Best 1911’s Chambered in 9mm

When you think 1911…you think big .45 ACP.

.45 ACP Ball vs Hollowpoint
.45 ACP Ball vs Hollowpoint

The .45 ACP incorporated a 230-grain bullet at about 850 feet per second in a semi-automatic platform and proved to be a very reliable and robust fighting handgun.

An Original Colt M1911, the 1911 That Started It All

So what if we take the original 1911 and build a pistol around the 9mm round?  Then we have the simple reliability of the 1911 in a very easy to shoot cartridge with a very good record as a defensive round.  

9mm (115gr vs 124gr vs 147 HP)
9mm (115gr vs 124gr vs 147 HP)

Best 9mm 1911s

1. Colt Defender

First up on our list is the compact Defender, a prime example of a compact 1911 in 9mm.  

Best Compact 9mm 1911
at Cabela's

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

Here we have a ready-to-carry handgun in a classic Colt package.  A 3” barrel, housed in a slide with genuine Novak Night Sights,  and an 8-round magazine make this gun easy to reach for when heading out the door.  

With a beavertail grip safety and left-side thumb safety, anyone who has any trigger time with a 1911 will be right at home with this fine pistol in their hands.  You’re paying a bit more than for a plastic-fantastic… but you’re getting a Colt!

2. Colt Combat Commander

The Colt Combat Commander is a full-size, 4.25” barreled Colt pistol.  If you want a carry gun that you can be proud of, you need to check out this gun.  Just a few notable features include beautiful dark bluing, checkered black cherry grips, Novak sights, and 9-round single stack magazines.  

Best Commander-Size 9mm 1911
at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

For those with a full-size 1911 in 45 ACP, this is the perfect companion.  You get to shoot ammo that’s a bit cheaper, and it’s easy on the hands as far as recoil because this is an all-steel gun coming in at 33oz, unloaded. 

3. Desert Eagle 1911 C

Usually when you think Desert Eagle you think big, like autoloading pistols in .44 Magnum, .357 Magnum, and .50 Action Express.  

at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

It’s true, Magnum Research is famous for its big revolvers and big semi-autos, but they really should be famous for their quality, and the Desert Eagle 1911 Series is no exception.  The 1911 series is available in 3 different barrel lengths; C series are 4.33”, G series are 5.01”, and the U series are very compact 3” barreled pistols.

The 1911 series guns all ship with 2 magazines.  The compact U series have 8-rounders, the C and G series feature 9-round mags.

Features like a high ride beavertail grip safety, extended magazine release, extended thumb safety, and full-length stainless guide rod make these guns ready to carry or compete with right out of the box.  The bigger guns are all steel, while the 3” models have an aluminum frame.

4. Kimber Pro Carry II

Kimber America makes more 1911’s than any other company in America.  There are 19 different variations of 9mms alone to choose from.  Personally, I like the Pro Carry II.  It’s got a 4” barrel, so it’s a ‘Commander’ size gun and easy to conceal.

at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

The frame is aluminum, while the slide is steel and features low profile fixed sights.  The two-tone color scheme is classy looking, and the rosewood grips finish out the good looks.

There is a full-length guide rod to keep things running smoothly, and, at 28 oz., there is enough weight to keep the recoil at a minimum and keep you shooting all day long.  The Pro Carry magazines hold 9 rounds, so with one in the pipe you have 10 total rounds at your disposal.

What’s your take on the Kimber 9mm line?

Readers' Ratings

4.95/5 (217)

Your Rating?

5. Springfield Range Officer Compact

Springfield Armory has been building 1911’s since 1985 and currently has 11 offerings in 9mm.  The Range Officer Series has just about everything one could want in a solid performing 1911 handgun.  

Most Modern 9mm 1911
at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

It has classic good looks, with a matte anodized aluminum frame and Parkerized steel slide that houses a 4” barrel and full-length guide rod.

Up top, the Range Officer has a fiber optic front sight with a low-profile combat rear sight to get you quickly and easily on target.  The grips feature the Springfield Crossed Canon™ logo and diamond checkering in rosewood.  If you haven’t picked up on it, I’m a sucker for nice wood and dark, blued steel guns.  Each Range Officer ships with 2 8-round magazines.  

6. Ruger SR1911

Ruger entered the market 1911 in 2011, the 100th anniversary of the 1911 with their SR1911 series of guns.  Like everything Ruger does, these guns are robust, built in the US, and worth a close look if you want to add a 1911 to your collection.  

at Cabela's

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

Most Rugers are heavy, and this 9mm is no exception at 29.3 oz.  The frame is gray anodized aluminum and the slide is stainless with Novak 3-Dot sights.  To enhance accuracy the stainless slide and 4.25” barrel are machined on the same tooling and from the same bar stock. 

Like many of the fine 1911’s today the Ruger has a beavertail grip safety and extended thumb safety.

On many 1911’s the plunger tube for the thumb safety and the slide stop are staked to the frame., but on the Ruger, the plunger tube is integral to the frame and cannot become loose, damaged or bent.

There is a visual port to provide confirmation of a loaded chamber as well.

Magazine capacity is 9 rounds.  This is a great, no frills pistol that will provide a lifetime of service and shooting fun. 

7. Taurus 1911

Taurus is headquartered in Florida and with a team of 300 on site, manufactures some of the many Taurus offerings in the US, with some being manufactured and imported from Brazil.  The Taurus brand is synonymous with quality and the lifetime repair warranty the company provides is ready proof that they believe in the products they produce.

at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

Taurus currently has two 1911 9mm’s in the catalog.  Both are full-size, 5-inch barrel models.  One is all blued, the other all stainless finish.  Both feature Novak sights, black grips, and 9-round magazines.

at Brownells

Prices accurate at time of writing

Prices accurate at time of writing

In addition to the beavertail grip safety, the Taurus also has an ambidextrous thumb safety.  The inclusion of the safety makes a transition to weak hand shooting or those that are lefties much easier.  Definitely worth a look as you search for your perfect 1911 9mm. 

Keeping It Small

Of course this is just a sampling to whet your appetite for a new 1911 in 9mm.  Are these the best 9mm 1911’s?  With so many great guns on the market these days, it’s hard to say, but I believe they all represent fine quality, reliability, accuracy and availability.  

None are custom, but all include many features on pistols built by the finest custom shops.  They are all reliable, accurate and have the classic good looks that 1911’s should have.  

Of course, you may prefer a different 9mm 1911 (and if you do, tell us in the comments!), but these are all great options, and regardless of your decision, you can’t go wrong having a genuine 1911 in you collection.  After all, it’s one of those guns every gun nut needs.

Sig Sauer 1911 Match Elite
Sig Sauer 1911 Match Elite, Another Great 9mm 1911

Until next time, aim small!

21 Leave a Reply

  • Bob

    After leaving gun news daily where they listed a Beretta 92 and a fnx on there list of 9mm 1911's I can't say too much bad about this list.

    1 week ago
  • Albert

    For what it's worth; I buy a 'low cost' 1911, take it to my local 'pistolero gunsmith' and have him do a 'street job' on it. Reliable and runs like a rabbit.

    2 months ago
  • Jack Deaner

    I recently purchased a Kimber Pro Carry II 9mm. After 300 rds. it still jams; sometimes failure to eject, sometimes failure to extract. I'm going to return it to the gun shop, and will probably take a blood bath. I plan to buy a Colt LW Commander 9mm. God help me if it is also a loser.

    4 months ago
  • Dean W.

    Just bought a Springfield Armory EMP4. I’m really liking it - slightly smaller all the way around and holds 9+1. The Carry Contour model has a clipped mainspring housing that makes it comfortable to hold and helps a bit with concealment. And shoots very nice!

    11 months ago
    • JD

      What kind of holster are you using?

      3 months ago
  • James Altizer

    Your lead photograph is not an M1911. It's an M1911 A1. You should know the difference.

    1 year ago
    • Fred Vo

      Some of us may, not, so why not point out the difference(s) and educate everyone instead of trying to prop yourself up as some kind of expert and just drop a steaming troll turd?

      6 months ago
    • Dale E Ross

      Your seat belt is too tight..

      9 months ago
  • Tom

    I have a Springfield 1911 RO Elite Champion 9mm and love it. It comes with an ambi safety, fiber optic sight, 4" barrel and alloy frame weighing 29 oz.. You can get 10 round magazines that don't stick out any further than 8 round .45's. Very accurate and great handling. I had bought the EMP 4 CC Contour first, but the grip diameter is smaller than the 1911 which feels better in my hand. I gave it to my wife and she loves it better than the other 9's that she has.

    1 year ago
  • Hoyden

    Springfield Armory EMP not on this list? A 9x19 built from the ground as a 1911. If you’re going for a 9mm in a 1911, take advantage of the smaller cartridge to get a smaller grip and a pistol made to fire the cartridge, not a .45ACP redesigned for 9mm (which I’ve had several with feeding problems, Kimber, Colt, S&W). YMMV

    1 year ago
    • joe

      The Colt LW commander was designed and built as a 9mm .... I have fed 2500+ round through mine with not 1 hic-up!!! Try it you will like it

      1 year ago
  • Randy

    I love all the comments and the real-world experience you guys have with 9mm 1911"s. As I stated, I don't know if it's even possible to say a given gun is the best. We are blessed with so many great guns today and the choices really are endless. It all comes down to what gun fits you, what features you are looking for, how you shoot it (if you have a chance to shoot some range guns), and your budget.

    1 year ago
  • Leonard

    Liked the point you are making here. However I am 60 now and the recoil of the 9mm is much easier for me to control vs 45acp

    1 year ago
  • Ostensor

    Not sure what the point is? There are so many pistols designed for the caliber to choose from. And not sure the comment about 1911 reliability is valid. Guess two each their own.

    1 year ago
  • Chris

    I have a two-tone Citadel 1911 9mm with Rosewood grips. It looks great and shoots awesome. I have $450 in it, like new Used, so not a $1,000 pistol. But, anyone that's held or shot it, really likes it.

    1 year ago
  • robert

    I just don't see the point in a 9mm that only holds 8-9 rounds. If I'm going to carry a 1911, it will be in .45 acp and still have 8-9 rounds. If I'm going with 9mm, it will be a glock 19. Yup its plastic, but it goes bang every time. Certainly not as accurate as my Kimber TLE/RL but within 20 yards, the bad guy is not going to see another day. Just my 2 cents

    1 year ago
  • Jeff

    My fav 9mm 1911 is my nighthawk T4. 3.8 in barrel and full-size clip. It’s thin and I shoot superbly with it. Nighthawk rulz.

    1 year ago
  • Bill G

    You missed what is in my opinion the best overall 9mm 1911. Though expensive, it is worth every penny. The Springfield EMP4 is the ONLY 9mm 1911 which was designed, engineered, and built with ALL newly speced and manufactured parts, designed specifically for the 9mm caliber. ALL other 9mm 1911's use off the shelf components from that builders 45 line, and that IS a compromise!

    1 year ago
    • Paul Santos

      Agreed, I absolutely love mine!

      1 year ago
    • Jeff

      My nighthawk T4 was designed from the ground up to be 9mm.

      1 year ago
  • Patrick

    My first - and favorite - gun was a Kimber Custom II in 9mm. I wanted a good gun to start out with, but I didn't want to spend all my money on ammo, so 9mm made the most sense.

    1 year ago
New to Guns ? Check out our beginners guns video course. Start Now