When it comes to handguns, the 9mm is one of the most popular calibers for pistol shooters.
And among the pistol arena, the 9mm compact, in particular, tends to be a regular choice for those looking to concealed carry.
These guns bridge the gap between full-sized and sub-compact, offering a nice middle area. Basically, they’re the Goldilocks guns — not too big and not too small.
But with a ton of models to choose from, it can seem a bit overwhelming to narrow down which one you should buy.
But that’s why you’ve got us, right? We’re going to walk you through some of our favorite compact 9mm handguns and tell you why we dig them.
By the end, you’ll have a better understanding of what’s out there and what we recommend.
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Value
-
Best 2011 Pick
-
Best Modular Compact
-
Best Soft Shooting Compact
Table of Contents
Loading…
How We Tested the Best Compact Handguns
The Pew Pew Team tested each of these handguns at the range. This includes accuracy testing from 7 to 25 yards, running at least several hundred rounds various types of range and defensive ammo through each firearm over a long period, and extensive time concealed carrying these guns.
We also measured trigger-pull with trigger gauges instead of just relying on manufacturer data.
Not every gun on this list is right for everyone, but we’ve included some of the most popular brands and models that work for us and the vast majority of concealed carriers.
Best Value Compact 9mm Handgun
1. Walther PDP
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Excellent trigger
- Optics ready
- Ambidextrous
- Extremely accurate
Cons
- High bore axis
- Optics plates must be ordered through Walther
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-auto, striker-fired
- Weight: 24.4 oz.
- Barrel length: 4″
- Overall length: 7.5″
- Width: 1.34″
- Height: 5.4″
- Capacity: 15+1
Features
- Performance Duty Trigger
- SuperTerrain slide serrations
- Interchangeable backstraps
- Optics-ready
- 2x 15-round magazines
The PDP by Walther is an impressive design that really stood out to the team at PPT.
Although there are various sizes and models available, we are looking at the PDP Compact. This model offers a 15-round capacity along with a whole host of other cool features.
This gun sports aggressive texturing and slide serrations that make manipulations easy. The magazine release and slide release are generously sized, making the controls easy to operate.
It also boasts one of the best triggers we’ve tried — seriously, it’s good. Dubbed the PDT (Performance Duty Trigger), it gives users a 4.5-pound trigger that has an exceedingly crisp break and reset that isn’t common among striker-fired guns.
The grip angle feels natural, and this gun is a comfortable one to shoot. Not to mention, it has proven to be both extremely reliable and accurate.
Topping everything off is an optics-ready slide, although you will have to order the specific adapter plate you need directly from Walther.
Although the PDP is a bit chunkier when it comes to concealed carry, the compact version is still more than manageable with a good holster and appropriate attire.
Sean has put over 10,000 rounds through his main Walther PDP, so be sure to read up on his thoughts here or watch the video review below. Between him and our editor, Wyatt, they have five PDPs — nuff said.
Best 2011 Compact 9mm Handgun
2. Staccato CS
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Accurate
- Improved longevity
- Reliable
Cons
- Price
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-auto, single-action
- Weight: 23 oz.
- Barrel length: 3.5″
- Overall length: 7.1″
- Width: 1.45″
- Height: 5.6″
- Capacity: 16+1
Features
- Optics-ready
- Fiber optics front sight with Dawson Precision rear
- Fluted bull barrel
- External extractor
- Fully captive recoil system
- 2x 16-round magazines
The Staccato CS is all about striking a balance between staying hidden and getting the job done. It’s not too big, not too small, and just right for most folks, regardless of hand size.
When it comes to handling, it’s got a good grip texture, but it won’t feel like sandpaper on your skin. No need to worry about your clothes getting caught up in it.
Staccato implemented a newer grip to help overcome that bulky and blocky feeling most 2011s have. It feels noticeably thinner and more natural than our editor’s Staccato C2, making it much more appealing for concealed carry.
The trigger’s got a crisp feel, barely any travel, and resets quickly. It breaks right around 4-4.5 pounds, and feels amazing, like a good 1911 trigger should.
Being smaller, it has a bit more recoil compared to other Staccato models, but no worries, it’s still easy to handle, and you can nail follow-up shots with ease and speed.
Accuracy-wise, it delivers tight groups thanks to a precision-fitted match-grade bull barrel. In short, this is a high-end gun, with high-end performance for the discerning shooter. This is an everyday carry gun for our content man, Sean.
So what is the catch? Well, it carries a hefty price tag of $2499. If money is a concern, this is probably not going to be your top choice.
To learn more about the Staccato CS, check out our hands-on review.
Best DA/SA Compact 9mm Handgun
3. Sig Sauer P229 Legion
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Double-action/Single-action
- Grayguns trigger
- Reliable
Cons
- Chunky
- Higher bore axis
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: DA/SA
- Weight: 31.1 oz.
- Barrel length: 3.9″
- Overall length: 7.4″
- Width: 1.5″
- Height: 5.4″
- Capacity: 15+1
Features
- Grayguns P-SAIT trigger
- X-RAY3 tritium day/night sights
- G10 grips
- Reduced controls
- Improved grip and extended beavertail
- Optics-ready
- 3x 15-round magazines
The Sig Sauer P229 takes the proven accuracy and reliability of the venerable P226 and trims some of the fat. The end result is a DA/SA, hammer-fired pistol that is a bit easier to conceal than its larger brethren.
We’ve enjoyed the P22X series of pistols for years and have a lot of rounds down range through various models to attest to the platform’s reliability.
The Legion version is the premium version of the P229 and does not disappoint in the least.
Needless to say, the Graygun’s trigger is outstanding in this gun, particularly in single-action, where the speed of follow-up shots can become blazing thanks to the very short trigger reset. The double-action is also notably smooth and very useable with minimal practice when compared to many other guns.
A trigger undercut, extended beavertail, G-10 grips, and X-RAY3 night sights are also standard on all Legion models. The slide lock has also been reduced in size to prevent accidental slide lockback.
Our editor, Wyatt, sees his P229 Legion in regular carry rotation thanks to its reliability, accuracy, and great combat trigger. Newer versions are available with optics-ready slides that use the Sig PRO (DPP) footprint.
Although the bore axis is a little higher, the gun is a bit blockier feeling, and the overall size is a bit bigger, this gun still ranks highly overall as a great carry option thanks to its overall shootability.
What do you think of the Sig? Rate it below!
Best Modular Compact 9mm Handgun
4. Sig Sauer P365 X-Macro
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Class-leading capacity
- Reduced muzzle flip
- Easier draw from concealment
Cons
- Mag can hang up on big hands
- Slightly harder to conceal
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: Semi-auto, striker-fired
- Weight: 21.5 oz.
- Barrel length: 3.1″
- Overall length: 6.6″
- Width: 1.1″
- Height: 5.2″
- Capacity: 17+1
Features
- X-RAY3 tritium day/night sights
- Interchangeable backstraps
- Integrally compensated, optics-ready slide
- Standard 1913 rail
- 2x 17-round magazines
One of the biggest complaints about smaller guns is the increased role physics plays during recoil. Smaller and lighter handguns tend to produce a little more muzzle flip in common defensive calibers.
Sig Sauer addressed that issue with the P365 X-Macro. This gun is yet another great member of the ever-growing and wildly popular P365 lineup.
Keep in mind this version is closer to the order of a G19 in comparison, so it isn’t nearly as small as the standard P365. However, with that size, Sig was able to achieve an impressive 17+1 capacity in a gun that is still only about 1 inch wide.
With the integral compensator at the end of the slide, the gasses are routed up at the end of the muzzle, providing counter-acting force. Combined with a low slide mass, this makes follow-up shots easier than most other guns.
Despite not having a stellar trigger (it isn’t bad by any means), when we had all of these guns next to each other, this was arguably the fastest-shooting gun on the table. The only thing that was in the same realm of speed was the Staccato CS.
The P365 X-Macro has the highest capacity-to-width ratio on the market. Combined with good accuracy and flat-shooting characteristics, it is a clear contender for best-in-class compact. Our amazing cameraman, Jonny, uses this gun as his EDC.
We have a review of the P365 XMacro Comp and a video below, so check that out!
Best Soft Shooting Compact 9mm Handgun
5. Beretta PX4 Storm
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Reliable
- Accurate
- Soft recoiling
Cons
- Grip texturing is lacking
- Not optics-ready
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm
- Action: DA/SA
- Weight: 27.2 oz.
- Barrel length: 3.27″
- Overall length: 6.8″
- Width: 1.42″
- Height: 5″
- Capacity: 15+1
Features
- Rotating barrel
- Interchangeable backstraps
- Ambidextrous slide release and safety/decocker
- 2x 15-round magazines
Somewhat of a dark horse in the lineup, the 15+1 Beretta PX4 Storm has a lot to offer to concealed carriers. Its big claim to fame is its rotating barrel, which helps reduce felt recoil and muzzle flip.
Unlike John Moses Browning‘s tilting barrel design, the Storm’s barrel rotates along the Z-axis, which eliminates the tilting-up action that can cause the muzzle to rise. It also soaks up some of the recoil by using the rearward motion of the slide to rotate the barrel itself.
The stock trigger isn’t bad, but it is a bit heavier in both departments at around 9-10 pounds in double-action and around 5.5 pounds in single-action.
Thanks to a modular, self-contained trigger design, you can pick up an LTT Trigger Job in a Bag and easily upgrade your gun in mere minutes. This drops the double-action to a light 5.5-6 pounds and the single-action to a feathery 3.5-4 pounds.
If you do the trigger mod and throw on some $20 talon grips to help improve the grip texture, you end up with a gun that has an outstanding trigger and overall feel for around the same price as a base Sig P229. But even unmodded, it’s a great buy.
Accuracy has been great during our testing as well, with the gun producing stellar 2-3″ groups out to 25 yards. These guns are also absurdly reliable, with some routinely going tens of thousands of rounds without stoppages.
All of These qualities have helped this gun make a huge comeback in the last two years. Check out our full review of the pre-upgraded Beretta PX4 Storm Compact Carry.
Honorable Mention Compact 9mm Handgun
6. Glock G19
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Lots of aftermarket support
- Reliability proven
- Fieldstrips without tools
Cons
- Plastic sights
- Mediocre trigger
Specs
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Action: Semi-Auto
- Weight: 23.63 oz
- Barrel Length: 4in
- Overall Length: 6.9in / 7.3in / 7.4in
- Magazine Capacity: 15rd
Features
- Adjustable backstraps
- Safe Action trigger safety
- Steel slide with Tenifer finish
- Polymer frame – impervious to corrosion
You can’t really have an article like this without mentioning the Glock G19. It’s still considered the gold standard when it comes to compact CCW by many.
Why?
Because it just works. Trust us, people have run these things over, buried them in mud, and even frozen them, and they still work. They are used by special forces, law enforcement, and civilians worldwide.
Aside from being durable, they are reliable and boast a huge aftermarket. Seriously, you can swap out sights, slides, barrels, triggers, mags — the sky’s the limit.
Standard capacity on the G19 is 15 rounds, but any compact or larger 9mm Glock mag will work. Glock’s come in three generations for you to buy — Gen 3, Gen 4, and Gen 5.
The trigger may not be the best, and the grip might not be the most comfortable, but we have over a dozen of them between everyone on the PPT team because they still rock.
We have a full breakdown of the generations and a full review of the Gen 5 Glock 19.
What to Look for in a 9mm Compact
No two 9mm compacts are exactly alike, so how do you narrow down which are the best? There are a few factors to look for when shopping for a new handgun.
First, consider the features you want. Do you want to mount a red dot? Do you want an external safety? Are you looking for a specific type of trigger action? Deciding what you want or need first can help narrow down your initial list.
We also like to look at both OEM and aftermarket support. Things like affordable mags, aftermarket sights, and holster compatibility should be considered.
When it comes to compact guns, know your use case. Some compact guns are pretty close to full-size guns, while others are notably smaller or slimmer.
Decide whether your gun is just going to be a range toy, home defense tool, concealed carry gun, duty gun, or a mixture of those to make sure you don’t get a gun that is too big or too small to comfortably serve in its primary role.
Finally, when shopping for a compact 9mm, consider how it feels in the hand. This may seem silly, but some guns simply don’t feel right when you hold them. And if it doesn’t feel right, there is a big chance you won’t enjoy shooting or training with it.
If possible, we recommend trying to find a range or gun store that will let you rent guns so you can try before you buy, or pick them up and handle them at the least.
FAQs
What caliber is best for compact handguns?
The most popular, by far, is 9mm. It fits the widest range of shooters and has the most availability in terms of what you can find on the shelf.
What is the best size handgun for carry?
Most people prefer subcompacts or microcompacts, but for those that want a little more real estate, compacts are great.
What size handgun is a compact?
A compact is smaller than a fullsize but larger than a subcompact or microcompact. They mostly come with barrels in the 3.5-inch to 4-inch range.
Are compact handguns better for concealed carry?
Compacts are large enough to help with recoil and small enough for carry. They occupy a nice middle area for a lot of concealed carriers.
Final Thoughts
The size of a compact 9mm handgun is a great starting point for most people. It’s large enough for your hand to still fit on the grip but isn’t quite as big as its full-size siblings.
For most people carrying a concealed handgun, the compact is about as big as you can easily conceal without having an untucked and oversized shirt.
Do you have any favorite compact 9mm pistols that didn’t make our list? Let us know in the comments. Want something even smaller? Check out our Best Single-Stacked 9mm Sub-Compact Handguns or the Best Micro Compact 9mm Handguns.
Latest Updates
April 10, 2024: Added the Beretta PX4 Storm, Sig Sauer P229 Legion, and Sig Sauer P365 X-Macro Comp to the list based on new tests conducted.
241 Leave a Reply
what you think of hellcat pro
The Hellcat Pro is a good CCW gun. We liked the original Hellcat and it seems like Springfield has been making good improvements to that platform.
Now that's sassy!
Where is the Glock 43x MOS, the most popular EDC ?? It’s extremely reliable and has Shield Arms gen 3 mags with 15 or 17 rounds. Same for the bullet proof Smith & Wesson MP Shield, that won the Garand Thumb mud challenge, ice challenge and “I’m just too angry to die” test of all the best known pistols? Extremely reliable as well. Hate that people that may not know better, will see your list, and think it’s anywhere near correct.
We consider the Glock 43X and the Shield to be micro-compact, which is why they aren't on this list. But if you hop on over to our Best Micro-Compact 9mm article, you will see both mentioned! Thanks for reading!
The Taurus GX4 Carry TORO is a phenomenal carry pistol. I carry it more than my Hellcat Pro.
I ‘m wondering if there are any other handguns a woman with rheumatoid arthritis could even rack. I’ve looked at only a few because the gun shop where I live is fairly small. I was advised from the shop that the best gun for me would definitely be a S&W Shield and I did buy one with a red dot. I may have tried to rack a Hellcat because of the white U sight on the front of the gun which I love, but couldn’t. In any case, the only gun I could rack after testing out a couple of guns was the Shield. Fortunately, I also have a SS MPX Copperhead because it’s fairly easy for me to pull. I also love that it’s necessary to hold much closer to the face because I know I will always be more accurate with it rather than a handgun for carry purposes which I could require a large tote or some type of bag like a gym bag. Thank!!
Amy, the first handguns that come to mind that are super easy to rack are the S&W Shield EZ and the newer Ruger Security-380 Lite Rack. Sig is now offering the P365 in a .380 ACP version that requires less force to rack; it still isn't as easy as the S&W or Ruger, but is fairly manageable. If you are looking for something in 9mm instead of .380, the Walther CCP is really ergonomic and easy to rack due to its gas-operated design. The trigger and capacity aren't the best on the CCP, but they are easy to use and soft-shooting.
It's obvious that sig pays you guys to kiss their butt PERIOD!
It occurs to me that a timely article on compact 9mm handguns would be remiss without mention of the Glock 45. Yes, you mention the G19, but frankly, the G45 will put the 19 and 19x out of business. I can not think of a single reason one would prefer a 19 or 19x over a 45. Had the G45 been reviewed, I believe it may have outranked most of the "winners"! Put a glock performance trigger in the G45, do a bit of polishing, and the G45 is an unbeatable compact handgun! (and for fun, you can run the Glock 34 barrel in the G-45 for one heck of a target pistol as well!)
Thanks for stopping in William. In the video's comments I addressed my specific feelings about Glock. Please keep in mind this is simply my opinion. Glocks are great for their reliability and accuracy though leave a bit to be desired in regards to triggers and ergonomics. For me, they tear up my hand if I don't use the extended beaver tail. I believe in the product, have trusted it with my life and the lives of those around me when I carried one on duty, but I'm discouraged by what I can only describe as organizational stagnation. We work with a lot of gun manufacturers and so many of them implement customer feedback in their evolving designs. I guess when your slogan is "perfection", it puts you in a bit of a tough spot when the shooting community offers ideas for improvements.
Thanks for your response! I understand, agree with and respect your position.
I agree with you Glen. I can't imagine not having the S&W M&P on the list. I have both the .380 and the 9 mm. And Sean, I realize there are a gazillion guns you could chose from. Maybe the list should have been longer??????
Thanks Herman, sincerely appreciate the suggestion. The article is now tied to the video and for the sake of brevity, we keep the list concise. We're very fortunate in that we have so many quality choices when it comes to firearms these days. I really like Smith and Wesson and wasn't exposed to them much during my LE career. But after I got some time on them, I really liked them for all the good reasons, mostly the trigger. I recently purchased a 2.0 Metal after reviewing it because I liked it so much. As I've said in other comments though, keep an eye on this list. We'll be updating it (article and video) as time progresses and we're exposed to more firearms.
Anytime I see guns above the $1K for compact I have to shake my head. While you can certainly carry a Staccato, for $2500, I don't see many people doing that. I'm surprised to not see anything from the S&W M&P on this list. I'll take my Shield over the Glock any day. Better sights, trigger, ergonomics and price tag, not to mention the improvements seem to come almost with every model year. Glock hasn't changed anything since 1985.
Glen, I don't disagree with anything you've said though I would point out I shoot the Staccato better than I do the other guns. Performance is somewhat subjective.
It's like the commenters here don't realize that there is a whole class of guns considered Compact. The ones that are complaining about the size of the pistols all bring up Sub-compact or Micro compact pistols. This list is specific for compact pistols. Stop whining about you tiny guns jnot being on the list just because you have tiny girl hands and can't hold onto a larger grip.
Part of it I guess, when there are no hard and fast guidelines defining each category.
Some good choices. Why does HK rarely get any love? The VP9SK is a good choice. Also the Hellcat Pro might be an option.
Thanks!
Sure Chip, the Hellcat is a good choice and I think the VP9SK is a good gun though I didn't like the trigger from what I recall. We have to try to keep the list short so our video isn't 30 minutes long.
Where’s the Taurus GX4xl?
Yep. I guess the list is “ too cool” to show a Taurus. Typical.
No hate here John. I'm a fan of the GX4 Toro and none of us here are too cool for budget options that work well.
It's a great option but didn't make the list.
The majority of these pistols are not compact pistols at all. The Walther PDP, a pistol with a 4" barrel and a 15 round magazine is not compact at all. The same can be said about the Glock 19. These are not compact. The Staccato costs $2550. You can buy almost 5 Canik TP9SC Elites or CZ P10S pistols for that amount. That is way too expensive compared to these other guns. Expensive guns do not mean they're better.
What defines a compact may vary from person to person, I take your point. The Staccato CS made the list due to its performance, in spite of its price.
If you don't have the MC9 by Canik on this list, then you are delusional. Would gladly put it up over any of the guns on your list. Accuracy, trigger, capacity, not to mention price..... well, again you are either delusional or lazy for not doing your due diligence. Just saying.
Timothy, I've certainly been delusional at times in my life but in the case of Canik, I've only been slow. I have a Mete MC9 and a Rival S to review very soon. I'm really encouraged by everything I'm hearing. These lists need constant tending, so it's likely you'll see a Canik in the future.
I’ll put my Shadow Systems CR-920 against any in the list. I run snappy +P loads & the recoil is negligible- a nice trick through such a tiny piece
That's a great shooter Dennis.
Carried the Beretta PX4 9mm compact on and off duty. Now that I am retired I still consider it my go to gun. I wish Beretta had better aftermarket products. Prefer hammer fired over striker fired guns. Good price point for this category. Thanks for the article.
Mark, thanks for your service, glad you made it out. My career started with Beretta and it was rocky, but newer models have really changed my mind.
All the guns listed are great. I would prefer to keep the price under $1,000 for most of my carry options. If price is not important, getting a Wilson Combat SFX9 with 3.25" or 4" barrel at ~$3,000 deserves a considerations.
My favorite brand is CZ and CZ P-01 will be a very good candidate to compete with Walther compact.
Sure, we try to offer a range of options at various prices with the most weight given to features and performance. CZ makes great guns!
I agree with many of these; so many great guns out there. I think others have agreed in the compact category and maybe add a "best hammer fired cost effective:" Beretta PX-4 Storm and especially their compact carry edition in collaboration with Langdon Tactical.
I was a little surprised based on the recent update made here that the CZ P-01 while a good gun was selected over the new CZ Shadow 2 compact or alternatively the Dan Wesson DWX Compact from CZ would have nudged out the old P-01. I've shot both and they are nice but I do realize they have only been out for a couple of months so it might be a testing issue.
Just an observation: You show several photos of pistols with Optical sights and/or what appears to be laser pointers or flashlights. Just how does this keep a pistol useful for CCA or even open carry? If you wannabe a Tommy Tacktical or look cool and dangerous, go ahead and hang stuff all over your shooting iron. Otherwise, keep it lean and clean. Practice, practice, practice.
Ruger Max 9 with the Ruger ReadyDot can easily be pocket carried.
Of course, if you want to keep it lean and clean, you can't do much better than the Ruger EC9S.
I agree with some of the other comments regarding hammer fired guns. The two you selected were the most expensive on the list. The Beretta PX4 compact is priced in the same range as the included striker fired handguns. The hammer fired Beretta Storm is reliable and durable without breaking the bank.
Beretta PX4 Storm Subcompact is also an excellent choice. 13+1 capacity, small, shoots and handles like a full-size gun. DA/SA with decocker (my favorite feature).
Unfortunately, Beretta just quit making this gun.
I believe it would have sold a lot better had they made it a single stack - it would have fit a lot better into the "subcompact" category. As a double stack, it was just a bit too thick.
Sorry, but my Glock 43X MOS will shoot circles around half of the pistols on this list all day long.
I don't think of a PDP as "compact", it's double stack and fits big hands (except for the F). I think of the PPS or PPK as "compact". What is the 2023 definition that you used to base this article?
But no what about the Ruger Max-9? You guys hurt my feelings.
Curiosity: Why isn't your category & choice for "Best Polymer Compact: Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0" included on the Quick List at the top of the article?
Hey Paul, we forgot to click the button that puts it there but it's been remedied and should be listed in the Quick List now. Thanks for reading!
Why didn't the Glock 43X make the cut?
It's a sub-compact.
The 43x is NOT a sub compact.
Hey William, thanks for reading and dropping us a comment. In short, we don't have enough room to list every gun we like on our Best of lists. I like the G43X, I think it's a solid choice especially for concealed carry. We do update these articles regularly and the G43X may make an appearance in the future, so check back! Thanks!
Put away those sissy pistols and get a 5906 or a 1911, young men..
I would have included the CZ P-01 on the list, but that’s just because it fits my hands so well and it’s an all metal, DA/SA pistol. Personal preference, in other words.
I just bought a Ruger Max 9 with optic. This weapon is a dream but no one ever rights it up..
It runs around $500.00 with optic
I have never had a jam and it shoots where you point it. Really what more do you need in a mid line compact. It holds 10 plus one down the pipe and has a physical safety. Urban carry makes an outstanding leather lock in holster for it.
If anyone needs to carry a gun, it’s all the whackos in Washington State. Folks in Washington, just carry a mini 9mm and shoot everyone in site.
I would like to read a little more about the Sig M11A1. I have owned many sidearms over the years, the best so far, Kimber 9mm Rapide and M11A1 Sig Sauer. The Sig has about the best trigger pull after the first shot. 36 shots 35-X and a ten. The ten I might have sneezed.
I like my Ruger SR9C - goes bang every time, can shoot +P ammo. Only paid $375.00 for it about eight years ago. With extended mag holds 17 rounds, 10 in the flush mag. After just some polishing on the stock trigger, 4lb pull and clean break. With stainless slide it is also a great looking gun. For all Glock haters, it does field strip without a trigger pull.
It is a solid one. It is one of my two CCW's. I bet my life on it...
Love the SR9C trigger. Everyone who has shot this gun comments on the trigger.
I think yalls input has gone to shit. You initially presented your input as SME from within the SOF community now I see you have Jacki Billings as your SME? WTF does she know or understand about a visceral experience with using firearms to protect herself or others while working nor understand that need? Her credibility is working on her blackbelt in Yongmudo? WTF is that ridiculousness? I was a Weapons sergeant in 1/10th Group SFA (A)and later as an Infantry Drill Segreant at fort Benning before becoming an AH-64 D pilot. I've worked all over the world in conflict. She must have some personal affiliation with an editor or someone in yalls organization to put forth BS about nothing she truly knows about. Because no one with any common sense would place her in this position without some sort of personal leverage. Go woke and go broke. No longer will I look towards yalls BS as knowledge or input.
I do have a personal affiliation with the editor. I am THE editor. I have a wide range of knowledge and skillsets that landed me this wonderful job at PPT. I worked hard to be here. I am not prior military or LE, but I've never pretended to be. What I am is an ardent lover of guns, believer that the Second Amendment is for everyone, protector of my family and home, and most importantly someone who wants to use my skillset to help grow the shooting sports. Thank you for your feedback, Jason, and thank you for your service.
Well, all you have going for you is the fact that you are a wonderful person.
Thank you for imparting your knowledge to me.
Jason,
Jacki Billings is an outstanding editor I’ve worked with at different publications for many years now. Her qualifications for her job are brand perfect. Furthermore, Pew Pew Tactical has never represented itself as SMEs from the SOF community. Around here we are more committed to providing good information to a wide audience, sharing our love of firearms, and not taking ourselves too seriously. The fact that you are so far off base about who we are makes me question the impetus for your comment, among other things. Don’t let the door hit you on the way out.
Jason, are you this rude to everyone? And didn’t your mother ever teach you how to treat a lady? Get some help, dude. Seriously.
Why are you so... angry?
Classic misogynistic BS. Jason may be mil but he obvs has a vey small mind.
I like your choices. I would have specified the VP9-B with button mag release rather than the paddles. Of course, you can learn to run the paddles, but why go with such an off-beat, wonky feature? I no longer think of these pistols as "compact." The Sig X-Macro (give me an XL slide, please) and Springfield Hellcat Pro now define the compact market. Except for the Taurus, these are all full-size pistols.
Oh my fine friends at Pew Pew Tactical. Hold on for a few microns of time. You need to get the paws on the new Staccato CS. Oh such a gift from the Gun Gods!
We're hopefully getting one soon!
Oh my fine friends at Pew Pew Tactical. Hold on for a few microns of time. You need to get the paws on the new Staccato CS. Oh such a gift from the Gun Gods!
I have only had one gun a long time ago an it almost got my 1 yr old daughter killed by me leaving it loaded an not secure. That happened 40 yrs ago ,and l have been trying to convince my wife to get a hand gun for home
Protection, so your advice is greatly appreciated.
Oh my fine friends at Pew Pew Tactical. Hold on for a few microns of time. You need to get the paws on the new Staccato CS. Oh such a gift from the Gun Gods!
Why aren't the Canik pistols ever included in the "Best of ..." articles? I have read and watched several reviews online and they all praise them. All of the articles like this one always talk about the same big name brands. Maybe someone should write an article about the lesser known brands and compare them just like you have for the big name ones.
This article was based on guns I've had time with. If it's not included, it's not a knock on that gun, just that I haven't thoroughly tested it as much as some of these others. I don't want to recommend something I haven't had lots of time behind. But we are constantly updating articles as we get in guns and test them so there's always room for additions down the line. Thanks for reading!
CZ P-01 - Excellent choice. I’d never put a list like this together without it. Better trigger than anything on this list and probably the most accurate. The low bore axis, ergonomic grip and natural pointing characteristics make it very enjoyable to shoot.
Most of this list is made up of Glock clones. I happen to love my G17 but it’s not the whole story, not by far. Cheers!
sig p365
YES! I have the sig p365 and love it - been shooting if for about 6 years. Works well for CC for me. (I am female). Willing to try the Taurus G3C - will rent it at a range. Love the price too. Great presentation!
What about the CZ P-10C
You left out one of the greatest compact 9mm pistol of all time! OK, maybe that’s TOO deliberately provocative. Let’s just say you left out MY favorite carry pistol. Hint for all you striker-fired, polymer-pistol fans born after 1988: It is all-metal, DA/SA with de-cocker, holds 15 +1, and weighs 28 ounces. It’s the CZ P-01. If you are an old-school (I almost said “old f_rt”) DA/SA shooter who likes the feel of metal in your hand, the P-01 can’t be beat. Personally, l love the ergonomics as well as the care with which these pistols are built by the Czechs. Despite what I said up front to get your attention, this is just one person’s opinion.
You sir, made my day. This was going through my mind the whole time while reading the article. I'm actually a younger generation but do not like striker fired pistols, I have many da/sa pistols in turn tho. I couldn't help but notice every pistol on here was striker fired.
Choose what you want however it appears that pew pew tactical has a bias against hammer fired handguns. I admit to being old school but hammer fired handguns have a long history of excellence and reliability.
No bias here! We only have so much space available. If we listed every gun we loved...that list would be super long. That said, we update these articles often, so we'll definitely consider adding some models in that aren't striker fired next go around. Thanks for reading!
They usually have better triggers too!
Every time you guys post THAT photo of popular pistol cartridges, you do realize you are missing the 32ACP cartridge?? (And the 25ACP) It’s been one of the most popular cartridges in history since John Moses Browning developed it in 1899. Maybe you need to re take that photo…..
I own most of these gun (don't have the Glock, sig, or Taurus) great list, id also throw in a CZ P10C (which i also kind of own, state police put a "delay" on my 4473 10 months ago and have yet to resolve it, so its paid for but its not mine yet).
My main carry piece is my VP9, the slide is milled for and equipped with an RMR06, carry in a darkstargear Orion (which has some issues, but is good enough for now) and I'm eventually getting my trigger upgraded by rick Holmes at lazy wolf triggers (going with the Vickers special)
PDP, and the M&P are right up there too, but the VP9 is the only one I have an optic on right now.
No Glock 26? Probably the best all around (cost, size, capacity, safety) conceal carry handgun in the history of the planet. Some of y’all’s articles are really skeptical.
Agreed - missing the Glock 26 is quite an oversight. Especially since it can take Glock 26. 17 and 19 magazines.
This has got to be THE most confusing review ever.
Best all around was a Blocked court because we all know, PewPew loves Glocks! $539
Best High End is an HK... that is ONLY $10 more than the Glock. $549
Editors Choice, the Walther PDP that is... $10 more than the Best High End selection! $559
How on Earth is the Walther PDP, which I happen to carry and adore, more than the High End? Shouldn't the high end have been something like a Staccato C2?
a, ,
Unfortunately prices shift pretty rapidly so when we publishing something, sometimes what we pick is "high end" but by the next day prices shift. We do our best to keep up with that but with thousands of articles on the site, it's impossible. We do update often, though, and we will consider some new titles based on that observation. Thanks for reading!
Guess you haven't shot a SIG p229 legion.
Glock 48
Well the field is becoming too overlapping and homogenized. Some other great options are the
Palmetto State Armory Dagger, the IWI Masada and the thin line model of the IWI masada. The Dagger accepts virtuall all Glock 19 Gen 3 afters and the Masada shoot way great out of the box and are VERY reasonably priced.
Just my 2 cents.
Rick
Agreed on the Masada, very nice gun! I will find a spot for an IWI somewhere.
Have seen G19’s reliably work in some of the worst conditions on the planet, with little to no maintenance from the foreign nationals who carried them.
Hellcat Pro hands down.
Yes, Thank you!
Hellcat Pro hands down.
Beretta apx Centurion very nice
Surprised you omitted CZ P01 CZ P10S and CZ P10C
Agree x3
CZ P10c should garner a mention.
where cz p10c/ p07
Sig is mass-market trash. Glock is perfection. That is all.
//Signed (with love),
No Sig for Sid
No one is talking about Grand Power. I have several Grand Powers. My favorite is X-Calibur. It's not a compact, but it is absolutely one of the best pistols available.
I'm now confused about choosing between two of S&Ws 9mm M&P2.0 models.
Previously, I decided to start looking for the Compact 4" model rather than the Full Size 4.25". Their specs seemed really close to each other [I expected the 0.25" shorter barrel could slightly affect performance, but that the Sight Radius difference being only 0.1" might offset some of that]. However, the Compact seemed like a more versatile overall choice because, using the 17+1 magazine (& spacer), it has the same capacity & height as the Full Size, but, when using the 15+1 magazine, it might be better for CC use than the Full Size. That's how I got to what I thought was my choice
HOWEVER, after I read PPT's "Best Beginner Handgun" & "Best Compact Pistol" lists here, I'm again confused.
PPT's "Best Beginner" list puts the Glock 19 Compact as #1 (& that's just fine) and puts the "Full Size" M&P2.0 right behind it at #2.
Post's "Best Compact" list also puts the Glock 19 at #1, but I was then surprised to see four other pistols listed before the list mentions the M&P2.0 "Compact"as #6.
What am I missing? Is there THAT much difference between the Full Size & Compact M&P2.0 models when compared to the Glock 19? If so, can those differences please be identified?
Thanks.
My suggestion, get both m&ps and both glocks, but of thats not an option, get tge least exspencive or most comfertable ones, though I have only used a m&p, ive heard all are good choices
If you plan to conceal carry, I’d go with the M&P shield plus. Then buy the full-size for home defense
They are just that close in quality. That is my opinion and that of many I shoot with. My brother crushes it at a range with his FN and I am a Glock guy. Find what YOU like and practice! Do not buy something you won't shoot enough to get good with. I have sold many micro-carry 9mm guns because I can't get the grip I need to shoot well, even with practice. It is critical that you can fire the gun you carry well. That cannot be overstated!
No caniks???smh
Why no caniks?
Caniks are awesome and very underrated. I have let Glock fans and 2011 fans shoot my METE SFX and their silence says a lot!
Agreed. I love my Canik TP9SF Elite. My next gun is the SC Canik.
I would also agree the CZ p10 C is very accurate with a crisp clean trigger pull among being very reliable and dependable I haven't had any problems
In my opinion, you should have included the CZ 75D PCR. Excellent fit, finish, weight and very accurate. A really fine pistol from the Czech Republic.
Great rundown on this gun you should have mentioned that a 17 round clip is available but no biggy.
It isn't a clip. It's a magazine.
I'll bet you say "suppressor" instead of "silencer", too. Calling magazines "clips" dates back to WWII and has become common (if not accurate) usage. We know what he means. The clip vs. magazine distinction is a piece of gun snobbery from Cooper's era that needs to go away.
CZ P10C
You left off the Beretta PX4 Storm Subcompact! A very nice DA/SA double-stack 9mm SMALL handgun, which feels like a big gun in your hand. Holds 13+1, just a tad too fat to pocket carry, but otherwise a very nice gun. Use grease, not oil, on the slide, and this gun will soon become your favorite handgun.
+1
Don’t forget Sig Sauer 226 & 229 (M11-A1) aree we both excellent concealed carry firearms.
Recently picked up a Canik TP9SF Elite. Great trigger and very right sized. A little top heavy, but eats recoil. Thoughts?
I love my Canik, same model. It eats any ammo and shoots true right out of the box. I love it.
Have you guys shot the HK P30SK? Pretty solid list in this article for affordability and reliability....as well as easy/comfortable to carry. While I love steel framed like CZ and Walther, most aren't going to carry those daily, especially in the warmer months.
how in the world did you leave out CZ. Both p10c and p10s maybe the best triggers on the market.
You are correct Sir. I have both.
I think this is a very short-sighted list given that they are all polymer striker-fired. Where are the hammer-fired and/or metal/steel/aluminum guns? Guns like the CZ P01?
My favorite is the Glock 48 MOS. I have 11 rounds with factory mags and 16 with Shield Arms mags and a longer barrel than the Glock 19, all in a slimmer profile.
True, there aren't as many aftermarket parts and accessories as with the G19, but that is changing.
What do you know about the Springfield Hellcat?
The CZ PO7 is my EDC I prefer a hammer gun. It's a great shooting gun
Everyone has their favourites. I found the Beretta APX Centurion to have the trigger and price I like best. So much that I also bought the full size APX too. And I already own the others... FN, Glock, Springfield, S&W, Ruger and Taurus.
I have to say the px4 storm compact 9mm with rotary barrel makes a fine conceal compact weapon
You list the Taurus G3C and before the Canik TP9SF Elite??? The Canik has a trigger that matches Walther and H&K and resembles the Walther ppq ergonomics. It is a superior gun to the Taurus G3C!
You listed the XDM which is fantastic, but the newest version is the game changer! XDM Elite OSP 3.8” in 10mm with 11 + 1. A concealable red dot pistol in 10mm is at home, concealed or open carry in the city as well as hiking the desert or forest.
I can't believe the p365 xl wasn't on the list. But at the same time I've been eye Ballin that 320.
How can you leave out the Hi-Point C9? Compact, light weight, low price, smooth lines and a lifetime warranty is pretty hard to beat. And it's P+ rated!
Taurus over mentioning a CZ? thats surprising.
Where's the CZ P10C or the P07?
I find it hard to believe that the Taurus comes out better than the CZ offerings.
I was going to say the same thing. A list this long without a CZ is almost criminal.
Every time I go through one of the multi-gun reviews, I look to see if the Canik TP9 series is included. In a negative way, I am not disappointed because they never are. Whether TP9 compact or the subcompact TP9SC, they are never included. Why not? Every time I see the same brands over and over, just the model or configuration is different.
The FNS-9C has been out for a while, now. I'm a bit surprised that you included the FN 509, which seemingly rates higher in your view. I've shot both, and prefer the FNS-9 compact. Its trigger is phenomenal, right out of the box, and the choice of magazines is a big plus.
Thinking you are overlooking the Ruger LC9s as a CCW. very concealable, no snag point on this slick pistol and it goes bang every time. Additional magazine can be carried but as we know most gun fights are over very quickly.
Another great read! I have carried a Glock 43 with a 9 shot backup mag for 5 years now because I have been unable to conceal or comfortably carry my 19. Maybe if I lived in Mogadishu or Detroit I would give it another try. Thanks for what you do!
I cannot believe the new Walther PDP compact isn't included in this list.
Funny - in the bit about the M and P there are two photos provided here however neither are of the M and P 2.0 compact (which is exactly the same size as the G19)! The first photo shows two full size M and P's and the second photo is the M and P subcompact........!!! (The M and P 2.0 compact has two bars on the picatinny rail)
PDP won Editors Choice??? For concealed I believe it was assumed the were referring to the Compact. I have a C4 I adore.
I carry a Colt Officer’s 45.
I carry a Ruger American compact,can go 10 +1 or 17 + 1
P30SK has been my EDC for just over five years now. I see no reason to change that.
1st define best. That's different for each of us. For us it needed to be affordable, simple to use in an emergency, accurate at self defense distances and of course reliable. We each have a SCCY CPX-2. Comes with 2 mags, 3.1 barrel, 10+1 capacity, finger groove grip, DAO hammer fired and adjustable rear site. No manual safety. You get used to the longer 8lb trigger by dry firing maybe 100 times or so. I can "stage" the trigger right at the breaking point easily if I want. Best part is only $218 for one and $258 for the other. Not a single glitch in hundreds of rounds. Fill with Federal HST 150 grain MICRO ammo and it's a stopper. Fairly loud with those shells too. Been very happy with them. Made in Florida and great warranty.
A SCCY CPX2 is my “boat gun”. Never has failed to go bang during lots and lots of rounds downrange. I generally load the mags with Speer GD 124 gr HPs.
I like the CZ 75D PCR for compact carry…
In my opinion the Cz p01 is the best compact carry pistol .
As far as 'compact 9s' go, as an LEO and civilian I've carried pretty much everything under the Sun. My personal favorites, starting with my current EDC, are: S&W SD9 in FDE, Kimber Stainless Pro Carry, SIG P239, Walther P99, and S&W 3904.
As far as 'compact 9s' go, as an LEO and civilian I've carried pretty much everything under the Sun. My personal favorites, starting with my current EDC, are: S&W SD9 in FDE, Kimber Stainless Pro Carry, SIG P239, Walther P99, and S&W 3904.
The Walther PDP is notably absent from this list and for no good reason. It has a much better grip than the slippery HK, has a better fit and finish than all except maybe a tie with the Sig P320, holds 18 rounds standard (so 3 more than these) or 15 in the "compact" version, is optics ready, and is as reliable as the day is long.
Although these pistol may qualify as compacts, they are on the large side. I don't consider them 'compact'.
I have a different take on the whole thing. In my experience, having shot different pistols and sizes and weights, etc., you cant expect a very small pistol to have the same qualities as a big one. I dont like full size pistols but they perform better. Getting some heft for recoil management, length for distance accuracy, it really makes a difference. A CV 75 SP-01 is all steel and isnt compact but what a shooter it is. If the aim here is light and small, fine go ahead, but dont believe that you can keep going forever smaller and lighter while expecting the same results as a bigger and heavier pistol. Dont think tiny and light first, think what youre really going to do with a pistol and then shop for that. If you have the budget for all types, of course thats nice too.
I had a couple of the guns on your list then bought a CZ P-01. Best gun ever. Only gun I carry now, for the last 3 yrs. Don't think I'll ever go back to a striker fire.
Canik 18 and 20 rd 9mm mags also fit the G2c and G3c nicely.
When I was shopping for my handgun, my FFL recommended the G19 first. It was nice, but when shown a Canik TP9 Elite SC, I was sold. Although it is marketed as a subcompact, it looks and feels
Like a compact. It has a shorter barrel (3.6") and the clips hold 12 or15 rounds, but I like the feel and better (heavier) weight The grip has a better angle for me. The Glock grip angle does not feel natural to me.
Why all of the big heavy pistols?
All of the new micro 9's make all of these obsolete.
Totally agree. VP9sk, vp30sk, Sig 365xl, etc, etc. 13-15 rounds, slimmer, lighter, more easily carried.................
How about the Beretta compact?
I like the mossberg Mc2c9mm. The barrel is less than 4 inches which makes it a compact to me and the width is very trim at 1.1 inches and weighs 21 ozs. It works for me.
Although I most often carry a S&W 9mm Shield, I must confess that I concur with your affection for the Mossberg MC2c. In fact, I’m smitten by it and 15 rd mags only magnify my feelings for it. Feels good in hand, excellent shooter, dependable, and a damn fine looking pisto.
Newer to guns. After trying different guns at the range I kept coming back to the VP9 as my choice. Definitely more comfortable in my hands. I am confused about one thing, and that could be my own ignorance. I thought the VP9 was H&K's full size handgun and the SK was their compact version, which did not feel comfortable to shoot. Either way good article.
Try the VP9 SK with the 13 round extended mag. With all fingers on the grip it's much more comfortable and it shoots just as well as the full size.
One of my favorites in this category is the Glock G45. G19 slide with a G17 frame.
Over the past 40+ years I have carried (on duty and off) everything from an S&W 3904 to a Walther P99, to the Glock G17, 19, 22, and 34, to a Kimber ProCarry 9mm, and my current EDC, an S&W SD9 in FDE. My favorites have been the P99, the ProCarry, and the SD9.
I wondered this about the S&W SD9, it felt good to me, but never shot one. Never had a chance to see the P99.
I have the Sig, which I converted to the carry version, the Wilson Combat grip in an FDE, now I love it! It feels even better.
The G23 never really felt right, but liked it better converted to a 9mm.
I recently picked up the Taurus G3C & really like this a lot! I have the G43, the G43X, and I carry the Taurus more often.
It conceals about like the G43, yet is 12 +1, with a 17 round backup.
A nice pistol, not just nice for the money, about 1/2 what the Glocks & Sig cost, but for me, it’s right there with them.
Over the past 40+ years I have carried (on duty and off) everything from an S&W 3904 to a Walther P99, to the Glock G17, 19, 22, and 34, to a Kimber ProCarry 9mm, and my current EDC, an S&W SD9 in FDE. My favorites have been the P99, the ProCarry, and the SD9.
Guys this is compact not sub compact review. My feedback is that this article didn’t get much thought. Taurus and Ruger are really not as deserving to be on this list and the FN doesn’t make sense in that configuration even though probably a great gun. As others have said I’d look at Beretta and then Canik (both cheaper as well probably) long before Taurus n Ruger in this list.
There are so many missing guns that would correctly fit within this concept that the article is of little or no help. Why waste our time?
It's their ranking of the 8 they think are best. Looks like you're expecting something completely different, despite what the headline said.
I had a Glock 19 gen3 it's a great gun. I changed to a G26 ge5 for EDC. For cold weather or home defense I use my old duty weapon a G22 gen4. If I'm carrying a larger gun I want a larger bullet. But the Glock deserves to be at the top of the compact list. My choice for top pick in the subcompact goes to the G26.
They Hellcat and the P320 are both covered under their sub-compact article. However, I don’t see the IWA Masada here.
After trying the sig's and Glock's I decided on the Kimber Micro 9 for a compact carry. Recently upgraded to the Micro 9 with the laser grip.
Why no mention of any double/single action compacts. There are a lot of us older folks that have been into handguns for many, many years like sense the 1950's that don't trust guns without a hammer. I admit that I am a old coot at 80, I don't own anything without a hammer, my every day carry is the Beretta PX4 compact, and why any male would would carry anything appendix carry without a hammer just blows my mind. One day they might regret that way of carrying.
I love my CZ PCR! Hammer fired, single/double action. Decocker model.
Wow no mention of the Hellcat or Sig P365? Not sure how these could have missed this list..
Just looked ahead looks like I was late to the Party with my comment......... I will leave it as a redundancy, as I have both............
Both are more sub-compact than compact, highly recommend both!
You missed probably the most reliable of all, the CZ P07.
That’s all I have to say.
And the p10c
Yeah...I have no idea how a "top 5 or 8 or 10" list of compact 9mm pistols can exclude the P10C. It comes stock cheaper than Glock with better sights, better trigger, AND better mags. I would put it's reliability up against the glock 19 any day.
The P225 or 229 are not listed. This is bad forum from a site that calls it's self Pew Pew Tactical.
Not one pistol is hammer fired, or have a metal frame.
Look at the Canik TP9SF some time. It's basically a Walther yet they have done their own work, qualified for NATO issue by passing the testing, and are an excellent firearm. At $200 UNDER most of the ones mentioned they are definitely a lot of bang for the buck. They are owned by an aeronautical supplier to Airbus and Lockheed, they have the bones to do high quality work.
If I have one gripe it's that they haven't offered something like the P320. The modular trigger unit is a concept that has shoved traditional framed guns to the back of the line - including Glock, who is, if you think about it, approaching 40 years old. Another ten after that and they will have used models shipping to C&R collectors. They aren't really innovating any more and certainly took their time getting a single stack in the line up. Goes to their evident bias in selling arms to military and LEO's, not the people. Colt made that mistake and it's hurt them for years.
Point being, if you really don't like a P320 - change the grip unit, keep your trigger. It doesn't require buying a whole new gun. That's why SIG amplified that modularity with the P365, and if you consider the XL model, you're tapping on the compact door from the other direction.
There will be no end to this, as others move to modular trigger units, we will be able to outfit a small attache case of grips, slides and magazines for specific conditions, all based off just one trigger unit. HK offered that a long time ago, just as they pioneered polymer long before Glock. It's going to be an exciting ride.
You left out the Bersa TPR9c. Fits my hand, damned good sights, 15+1 mags, eats any 9mm ammo you want to feed it. And less cost than any of the 'wonder nines' that are mentioned in the article. The Bersa is one serious pistol.
No hellcat, P365, or G43x... interesting.
We consider those even tinier at sub-compacts! https://www.pewpewtactical.com/single-stack-sub-compact-9mms/
Then it gets even more complicated with the P365/hellcat maybe not technically single-stack...
Walther PPQ M.2
I definitely agree, Oscar. The PPQ has a trigger that is better than most on this list, except maybe the VP9. It is smaller than the Springfield and it also has a compact version. Walther PPQ is definitely better than the Ruger and probably the S&W, too. More ppl would be pleasantly surprised if they only tried it. Walther has a rep for high-quality.
P.S. I also have a Glock -17, a P320, and VP9SK, among others. All high quality. I use different Guns for different situations and it’s hard to say any one firearm is the best. Just saying Walther PPQ definitely belongs on the list.
I have shot every gun on this list, I agree the PPQ should be on it. Easily the best trigger, the VP9 is close but slightly less refined than the Walther. I chose the PPQ as my EDC.
My PPQ M2 is my hands down go to gun...stock trigger far better than those listed in the review (including my Sigs...).
Cz p07 or Cz p10c
I’m a 78 year-old man who started taking a class and shooting a hand gun in February. After trying over a dozen different pistols over a few weeks, I bought a Walther PPQ M2. I have since fired over 500 rounds with no problems. Great grip and trigger for me. That’s just me. There are many good guns.
The CZ P07 is a sweet shooter and light enough for concealed carry. I fired a Sig 320 and prefer the CZ P07 hands down.
What is the first gun pictured?
HK USP Compact!
CZ P10C
Well I have to say after reading this article that the author has an "interesting perspective" on things in my mind...
FIrst off, The VP9 really isn't a compact pistol. It's far more full size than a Glock 19 or 509, albeit certainly a really excellent shooting gun.
Second, the 509 is without question the best out of the box gun on this list, with maybe the exception of the not so compact VP9. It's also a much more pleasing gun visually than the Glock, M&P, and the XD.
The XD is also a bit bloated for this list and is really "full size or duty size" and they're not exactly heralded for their reliability.
IMHO, and I own or have owned, or shot all of these guns, the three real compact do it all not going to fail, strong competitors are the 509, the M&P 2.0 9C and the Glock and in that order of best value for the money.
If you want to go buy new sights, new trigger, custom stilples, etc buy the 600 dollar Glock and spend 400 more to make it what it should be for 600 or, buy 509 for 550, or the M&P for 550 and go shoot, carry and love it the way it came..
Peace, and remember just one man's opinion.
I will take my FN FNS9 for EDC. Fits my hand perfectly, accurate, nice tactile reset and much more accurate than I am. I got such a good deal on it NIB that I couldn’t turn it down.
Bersa TPR9C Is my fav.
Here's one of the most important aspects of handguns stated in the article.
"When shopping for a compact 9mm, the primary thing to look for is how it feels in your hand."
If the handgun does not fell comfortable in one's hand, whatever the caliber, the owner/shooter will probably not shoot it enough to become proficient. Rent and shoot several handguns and become familiar with the re-coil and erognomics. If you're constantly regripping the gun it's not right, in my opinion.
I own several makes of handguns in 380, 9MM, .38/.357, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP. I'm not brand snobby. I own guns I know I can shoot well.
I have the Glock Gen4 and the SM MP2, both great. Like the look and feel of the S&M a little more overall. But, carry either. I'm not really one for modifying after the fact, but do have laser sites, which are fun. Can't go wrong with either. The Glock is kind of stupid easy to have and reliable, plus, easy to find used pretty cheap. I've fired a ton through both, never a jam with the Glock, one issue with the S&M, while shooting reloads through both, but likely the reload, only happened with one, one time...
I recommend looking into a Diamondback AM2. It almost the same size a S&W Shield but, the AM2 holds twelve rounds in the flush fit mag. The larger, extended magazine holds 17 rounds.
After shooting & training with a HK USP .40 full size for over five years (hey, it was already paid for), I finally made the move to a 9mm. Shopping around, I found the S&W M&P 9 2.0 full size fit my hand best (with the medium-large backstrap insert). Taking it out on our first date, I found the trigger to be everything the HK trigger was not; crisp, not weighty & with a very positive, easy-to-find reset that provides for a very consistent break. Accuracy is superb with 15 yard groups printing as one ragged hole not too difficult to obtain. The VP-9 trigger is also excellent right out of the box but the overall fit of the Smith was better for moi. Several shooter folk who have compacts of various makes, comment that mag changes can be somewhat painful if the lower portion of their hand pooches into the well causing the occasional blood blister. Full size versions of most fighting guns have sufficient handle length to avoid this depending on hand size and maintaining proper grip. Thank you for your indulgence.
I'm a 66yr old going on 40 and getting my ccw training for single woman safety. I have Taurus 357 for another other location but needed smaller to carry and this was very helpful with pointers on accessories etc. to make decision for test drives. Cross this one off bucket list. Thanks Trevor!!
Hi Cathy if you're still looking, the Taurus G2C is a hugely great value for the money and all but a few examples have been extremely reliable and affordable guns.
I second the Taurus G2C. I have the older version PT111 G2 and have ran many boxes of FMJ and JHP through it. No FTF or FTE. This one fit my hand best. I also have a Springfield XD Mod.2 4" service model which also fits my hand pretty good, but I'm not as accurate with that one as I am the Taurus. The Taurus I'm VERY accurate with at 15yd groups. I also backup what MugsMalone stated above. Test hold MANY and don't be afraid to take your time and keep going back and forth until you find the right one that feels that best in your hand.
I find it odd that the photo of the handgun you’re using for your buyers guide of the “ 7 Best Compact 9mm Handguns”, is not one of your 7 best. You’ve got the H&K VP9 in your 7 best, but the photo used in the part of the guide about good fit and as the title photo shows the USP Compact 9.
Ruger and Springfield - really?
Forgot all about the Walther PPQ and CZ's.
My next purchase top contender didn't make the list; the CZ 75D PCR Compact, nor the similar CZ P01 with an accessory rail. You might want to check them out..
Not a huge Glock fan but the 43x does have my eye for a new CCW for myself! Any idea on price and release date?
My Walther PPS M2. Great firearm for the price, right out of the box. 500 rounds in, and still reliable, accurate, and concealable.
I have several of the guns on this list and some that aren't. The one that doesn't get any love is the Beretta px4 storm subcompact. I just seem to keep coming back to it, it's become my favorite.
Tristar C100, CZ75 Semi Auto 9mm Clone. good as CZ75. with less money.
I have a Ruger SR9C and its replacement the Ruger American compact. Yhe American is a little heavier which I actually like. I carry the American every day. Which I can conceal but it does print. The SR9C I carry when I am wearing something that doesnt conceal well. Dress clothing or shorts. The American holds 12+1 with a 17+1 back up clip. SR9 holds 10+1 with the same backup. I love them both.
You kinda have to wonder how qualified one is when they put Glock and Springfield in the same boat..
You're right. The glock doesn't hold a note to the xdm. Buying a glock is like buying a Harley. There are more reliable bikes out there, but some people just feel they have something to prove.
There is a definite bias against metal guns. The CZ p01 should be on this list.
Too many polymeraphiles.
Once you shoot all steel you will not go back to plastic.
great list, keep them coming!
VP9SK!
Hello, nice list. However, I agree with Tom regarding the legality of handguns in CA. Many are not available. The CA DOJ also recently culled the list and quite a few that were available in 2017 are not in 2018. Anyway, my pick not on your list is the CZ 75D Compact, Superb firearm with excellent accuracy and feels great in the hand.
I agree with Dave on the CZ; I have a PCR, which lacks the rail that adorns the Compact. AWESOME in the hand for those of use who prefer that grip pitch. I've yet to find a stock holster I'm happy with, so a trip to the custom shop is in my future. However, it's practically identical in size to the Glock 19 Gen3 and doesn't worry a hole in the pad of your trigger finger the way the Glock does. Buy the Self Defense Package from Cajun GunWorks and you'll be a happy shooter.. Truly!
Happy me: I'm an Alaskan and don't have to worry about the CA Horse Hockey!!
Definitely sad face in CA...
fk ca and that bs. move or vote brother it only going to get worse! All these guns are great just depends on you just get one. I have shot all of them and own others.
Hello Trevor, I understand that you need to be relevant to the greatest audience. However, if you are a California resident most of the "Best of..." articles on gun choices are not very relevant as most are not available for sale in California. I know it is a little extra work, but would it be too much to ask for you all to add NA CA to your gun pick articles? Thanks
A great compact 9mm that you don't hear about often is the Beretta Nano. I purchased my Nano a little over three years ago and it quickly became my prime EDC pistol. I bought mine with a factory installed LaserMax red laser. It initially had some issues with FTE, but some research and changing out the factory polymer guide rod with a stainless steel rod completely remedied those issues. It's small, accurate and handles all 9mm up to +P. You can also purchase different color shells and swap the serialized portion of the gun between them, which is an easy process. Although I have other Semi-Auto's in 9mm, 40 S/W and 45ACP, I mostly carry my Nano as my EDC PDW.
Hi Trevor,
How is it the CZP10c didn't make your list? It is every bit as good as the Glock 19. With some better features.
My added comment will be scorned because of price however, for ccw you want 100% reliability! The BULLPUP 9 meets that need. Conceals very good, weighted for perfect handling, smooth firing trigger,excellently crafted..I also own a RUGER LC9s model 03279 which I upgraded with Galloway Precision captured sure feed guide rod assembly and Hogue beavertail grip..Both additions improved the weapons handling and smoothness of operation. however, when if the time ever comes ( and I hope not ) I will rely on my BULLPUP 9.. In any case the weapon that you trust and works for you is the one you should carry. Best to all.
Sig Sauer P229 is a great compact handgun with a long tradition of use by both our police, military and civilians. A nice alternative for those who might prefer metal over plastic. With 15+1 capacity, the P229 9mm sports many of the advantages of its full size cousin the P226. While the P229 costs more than the other guns on the list, Sig Sauer's quality and reputation have made it a classic.
My wife owns the Legion version of the P229. It has an amazing SA trigger and reset that is beyond belief. However, she carries the P938 BRG, which pistol is a little more challenging to handle due to it's diminutive size (at 16 oz empty). That said, with practice, I find I handle it better than it's mid-size sibling. ME? I carry a CZ PCR that is not compatible in operation to the 1911 format of the P938. However, I can shoot the Czech gun much better than the small Sig. I still prefer my S&W Model 28 Revolver to all three of these pistols. :-)
That is most definitely not a gen5 glock picture
when looking at m&p compact the guy behind the counter told me to look at the sccy.
Bought it and have never been happier..it is my edc
Nice set.
My cz75 compact is the best I’ve found, at least it works best for me.. Superb shooting with doublestack, 2 carry options, from their site—> “a manual safety lever provides the user with two options for carry: hammer-back with the safety on for single action operation or manually decocked for a double action first shot with no need to remember to take off the safety before firing”.
and weight, giving me a smooth action when I might be a bit less than steady. I don’t plan to be. But who knows?
I’m new(ish) to firearms and after trying many styles, this is it for me.. I’m female and have a weaker grip than I used to, as well, and my cz75b compact is the answer. :-)
Laurie, you have a great gun! I have the PCR, which is decock only. Being a revolver guy, I don't like having a safety on my pistol That's what queered me on the Beretta M9, which I can shoot like it's a part of me. I went with the PCR and would only wish I'd picked the Compact D for the rail. Now looking at a snubby revolver; maybe the new Colt Cobra cuz J-frame trigger is SOOOooooo stiff out of the box.
Where is the Taurus pt111 or pt140?
Great price point, wonderful feel in the hand, eats anything, and accuracy is it's best quality.
I’m with you for the price and accuracy the Taurus G2C is a great compact 9, 12+1 with a good feel in the hand. The only thing I can knock it for is the long trigger pull but for the price it’s hard to beat. Over 1500 rds through mine and no issues.
I have the Ruger SR9C and really like it, but I EDC with my Ruger LC9S.. It is easier for me to conceal using my IWB holster and less bulky.
I was honestly surprised that CZ wasnt on this list.
All good guns but I think the Walther PPQ would rank up there to.