Hand-Picked Daily GUN DEALS

Hollow Points vs. Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) Ammo

If your life depends on it, what kind of ammo should you use? Hollow Points or Full Metal Jacket? Find out the difference and our recommendations for the best defensive ammo for each caliber.

We review products independently. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission to help support our testing. Learn more.

Nothing will make up for shooting skill… If you don’t hit your target it won’t matter if you were using the Golden Gun and firing depleted uranium rounds – you still missed.  But that doesn’t mean what you shoot isn’t important. There’s an unwritten rule of firearm ammunition: use hollow points for your carry/home defense guns and use full-metal jacket (FMJ) for practice. This is mainly due to the fact that FMJ rounds are significantly cheaper than your average hollow point. It’s also due to the fact that, from a “put the attacker down” point of view, FMJ rounds aren’t exactly ideal.
9mm 115 gr Federal FMJ vs 124 gr Federal Hydrashok, Top
9mm 115 gr Federal FMJ vs 124 gr Federal Hydrashok, Top
That’s not to say that FMJ rounds are useless for defense. Far from it, in fact. Most NATO militaries use only FMJ rounds.  This is due to an international treaty that was signed many years ago that forbids the use of expanding rounds.  That same treaty also bans the dropping of grenades from hot air balloons, mind you, so some of the stuff might be outdated in the grand scheme of things. However, the USA never ratified that section of the treaty…and the US Army just recently adopted hollow point ammo along with the new Sig Sauer M17 pistol. But I digress, the FMJ is still a bullet and will still punch a hole in your average bad guy.  Stories of people “shrugging off” FMJ rounds because they “just passed right through” are rare and often exaggerated.

So Why Do We Use Hollow Points Then?

Ballistics Gel Testing
Ballistics Gel Testing, Lucky Gunner
While a full metal jacket round will still drop a bad guy, a hollow point will do it just a little bit better.  That’s not to say there aren’t all kinds of misconceptions about hollow points as well.  What I want to do today is talk about both rounds and touch on the misconceptions of both. Or if you’re ready…check out our Ammo & Reloading Definitive Guide for our favorite ammo picks for common calibers.

Full Metal Jacket

A full metal jacket round, as we talked about in our Basic Bullet Guide, is a soft lead bullet that’s been encased in a harder metal. When passing through soft tissue and other stuff, the bullet retains the majority of its shape.  The upside of this is that, in theory, it has an easier time retaining its lethality after passing through a barrier among other things.  It also has an easier time working in almost any gun you put it in. The main thing, however, is that it’s just far cheaper to manufacture FMJ ammo.
FMJ Cut
FMJ Cut
So why does FMJ ammo have that “less lethal than hollow point” thing associated with it?

It comes down to physics…

Because the bullet is just passing through, for lack of a better term, it retains a great deal of its energy.  This ultimately results in 2 small holes (entrance and exit wound) and also allows the bullet to possibly continue on for a long time and hit something you don’t want it to. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want 2 small holes punched in me and I don’t think anyone else does either. It’s a safe bet that anyone, and I do mean anyone who says that a person could just shrug off a shot from an FMJ round (or a given caliber) would not be willing to stand downrange of said caliber and attempt to shrug it off. That being said, what about the common alternative?

Hollow Points

Take an FMJ round, then drill a hole in the tip.  Hey look, the point of the bullet is now hollow.  I wonder what we could call it… Ok, it’s a bit more involved than putting a hole in a round with a drill press but still. That hole is there to create a weakness.
Overhead Hollow Point Comparison, ar15.com Molon
Overhead Hollow Point Comparison, ar15.com Molon
That weakness causes resistance when it hits something squishy and that resistance causes the bullet to start expanding.  That expansion is the key point. Remember Newton’s Law: energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transferred.  With the expansion, the majority of the energy from the shot gets dissipated into the thing what you shot. Ideally, this results in a much larger wound cavity and no exit wounds meaning the bullet stops inside the body.  Chance being what it is, that doesn’t always happen exactly as planned but there it is.
147 Federal HST Expansion
147 Federal HST Expansion
To finish up here, I want to take a moment to explain what a hollow point isn’t. First off, it’s not some magical death talisman.  Aside from how Hollywood likes to portray them, the person isn’t going to go flying across a room if you so much as graze their shoulder.  All it means is that this bullet is going to impact a bit harder and probably not punch all the way through someone.  If it does go through, it’s probably not going to have much power after that. It’s also not a “cop killer” round as some like to paint it.  Even low-end body armor is far more likely to stop a hollow point than it will an FMJ round. Finally, barriers and such aren’t going to affect hollow points as much as you would think. First off, they need a great deal of resistance to expand which the momentary contact with a barrier just isn’t enough to cause.  Mind you, it will start to expand in most cases but they’re made to fully expand via soft tissue contact.  Secondly, most hollow point rounds made in the USA are meant to satisfy the FBI Ballistic Test requirements. They’re pretty extensive so I’ll just give you the Reader’s Digest version: gel penetration of a minimum of 12 to 18 inches through bare gel, heavy clothing, steel, wallboard, plywood, and glass.
5 Shots into Ballistic Gel
5 Shots into Ballistic Gel

Conclusion

Like I said in the beginning…FMJ for practice and hollow points for everyday carry and such. Does that mean you should never practice with hollow points? Heck no! You need to know how your gun is going to react with that ammunition.  Guns don’t always like every bit of ammo you feed it.  Put at least a box or two through your gun when practicing but, beyond that, save yourself the money at the range. Recommendations

Written By

Gun Noob

Gun Noob

Author

Articles written by TheNoob from GunNoob.com before its acquisition by Pew Pew Media in 2016. TheNoob was dedicated to passing on knowledge to beginners that he learned along the way. A *hat tip* to you, good sir.

WHY YOU CAN TRUST PEW PEW TACTICAL

Since 2016, the Pew Pew Tactical team has been dedicated to providing expert reviews and in-depth testing of guns and gear. All while keeping in mind that guns are fun and that readers come first.

Written by American gun enthusiasts, competitive shooters, former military/law enforcement personnel, and trained journalists, we use our extensive skill sets and knowledge to bring a well-rounded, researched approach to our content.

We pride ourselves on hands-on testing and real-world experience with all products we recommend. Further, we believe in objectivity and approaching all articles without bias – our few advertisers never influence our reviews or recommendations. We believe in giving our readers a comprehensive understanding of how and why a product is great – or isn’t. And if it’s good enough for us to use ourselves and recommend to loved ones.

Our content, analysis, and insights on firearms and gear are recognized across the web. We are proud to be cited by authoritative third-party platforms including Newsweek, Yahoo News, and Wikipedia, demonstrating our standing as a trusted resource in the firearms industry.

Conversation

50 Comments

Join the discussion

  • Condescending remarks like yours shows you probably are not as knowledgeable as you want people to think , in a combat or self defense situation more has to be considered than just fragmenting or penetration, you should carry at least two mags hollow points , with one of those in you weapon during carry , there are times penetration can make all the difference, true most people (civilians) have to remove their firearms from their holsters , it’s gonna be 5 to 25 feet from you , with no time to use cover , no vest , that situation is ideal for hollow points especially in .40 cal and up , but for suppression fire with opponent behind solid but penetrable objects like auto mobiles , wooden or brick walls , that penetrating round May come in handy ,
    ...
  • First and foremost, your self-defense round must reliably cycle the action of your pistol. Failures to load or eject can prove fatal. If your pistol isn't reliable using hollow points, then FMJ's are in order.

    Second, the bullet must reliably penetrate, reaching vital organs (heart, lungs, liver, etc.), central nervous system (brain and spinal column), and/or breaking major bone structure (femur, humerus, hip). A hollow point that doesn't reliably penetrate sufficiently due to over-expansion or fragmentation can also prove fatal.

    Third, accuracy is a must. Hits count, misses don't.

    While it's nice to say you must use hollow points for self-defense, the round you use, HP or FMJ, must meet the above criteria.
    ...
  • The fact that this is even a conversation in today’s world is laughable and pathetic. JHP are more lethal and better than FMJ for self defense END OF STORY. Anyone in this comment section or the world who thinks otherwise is an idiot and has no business carrying a firearm. Even though it’s not the majority, the fact that there is a sizable amount of people in today’s world that carry FMJ over JHP shows how much stupidity and ignorance there is in the gun community, especially when all the empirical data says otherwise. A JHP has way less chance of passing through and hitting an innocent bystander and as explained in this article will create a bigger wound channel causing more damage/bleeding, and will put a would-be attacker down quicker and more efficiently. A lot of people in this comment section and the gun community need to educate themselves because an FMJ will always be inferior to a JHP for self-defense and the only people that carry FMJ as far as I’m concerned are broke/cheap asses who don’t wanna spend the money for a quality JHP. Great article by the author and hopefully the knuckleheads listen and carry JHP for self-defense and keep the FMJ on the target range where it belongs.
    ...
    • Jack Sparrow

      Yes, but FMJs are so much cheaper than hollow point. I don't think there's truly anyone out there that thinks that FMJs are better. It's just all people can afford, but especially these days when we're in an economic recession.
      ...
  • Lousy definition of FMJ vs Hollow points. Never addressed the ergonomic and nuts and bolts.
    ...
    • Jerm

      Was just fine
      ...
    • InGodwetrust

      The Article was written for the new guys to carrying(including me) Write your own if this isn’t good enough for you.
      ...
  • I use full metal jacket ammunition for personal protection in my 45 and 9mm. I have two reasons. First, the FMJ rounds provide a more reliable feed in my two carry firearms. I want my semi-automatic to be semi-automatic, not manually operated. Second, they do, in tests I have seen and tests I have conducted, provide better penetration. The bullet has to reach the vitals (heart, brain, lungs), or at least break bones (spine, thigh, or humerus for example) that will incapacitate an assailant.
    ...
    • David Mcpherson

      Thank you, for your info. I recently purchased a Taurus "2 matte blk Carbon steel Taurus 38 snub nose and have it loaded presently loaded with fmg bronze 38 special ammunition. I appreciate it.
      ...
  • Thanks for this article!
    ...
  • If hollow points are so great why dont big game hunters use them?
    ...
    • Jackson

      Hollow points dump energy quickly. Does more damage and bullet stops quicker not going through the target and worrying about what is behind it. When hunting big game, you are not worried about what's behind the shot. You also don't want to tear up the meat. Hollow points, much larger wound cavity. Typically big game uses soft point bullets which is balance mid range expansion and going through tougher skin.
      ...
    • Domino

      I would imagine because hollow points are designed to penetrate human skin, which is relatively thin compared so something like a hog, or moose, or elk, or….. well, you get the idea. Against thicker skinned game, penetration and expansion could become an issue.
      ...
  • I'm not a gun guy, I'm just interested in the science behind Many things.

    Thank you for this informative article written from a very neutral POV.
    ...
  • Do you mean to tell me that A "Full Metal Jacket" is not a a type of clothing that Knights use to wear during the middle ages?
    ...
  • I use FMJ ammo in my .380, 9 mm and .45. Why? Because I've found the ones I use to be the most reliable feeding rounds in my pistols. To date, I haven't had to use any of my pistols for self defense, but I do want it to reliably feed that second (or third or fourth, or whatever it takes) round. Clearing a jam when my life depends on it is not something I want to have to do.
    ...
  • I've been shot with 9 mm 115gr FMJ. While it was just a flesh wound, it felt like getting hit with a hammer full force. I was still able to function just fine, It didn't hurt from the adrenaline. When I got worked on, I started feeling it, but by that time I was pumped full of dilated. .... LONG STORY SHORT.. FMJ is effective only in effective locations. If I put two rounds in your chest and one in your head. You wont know the difference
    ...