looks at you and says “ok, what do you want for it?”, don’t just shrug your shoulders.  Also, don’t ask for the brand new price either.

Both of those are telling the salesperson “I have no idea what I’m doing.  Please take advantage of me.”

Make sure you have a reasonable price in your head before hand.  Let’s go over the basic “rule of thumb” steps for finding trade in value.

PT Barnum Quote
PT Barnum Quote

Calculating the Trade-In Value

  1. Be honest with yourself about the condition – Never taken out of the box with 0 scratches and hardly a fingerprint is considered mint condition.  Scratches, corrosion, worn finish?  Take your initial assessment then move down to the next grade.  You can argue all you want but that single scratch is going to keep you from getting the “excellent” price even if you’re selling to a private party.  Them’s the breaks.
  2. Find the going used rate for your gun – Go to GunBroker.com, Armslist.com or even bluebookofgunvalues.com (although the last one isn’t free) and find your gun.  Make sure it is EXACTLY your gun.  Yes, Kimber 1911’s are going for $800 but your 1911 is made by Rock Island Armory. There will be a price difference.  It also helps to know your area and what used guns go for there.  The only way to do that is frequent the gun stores and try to figure out where your local stores sell compared to internet used prices.  Is it higher?  Is it lower?
  3. Take that going used rate and cut it in half.  That’s your starting point.  If the cut in half price ends in 50, I like to round up to the next 00.

So, for example, let’s say I have a Ruger LCR .38 with the factory Crimson Trace Laser.

Ruger LCR
Ruger LCR

I have only put, say, a dozen shots through it at the most and it is truly in excellent condition.

The used prices on GunBroker.com range from 400-600 dollars.  I tend to grab the middle price, in this case $500, because that’s how stuff generally falls in my neck of the woods.

So with that in mind, when the salesman behind the counter says “what do you want to get for it”, I’ll look him right in the eye and say “$300” (50% of the used selling price and I rounded up).

So what are the chances that I’ll get that amount?

Slim to none.

He’ll probably go “talk” to the “manager” and come back with $200.  That was the low end I found online.  If I wanted, I could probably get him to $250 at this point and I would try.  I’d probably walk away with $225 final offer.

Not bad for a gun that was just sitting in a drawer completely unused.

If I’m trading this gun in for a pistol with a high profit margin or dealer sales incentives, well, they might actually give me that $250.

This is because that even with the trade-in “discount” they’re giving me, they’re still making a profit over what they payed for the gun.

This is RARE, mind you.

There are only a couple of manufacturers where this is possible.  Believe it or not, the markup on most guns isn’t as much as you think it is.

BONUS: Shoot better. Download our exclusive shooting targets for FREE ($47 value)

Trade-In vs Selling

All of this was assuming you were trading the gun.

If you’re wanting to just dump the gun for some quick cash (essentially pawning it), figure 30%-40% in that case instead of the 50%.

In those cases, you might actually get more for your gun at one of those police buyback programs, controversial though they may be.

Pawn Stars Meme
Pawn Stars Meme

Conclusion

In the end, this is just a quick way of determining the starting point.

The store is going to give you what they want to give you.

Fortunately, you have a choice.

If they’re just insisting on low balling you, just walk away.  Say “thank you for your time but no thanks”, collect your gun and try somewhere else.  Don’t ever feel pressured to go through with a transaction you’re not comfortable with.

Remember: knowledge is power in all cases, not just dealing with salespeople.

Previous Comments:

Posted @ 9/10/2012 5:24 PM by Wolffman

Wolffman's avatar

Good article I was disappointed when I went to a store (local sporting goods store) with my father trying to trade/sale a rifle of his that the price they gave him was the same for either. He didnt take the offer trying to sell it himself, but was really surprised considering he wanted a 1911 to trade it for they still didnt offer anymore on a trade then to buy it for cash….

Posted @ 9/10/2012 7:20 PM by Teh Noob

Teh Noob's avatar

There’s another rule of thumb for you: With the “Big Box” stores, you’ll be lucky to get pawn shop pricing on a gun. If that’s your only option, you’re far better off selling it yourself via armslist and such.

Posted @ 9/14/2012 6:51 AM by Josh

Josh's avatar

Great article, I’m definitely with the school of thought of trying to sell privately, but this is useful to know how to evaluate. Great read.

Posted @ 8/7/2014 7:43 AM by Gulf Tango

Gulf Tango's avatar

Good read. I recently traded in my Walther PK380. Paid $200 for it brand new, was hoping to maybe get $100 for it. Took it to the shop, and the guy behind the counter said…”I’ll give you $300 for it, but that’s the best I can do.” Of course I sounded reluctant when I told him, alright if that’s the absolute best you can do…guess it was just my day.

Posted @ 1/29/2015 1:27 AM by undeRGRound

undeRGRound's avatar

My son bought an M&P9c for $550 @ Gouger Mountain, on the same day I bought an M&P 9 at an LGS, non-chain store. I paid $499 and the 9c was the same price. Anyway, he later (a year or so) sold the 9c at the LGS, with 4 mags total, 2 of which were the full sized ones with X-Grips on them. $300, because they pretty much had to pay as if he had bought it there… Your formula held true there, it is our #1 LGS, we buy most of our items there, and they know us well. The deal was the offered $300 right away, and he took it. No haggle. Expect much more resistance at a place where you have not spent so much money, however 😀 He had dropped around $5,000+ there on several purchases, but a used M&P might only bring $400 if the LGS is fortunate. But it was perfect, and low round count, very clean. Marines tend to keep their weapons spotless!

5 Comments

  1. My son bought an M&P9c for $550 @ Gouger Mountain, on the same day I bought an M&P 9 at an LGS, non-chain store. I paid $499 and the 9c was the same price. Anyway, he later (a year or so) sold the 9c at the LGS, with 4 mags total, 2 of which were the full sized ones with X-Grips on them. $300, because they pretty much had to pay as if he had bought it there… Your formula held true there, it is our #1 LGS, we buy most of our items there, and they know us well. The deal was the offered $300 right away, and he took it. No haggle. Expect much more resistance at a place where you have not spent so much money, however 😀 He had dropped around $5,000+ there on several purchases, but a used M&P might only bring $400 if the LGS is fortunate. But it was perfect, and low round count, very clean. Marines tend to keep their weapons spotless!

  2. I just inherited an 1891 Mauser Argentino Modelo 7.65×54 Berlin, Ser# W0700, with a great adjustable open sight. It’s in AWESOME condition…. blue too. Looks like it’s rarely been used. All matching #s. What is something like this valued at? Is this a ‘keeper or should I sell it?It’s light yet seems like a great gun for ‘the hunt’.

    1. Hey James, nice! I’m not too great on the pricing of antique guns. I’d say take a look at the Blue Book or try to find a recent auction.

    2. If you look at gunbroker.com they are ranging between 200 to 600 (asking) not a lot of bids on them. I have seen them at a gun show but they weren’t selling in this area right now. However if you find a Mauser guy, then it may draw more.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *