Taurus Judge Home Defender Review: Crazy Fun Or Just Plain Crazy?

I’ve always thought the Taurus Judge was just about the dumbest gun on the market. It shoots .410 and .45 Colt, but it doesn’t fire either of them very well. 

I didn’t have a whole lot of faith in the Taurus Judge Home Defender. 

With no hope in my heart, I grabbed the Judge Home Defender, a pile of .410 ammo including multiple buckshot loads, and a little bit of .45 Colt.

Would this great big Judge be any better than the original? 

Specs & Features

Specs

• Caliber: .45 Colt, .410 bore up to 3”
• Action: Double-action revolver
• Capacity: 5 
• Safety: Transfer bar
• Barrel Length: 13” 
• Overall Length: 19.5”
• Overall Width: 1.9”
• Weight: 3.66 lbs
• Country of Origin: Brazil

Features

• Shoots solid projectiles and shot interchangeably
• Picatinny rails for optics and accessories
• Much better accuracy than the original Judge

Origin of the Taurus Judge Home Defender

How far back do you want to go? Years and years ago, Taurus released a series of small-frame, large-caliber guns. The three ported, snub nose revolvers were available in .45 Colt, .41 Magnum, and .44 Special. 

This started a large-caliber, small-frame series of guns which led to the original Judge. The original Judge was called the 4410 but Taurus renamed it as the Judge when the company’s executive vice president learned judges in Miami were carrying the weapon for self-defense. 

The Judge became a huge hit, and Taurus released several variants of the gun. This includes the Rossi Circuit Judge, which was the rifle version of the Judge. The Taurus Home Defender sits between the Judge and the Circuit Judge. 

The Judge Home Defender is still a pistol by law, but it’s way bigger than any other pistol you’re likely to find. This larger gun is Taurus’ compromise in size to make a gun larger and more effective than the Judge, but to keep it maneuverable.

The Judge Home Defender is an odd duck. It’s a massive gun with a medium-size frame. This means we get a very small grip for such a large gun, but it’s sticky and well textured. We keep the double-action design with an exposed hammer, but we lose all semblance of sights. 

Instead, we get a Picatinny rail for mounting a red dot that runs the length of the top strap. Forward of the cylinder, on either side, sits a pair of blast shields to protect your wrists from hot gas squeezing out from between the cylinder and forcing cone. 

In front of the blast shields sits a large handguard, or grip. It’s a piece of black polymer that allows for a forward grip with your support hand. More importantly, it allows you to mount a light on another Picatinny rail, although barrel shadow is unavoidable with this gun. 

Who is the Taurus Judge Home Defender For? 

As the name implies, the Judge Home Defender is aimed at those looking for an effective home-defense platform. 

It’s an oddball in many ways. Most defensive firearms are either handguns, rifles, or shotguns. This thing is a bit of both. 

If we think of it as a shotgun, we can start to see its usefulness. Shotguns launch multiple projectiles per trigger pull. The .410 is the smallest widely used shotgun cartridge and a three inch .410 shotshell can hold five pellets of 000 buckshot. 

That means each trigger pull is launching what’s essentially five 9mm projectiles. That’s nothing to laugh at. At the same time, .410 doesn’t have a ton of recoil, so it’s controllable. 

In the Taurus Judge Home Defender isn’t a trench broom, but it’ll take out the trash. 

I believe if you are going to use the .410 for defensive purposes you might as well use the smallest, most maneuverable platform available.

Ergonomics: Fit and Feel 

The gun feels surprisingly balanced for a goofy, oversized revolver. The front handguard is a nice touch – remember, this revolver is almost 4 pounds. Taurus didn’t change anything when it came to the Judge’s action. 

It’s not terrible, but it’s not exactly the smoothest design. We got a massive three-inch cylinder, and that mechanism has to work hard to rotate it, so you feel that weight.

Taurus attached the rail securely, and the front end of the gun features a solid picatinny rail for attachment purposes. 

As a package, the Home Defender is easy to handle. You can navigate close-quarters situations with ease. 

How Does it Shoot?

No sights meant I needed some kind of optic. I mounted a Vortex Defender-CCW with a Picatinny rail adapter and a .243 side saddle, which also fits .410 rounds. I topped it off with a Streamlight for the home defense setup. 

.45 Colt Accuracy

I zeroed the dot with .45 Colt, and walked away impressed by a bullets that had to jump through a lot of open space to hit light rifling. I wasn’t stacking rounds, but I produced a group smaller than my finger length at 25 yards. 

The .45 Colt loads had hardly any recoil. Honestly, I’d describe it as pleasant. I’d prefer .410 inside the home, but if I needed to extend my range for dealing with threats like coyotes or hogs, a good .45 Colt would get it done. 

It’s easy to assume the .410 would pack a punch for the shooter and cause recoil issues in a gun like this, but it doesn’t. It’s very controllable, with no push/pull technique required. It’s not painful or difficult to control. 

I could start at the low ready and, with full-powered buckshot, I could place two shots onto two targets in less than two seconds at 10 yards. I shot the drill cold, so imagine what I could do with a little practice.

Firing all five rounds wasn’t much of a challenge. It’s doubtful you’d need more than one per target, but being able to fire all five quickly isn’t a bad thing. It’s also super fun to shoot. 

.410 Patterns

The old Taurus Judge threw horrendous patterns. I’d consider it unusable without special .410 ammo.

The Judge Home Defender delivered impressive results with Remington Ultimate Defense – way better than the original Judge. A longer barrel seems to help. My biggest pattern was 7 inches wide, and the smallest was 6.5 inches with the Remington load. 

Most standard buckshot resulted in 7-inch patterns. I tried a variety of .410 handgun loads and they did have tighter patterns. 

We saw the best performance from the Federal Personal Defense Handgun loads through a tight 3-inch pattern. Hornady Critical Defense with the .41-caliber FTX slug and two .35-caliber pellets would often pattern within 4 inches of each other. 

The Winchester PDX Defender load delivered a mixed bag. The stacked discs did a great job, but the BB buckshot patterned way too big to be useful. Ditch the BB shot, and this could be a great defensive load. 

Mind The Gap 

Those blast shields are placed to protect your arms, and they do a mostly good job. Some loads deliver more blast than others, but they all deliver a little sting. The Winchester load delivered the biggest and most uncomfortable blast. 

Even with the worst blast, a mere five rounds don’t hurt. It’s something to be aware of, and if you’re doing a long day of training, I’d wear long sleeves. After shooting a hundred rounds, my left forearm was black and bleeding just a bit. 

In terms of reliability, the Judge Home Defender didn’t let me down. It went bang every time I pulled the trigger. The gun never failed to fire, and nothing broke. 

The only significant problem I had came from Monarch birdshot. The shells seemed to expand too much and get stuck in the cylinder.

What Sets it Apart? 

The only real competition the Home Defender has is the Mossberg Shockwave in .410. Both are super small and maneuverable firearms, but the Judge Home Defender has some advantages over the Shockwave. 

First, it can hold five 3-inch shells compared to the Shockwave’s four. Second, the gun can be operated via one hand since there’s nothing to pump. 

The Shockwave does get the advantage of a smooth bore and better patterns overall, but the Judge Home Defender can shoot .45 Colt.  

By the Numbers

Accuracy: 3.5/5

The gun is not a bull’s-eye pistol. Between the .45 Colt groups and .410 patterns, it’s average at best. 

Reliability: 4/5 

The gun seems to function fine. I knocked a point off for needing a rubber mallet to free five rounds of Monarch birdshot. 

Ergonomics: 3.5/5 

It’s a big, heavy revolver that blasts your wrist with each trigger pull. Other than the obvious flaws, it’s easy to use and ergonomic like any other revolver. 

Customization: 3.5/5 

The long optics rail makes it easy to attach optics and more. I added a side saddle, and the front pic rail makes adding a light easy. There are a number of grips available for the Judge. If you get an SBR stamp, the Circuit Judge stocks should fit (I might just SBR it). 

Value: 4/5 

The MSRP of over $700 seems high, but they seem to sell for around $550, which is not a bad price for a unique .410 defensive weapon.

Overall: 3.5/5

Taurus Judge Home Defender Upgrades & Accessories

Taurus was thoughtful enough to make this revolver customizable. Here’s what I recommend.

I used the micro-sized Vortex Defender-CCW, and it’s fine, but the gun could do with a bigger optic. The Vortex Defender-XL is much larger and comes with a Picatinny rail adapter for easy mounting. It’s a solid dot and will get your .410 and .45 Colt on target. 

Don’t forget, it comes with a green dot, too!

The Judge Home Defender’s long Picatinny rail has room to mount a five-shot side saddle. While this thing is intended for .243 Win, it will hold .410 no problem. With the ammo holder on the left side, it clears the cylinder. 

Take your pick from the Streamlight TLR RM 1 and TLR RM 2. I used the shorter TLR RM 1, but the Judge Home Defender’s barrel length means there’s plenty of room for the TLR RM 2.

This is a long-gun light, but it mounts to the Home Defender just fine. It offers both a ramping switch and the ability to use a pressure switch to activate the light. It throws more than enough light for home defense and won’t weigh your gun down.

How We Tested the Taurus Judge Home Defender

For this article, I got my hands on a Turus Judge Home Defender and put it through some real-world testing.

Ammunition included a variety of .410 and .45 Colt. Since this is a home defense gun, I focused my attention on drills that reflected that. To test accuracy, I shot groups at 25 yards.

Taurus also gave us not one but two Picatinny rails, so I added a red dot and a weapon light, too.

Meet the Experts

Heading up this article is Pew Pew Tactical author Travis Pike. Travis spent a lifetime shooting and hunting before joining the United States Marine Corps, where he spent five years as an infantryman. Travis is also an NRA-certified instructor and concealed carry instructor in the state of Florida.

Editing this article is Scott Murdock. Scott is a Marine Corps veteran who competed and qualified as a rifle and pistol expert while in service. In addition to shooting, Scott has written for a variety of publications, testing, researching, and evaluating guns and gear. He brings that knowledge and skillset to this article, editing and fact-checking for accuracy.

Editor-in-Chief Jacki Billings runs our experienced team of reviewers. She is a National Rifle Association Basic Pistol Instructor as well as a member of the Society of Professional Journalists, ACES: Society for Editing, and the Professional Outdoor Media Association. Jacki has a bachelor’s degree in journalism and has worked as a media professional for close to 20 years, specializing in gun media for almost 10 years. With 2,000+ articles to her name, she uses her professional journalism and editing experience to set testing protocols and editorial standards for Pew Pew Tactical.

Final Verdict

The longer barrel of the Judge Home Defender gives us better patterns than any other Judge on the market. This big pistol can be used one-handed but provides long-gun firepower. It’s the right size for a defensive .410. 

I question the potential of using a .410 over something like a PCC, but I guess everyone gets their options in the United States. I do see the Judge Home Defender excelling as a yard gun for dealing with all sorts of pests while being small and convenient enough to carry.

Would you use the Taurus Judge Home Defender for home defense? Let us know in the comments. Like defensive shotguns? Check out our guide to the Best Home-Defense Shotguns!