Best Compact 9mm Handguns

When it comes to handguns, the 9mm is arguably the most popular and best suited caliber made.  

The 9mm compact is particularly popular due to its Goldilocks size that makes it perfect for both open carry AND concealed carry.  Looking for something a little smaller?  Check out our Best Sub-Compact Single Stack 9mms.

We’ll cover some of our favorite options across all budgets.

But if you can’t wait, here’s our list of the Best Compact 9mm Handguns:

What to Look for in a Compact 9mm 

The Fit

When shopping for a compact 9mm, the primary thing to look for is how it feels in your hand.  

This may seem a little silly, but some guns simply don’t feel right when you hold them.

Shooting Compact 9mm
Your compact 9mm should feel good in your hand.

The Sights

When making the jump to a compact 9mm versus the subcompact version, you open up the door for some new options.

One that is inherent with any gun with a longer barrel is greater accuracy at a greater distance.  You aren’t going to be a marksman with a snub nosed revolver at 100 yards, but at 10 feet shooting from the hip, it does the job.

When you get into a compact gun with around a 4-inch barrel, your overall gun length increases.  

Aside from being more accurate at a greater distance, you start to get into the different types of optics available.  Some, as you will see later in the list, have reflex optic options.  While this adds bulk and can narrow your holster choices, it makes sighting in your target much, much easier.

Smith & Wesson M&P 9 Pro Series with Reflex Optics
Smith & Wesson M&P 9 Pro Series with Reflex Optics

Now let’s talk about the guns themselves.

Glock 19

You can’t really have an article like this without mentioning the Glock 19.  It’s pretty much the standard when it comes to compact CCW and even open carry guns.  There’s not much to say about the Glock 19 that hasn’t already been said. 

Most Dependable
Glock 19 9mm G5

Glock 19 9mm G5

It’s probably the most popular gun in Glock’s offerings, and is one of the most popular firearms for government and law enforcement agencies.  It features a rail so you can add a flashlight or other accessory on the front, and, of course, it also has Glock’s famous reliability. The Gen 5 Glock 19 also has some upgrades to the slide, grip, and barrel.

Readers' Ratings

4.76/5 (17)

Your Rating?

HK VP9

The Heckler & Koch VP9 is another wildly reliable compact 9mm and it comes from a series of guns that a lot of law enforcement and military agencies are beginning to favor.

The VP series of HK handguns rivals the Glock in terms of durability and reliability, but the guns feel different when they shoot.  As far as which one’s better, it just comes down to personal preference.  So be sure to hold and hopefully shoot all your options.

Springfield Armory 9mm XD(M)

Springfield has been around for quite a long time and has produced many great handguns.  

Personally, when I was shopping for my first gun, I was torn between a Glock and a Springfield.  The reason I went with a Glock was the wait time.

Most Bang-For-Your-Buck
Springfield Armory 9mm XDM Compact

Springfield Armory 9mm XDM Compact

The Springfield Armory XD(M) 9 mm is a solid performing compact CCW choice.  It’s priced about the same as a Glock, but less than an HK.  It’s right in the middle, so it’s a good bang for your buck, and a great first gun to purchase.

Sig Sauer P320 

What I like about the P320 Compact is there’s a lot of variants…so you can get something that fits your needs really well.  

One that I particularly like is the option to get a reflex optic.  A lot of times this is a feature where you have to purchase a specific slide, or have your slide milled so the reflex optic will have a place to mount.  

Most Versatile
Sig Sauer P320 Compact

Sig Sauer P320 Compact

The P320 is one of the first polymer pistols from Sig, and is a striker fire.  Both make this a reliable 9mm CCW choice.  I also enjoy the texture of the grip.  It has that rough texture on all four sides of the grip.  Most shooters end up adding some sort of grip tape to in the areas where there is no texture, so by having Sig do it for you, it saves you time and money.  

Ruger SR9c 9mm

The SRC9c from Ruger is a pretty nice little compact CCW.  

Like some of the other manufacturers, you can use the accessories and magazines from the full size variant of the same gun.  

Most Wallet Friendly
Ruger SR9c 9mm

Ruger SR9c 9mm

There are four versions of the compact SR9c.  You have an all black or two-tone version, then there are a couple choices beyond color.  They all come with at least a 10+1 round magazine, but one of the all black and one of the two-tone versions comes with a 17+1 round magazine.  That’s like having a double stack magazine amount of ammo in a single stack gun.  

The 17+1 has a finger grip on it which helps it look like it’s actually supposed to be in the gun.  

Smith & Wesson M&P9 9mm

The features of the Smith & Wesson M&P9 2.0 compact are on par with most of the other manufacturers.  

You have a short rail for your light or other accessory.  A lot of the modern CCW options are going away from the thumb safety and using a trigger-based safety.  The M&P9 is no different in this regard.  

Smith & Wesson M&P9 2.0 Compact

Smith & Wesson M&P9 2.0 Compact

The M&P9 has a great feel to it.  Almost all of the Smith & Wesson handguns I’ve held and shot are comfortable to hold.  They shoot smoothly, the grip is a good angle, and the texture is great.  I don’t know if they do something special to make it feel great in my hand, but I dig it.

Overall, what you get with the M&P9 is a solid and reliable compact 9mm CCW.  

FN 509

The FN 509 is one of those guns you don’t hear a lot about unless you know someone who is into them.  FN, as a manufacturer, doesn’t show up as a real competitor on many of the topic-specific lists like these.  That’s a shame, because they’re high quality firearms, in the same ballpark price as a Glock or Springfield Armory XDM.  

The 509 is a variation on the MHS gun they submitted to the military for testing.  It took components from previous model FNs, but eliminates the happer fire and goes with a striker fire.  While it’s a very functional gun, it leaves a little bit to be desired in the looks department.  It has a mishmash of textures that help you grip the gun well, but aren’t  as pleasing to the eye as some others.  

Final Thoughts

The size of a compact 9mm CCW is a great starting point for most people.  It’s large enough for your hand still fits on the grip without having the dangling pinky, it offers an accessory rail so you can add a flashlight if you want to be tacticool or actually use it, and it holds a few more rounds than a subcompact semiautomatic pistol.

For most people carrying a concealed handgun, the compact is about as big as you can easily conceal without having an untucked and oversized shirt.  

Many of the compact 9mm CCW choices on this page are not that much larger than their subcompact counterparts, but you get so much more in terms of number of rounds you can carry, add-ons available, and choices of quality guns.

Carrying a Compact 9mm
Carrying a Compact 9mm

Do you have any favorite compact 9mm pistols that didn’t make our list?  Let us know in the comments.

26
Leave a Reply

avatar
20 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
8 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
24 Comment authors
TroyBobkossTonyBig tasty Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Bob
Guest
Bob

I have several of the guns on this list and some that aren’t. The one that doesn’t get any love is the Beretta px4 storm subcompact. I just seem to keep coming back to it, it’s become my favorite.

koss
Guest
koss

Tristar C100, CZ75 Semi Auto 9mm Clone. good as CZ75. with less money.

Tony
Guest
Tony

I have a Ruger SR9C and its replacement the Ruger American compact. Yhe American is a little heavier which I actually like. I carry the American every day. Which I can conceal but it does print. The SR9C I carry when I am wearing something that doesnt conceal well. Dress clothing or shorts. The American holds 12+1 with a 17+1 back up clip. SR9 holds 10+1 with the same backup. I love them both.

Randy
Guest
Randy

You kinda have to wonder how qualified one is when they put Glock and Springfield in the same boat..

Big tasty
Guest
Big tasty

You’re right. The glock doesn’t hold a note to the xdm. Buying a glock is like buying a Harley. There are more reliable bikes out there, but some people just feel they have something to prove.

Guy Schwartz
Guest
Guy Schwartz

There is a definite bias against metal guns. The CZ p01 should be on this list.
Too many polymeraphiles.
Once you shoot all steel you will not go back to plastic.