Carrying a Backup Gun

Still looking for the perfect holiday gift? Check out our Best Gifts for Gun Lovers [All Budgets]!

Who do you think you are?  Why the hell would you need more than one gun?

I mean, you’re probably not going to use one gun, let alone two.

These doubts and others (where will I carry it? why bother? etc) can make carrying a backup gun a daunting prospect.

Shooting Pistol
Beretta 92FS in Action

That’s where we come in.

But fear not, we’re here as the voice of reason.  Not just gun guys who want you to have a bigger gun collection, but a group of guys in the same boat as you are who can give you some advice about why (or why not) you might want to carry a backup gun.

What we’re going to do here, is go over some pros and cons of carrying a backup gun and come to some conclusions about why it may or may not be right for you, even if you aren’t a part-time night dwelling vigilante.

Why Do You Think You Need To Carry A Backup Gun?

First off, why do you think you should carry a backup weapon?  

You are carrying a gun to protect you and your family.  If your gun fails or is otherwise not able to be used, you want another option.

You want to do everything in your power to be as safe as possible. 

What Can You Carry For A Backup Gun?

Your backup gun can be anything you’d like.  If you want to have a backpack full of 1911s, by all means, go for it.  But that’s not very realistic.

So, what’s something more reasonable to carry as a backup?  There’s a long list of sub-compact 9mm guns that are small and still have the power you need to defend yourself.

A .380 is another solid choice.  They are small, don’t weigh a lot, and can fit almost anywhere.  They are also a great choice if you have a smaller body or are thin.  A larger gun might not hide so well, let alone two guns.

Where Should You Carry Your Backup Gun?

The “where” is definitely a personal choice.  Say, for example, you decide on the Smith and Wesson Bodyguard .380.  The 380 is small and offers a lot of options for a carry location.  You can carry it in:

  • Your pants pocket,
  • A backpack,
  • A purse,
  • An ankle holster,
  • A holster,
  • A jacket pocket.
Shoulder Holster
Shoulder Holster

The location will depend a lot on how you dress and what you’ll be doing.

For example, if you are in your car all day, it would make sense to keep a backup in an easily accessible spot in your car rather than in your pants pocket.

If you wear shorts all the time, an ankle holster or jacket pocket won’t cut it.

Focus on the accessibility and amount of concealment you have when you’re choosing your backup gun carry location.

And check out our pick of the Best Gun Holsters for however you carry.

Why You Shouldn’t Carry A Backup Gun

This is the devil’s advocate part of the article where I will talk about the reasons why you wouldn’t want to have the extra security of a backup weapon.

It’s More Dangerous

You are handling two guns on a daily basis, thus increasing the odds of a mistake or mishap. I know you’re careful, but you’re increasing the odds of a mishap, that’s all.

It’s Twice as Hard to Conceal Two Guns

When you’re moving you have to bend, lean, and maneuver in a way that doesn’t show either gun.  When you are new to carrying a concealed gun, you are VERY self-conscious. 

You move differently, probably stiffer than normal.  You also don’t bend normally.  Well, when you have two guns (let’s say an IWB holster at the 4 o’clock position and an ankle holster on your left leg) lifting your leg or squatting down to tie your shoe takes a little more thought than before.

Added Cost

This one is pretty self-explanatory.  You obviously have the cost of buying another gun, holster, and ammo for the secondary gun.

The added training will also add to the cost.  You will need more range time, ammo, targets, and anything else you might use to train.

It May Not Be Practical

Do you work in an office or for a business that doesn’t allow guns in the building?  If you do, carrying two guns to work, locking them in your car all day, then wearing them on the way home could get old really quick.

Gun Store
Gun Store

More Training

When you carry a gun, you need to practice your draw from wherever you are carrying.  Using an ankle holster is a vastly different draw than drawing from your hip.  It will take time to get a feel for it.

This is a tough one for some people.  A lot of people – including myself – don’t get to the range as much as they should.  Add a secondary weapon to train with and it will be even more difficult to get the appropriate time in at the range.

Why You Should Carry A Backup Gun

I like to think of a backup gun like a spare tire for your car.  If you have a blowout on the highway, you have options.  You can call the tow truck to tow you into a shop, have someone change it for you, or you can get off your ass and change the tire yourself.

If you are carrying a backup, you might find that it’s faster to pull your secondary gun than it is to reload your primary.  Even with a speed loader, a revolver might take a more time than drawing from your ankle holster or pocket.

If your first gun fails or you lose access to it, a backup gun is a godsend to have.

And, of course, just peace of mind.  You know you have a backup in case you need it.  If you don’t need it, all the better. It’s like insurance.

Does It Make Sense For You To Carry A Backup?

Realistically, there is a slim chance you will need to use your gun in the near future.  Depending on where you get your news from, things are getting better or things are going to hell in a handbasket… like always.

You can take into consideration a lot of things that may sway you one way or another. 

For example, the area where you live.  Do you live in a high crime area?  If so, you might be more likely to need your weapon.  If you live in a really rural area, you might run into a wild animal. 

Off Duty Officers

Most of the officers I know carry a backup gun.  Some even when they are off duty.  They feel like they are missing something when they are not carrying.

While an off-duty scenario is a lot different than on the job, police officers tend to get involved in bad situations whether they are punched in or not.  When putting yourself in harm’s way, having a backup is a lifesaver.

Everyone Else

For the rest of us, you can think about whether you can guarantee you will always be standing when you need quick access your gun.  If you are in your car, is an IWB holster on your right hip easier to access than an ankle holster?  What about if you get knocked down?

Ankle Holster
Ankle Holster

These are all real scenarios you should think about when deciding if a secondary gun is for you.

Final Thoughts

Personally, I don’t feel the need to carry a backup gun.  In my years of carrying, I have not had a single case in which I debated whether or not to draw my weapon, thankfully.  I feel prepared having a single weapon I am comfortable shooting and can draw quickly if the time comes to use it.

Do you carry a backup gun?  If you do, give us some details about why, where, and when you have ever had the need for a secondary weapon.  And if you’re in need of some suggestions, check out our Editor’s Picks.

11
Leave a Reply

avatar
8 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
9 Comment authors
TimDavidMichael GrimmShawn S.Mark Wynn Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Tim
Guest
Tim

I have a VA CCP and from what I have looked into about the subject, I am not legally allowed to carry a second concealed weapon on my person. Does anyone have any knowledge that contradicts this in VA?

David, PPT Editor
Admin

I poked around the topic just now and can’t find any clear answer, the best I found was an old thread on TheHighRoad.org forums. Post #10 in the thread is someone in VA quoting a letter response to the question from an unnamed DA.

Its the internet, so take it with a grain of salt. But seems in line with else I read, that the subject isn’t clearly defined either way and different departments within VA read the statute differently.

I wouldn’t risk it, but I don’t live in VA either.

Tim
Guest
Tim

Thanks for taking the time to look into it! The language on the permit says handgun (not plural) so there is every reason to think carrying more than one is not allowed.

I’m thankful I can carry one legally.

Michael Grimm
Guest
Michael Grimm

I have a Beretta M9, and a Beretta bu9 nano. I carry the Nano more often. I’ve carried both. I always carry 2 spare mags per gun. If I carry both, then I’m carrying 58 rounds total.

Shawn S.
Guest
Shawn S.

I carry a back up every time I leave my property. My main carry gun is a Taurus .357. My back up is the S&W .380. I openly carry my .357 and concealed with the .380. I help a lot of people including stranded motorist’s along side the road. These days you can’t trust everyone. Still I pull over and help. Thankfully I’ve never had to use either gun. I have however ran into situations where my openly carrying has made a person very noticeably nervous. I politely tell them I mean no harm and I’m just there to help.… Read more »

Mark Wynn
Guest
Mark Wynn

In looking for a “pocket pistol” replacement I rented several at my range … and settled on a Ruger lc9s as Goldilocks — just right.

Silence DoGood
Guest
Silence DoGood

Eventually everything breaks. The magic acronym is MTBF, mean time between failures, or in the case of firearms, Mean Rounds Between Failures. Three is two and two is one and one is none.

And the fastest reload is a BuG.