Federal M vs XM (5.56) and XM193 vs XM855

Still looking for the perfect holiday gift? Check out our Best Gifts for Gun Lovers [All Budgets]!

X vs XM…XM193 vs XM855?!?

Learn the confusing differences between Federal’s X and XM designations of their 5.56 ammo, as well as the differences between XM193 and XM855 rounds.

Plus ammo recommendations!

Federal 5.56 M193 vs XM193

XM193
XM193

In a nutshell, “M” by itself means that it meets military specification (mil-spec) while “XM” means it does not.

But just keep in mind that mil-spec is very stringent and even a small thing out of specification can lead to tons of ammo being rejected.

And overwhelming consensus/review is that XM193 is some fine shooting ammo.  But for some sleep-inducing reading pleasure, you can check up the mil-spec standards of M193 for yourself.

Federal must have gotten so many questions that they put up a site that describes XM193.  Emphasis is done by me.

XM193 product is first run, first quality product manufactured at the Lake City Army Ammunition Plant for Federal Cartridges and is made to Federal specifications typical for commercial ammunition.

All XM193 product is the same regardless of the sku or part number. (ie. XM193C is the same as XM193F, XM193CBP and etc … )  The only difference is the package configuation.

Sadly the page is now down (as of 2016) but here is the link (slow load) where I grabbed a cache of it from 2012 and a screenshot of the cache below.

Federal XM193 FAQ
Federal XM193 FAQ

I think they were just trying to calm fears that it was inferior ammo for the shooting public.

If you’re trying to be technical…I guess it is inferior to mil-spec, but still fine enough for commercial specification.

And to make it more confusing, the M vs XM only applies to Federal/American Eagle.  Other manufacturers such as PMC use the M193 designation.

As far as I know, it’s really good ammo but just because it’s called M193 doesn’t mean it’s mil-spec.

So Can You Buy M193?

Once it is designated M193, it should be going to the military so you’re going to have a hard time getting the “real deal” without possibly breaking some laws.

We do not recommend that.

But we do recommend the below ammo:

M193 vs M855

The M193 cartridge is a 55 gr lead core surrounded by a copper jacket (FMJ-BT, full metal jacket with boat tail).

While the M855 “green tip” cartridge is 62 gr and has a steel core “penetrator” at the tip which helps it go through barriers more easily (also FMJ-BT).  You can see the lighter gray of the steel below.

M855 Cutaway, Bearingarms.com
M855 Cutaway, Bearingarms.com

To make things a little more confusing, you might also see SS109, which is more often the designation of the bullet projectile but for some non-US ammo manufacturers, it could refer to the entire cartridge.

Green Tip SS109 Projectiles
Green Tip SS109 Projectiles

Should I get M193 or M855?

You’re probably thinking…”penetrator” sounds pretty badass and it goes through barriers more easily…so I need it.

In reality, M193 does a better job against soft targets under 100 yards since it fragments more than the M855 which has the steel core.  After that length, the M855 seems to catch up.

M193 Fragmentation, Ammo Oracle
M193 Fragmentation, Ammo Oracle

Also, keep in mind that the barrel twist of your rifle will also dictate how well the heavier projectile will fair.

If you have a 1:7 or 1:8 twist, it will be fine, but if you have the more commercially popular 1:9, you’re better off sticking with the M193 55 gr.

Ideal Bullet Weight vs Twist, Shooters Log
Ideal Bullet Weight vs Twist, Shooters Log

Now for penetration, below is a picture of regular PMC Bronze .223 (approximation to XM193) vs XM855.

PMC Bronze .223 vs XM855 Green Tip
PMC Bronze .223 vs XM855 Green Tip

The depth of penetration against the 3/4″ steel plate was .20 inches for the 55gr and .35 inches for the XM855.

The complete video is here, but get ready for a lot of misses (I’d start halfway in).  So I’d say it does penetrate more but it doesn’t cut through steel like butter.

And because it penetrates, it will do a good number on steel targets and potentially spark a fire, so many ranges do not allow it.

Last thing, is the price difference.  Most likely you’re going to see 193 slightly cheaper than 855 by a few cents.  Nothing too much of a deal breaker.

So to sum it all up:

  • Pricing is pretty similar
  • Some ranges do not allow steel core bullets such as the M855
  • M193 likes 1:9 barrels while M855 likes 1:8 or 1:7
  • M855 penetrates slightly better
  • M193 better performance against soft targets under 100 yards

And FYI, there was a brief scare in 2015 that the ATF was classifying M855 as armor piercing and taking it away from civilians, but they’ve since backed down.

Supplies dwindled as people thought it was going to be banned, but now it’s almost back to normal.

And our recommendation with the 855 thrown in there.  See our Best Ammo For Your AR-15 for more.

Got any questions? What do you shoot through your rifle? Let us know in the comments!

13
Leave a Reply

avatar
9 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
Fred SebastianDanHornet135RichardJason Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Fred Sebastian
Guest
Fred Sebastian

IMHO: Your test would be more “visual” with thinner steel targets. I use 3/8″ well casings as “Gongs”.
The M885s drills a clean hole, Ever’time.
I would rather know what a particular “cartridge” WILL do not what it won’t do. I already know it won’t hurt a Jersey Barrier w/o a test.

Hornet135
Guest
Hornet135

PMC bronze .223 is not an approximation to XM193, it’s really weak; about 500 fps slow.

Jason
Guest
Jason

I’m somewhat new to the AR scene, but I’m liking the M855 62gr ammo. I have a 10.5′ AR pistol with a 1/7 twist, and have had no problems staying on target. I wouldn’t recommend the M855’s for soft targets, but if you want to punch through Cinder block, Stucco, or Drywall, these will do it

Tony
Guest
Tony

I worked at LCAAP for 5 years as an engineer making 5.56. There is generally no difference between XM193 and M193. Most of the XM193 ammo is made specifically for commercial pack and never tested against mil-spec, though it is made the same as the milspec ammo. Yes, if a lot fails the milspec for any slight variation it does gets sold as XM193 as long as it meets the commercial requirements. As mentioned in the article though milspec testing is very strict, and this ammo will work flawlessly for the average shooter. I use nothing but LCAAP ammo for… Read more »

Zee
Guest
Zee

My boxes of XM193 literally say “military grade” on them, for even more confusion!