Berry’s vs Xtreme Bullets

In the battle of budget plated bullets, we go over why we give the slight edge to Xtreme (Extreme) bullets vs Berry’s bullets.

Results are our opinion based on reloading 9mm in race guns.

Plated Bullets

Plated bullets are when the entire bullet is encapsulated with copper so there’s no exposed lead which reduces lead exposure during shooting.  Here’s a refresher on Calibers & Types of Bullets.

Full Plated Bullets
Full Plated Bullets

Berry’s Bullets

Well known name for affordable bullets.  We first started with 1,000 124 gr RN (round nose) 9mm bullets from Berry’s as we liked factory 124 gr compared to 115 gr.  They looked shiny, reloaded fine, and shot great.  The overall cost was $93.45  (9.345 cents each) utilizing free shipping with orders over $75.

Berry's Bullets 9mm 124gr
Berry’s Bullets 9mm 124gr

Xtreme Bullets

Recommended by a fellow competitor for slightly cheaper prices.

We tried out their 147 gr RN (round nose) 9mm bullets.  They also were very shiny, reloaded fine, and shot great.  In fact, we were converted to the 147 gr 9mm weight due to the more “push”-like recoil.  Price was $43.75 per 500 and $5 flat shipping.  We bought 1,000 for 9.25 cent each.

Xtreme Bullets 9mm 147gr
Xtreme Bullets 9mm 147gr

Why Xtreme?

It really just boils down to price.

Keep in mind that 147 gr are more expensive than 124 gr bullets simply because of the extra materials.  If we bring it all to 124 gr, Xtreme bullets cost $39.90 per 500, so the per bullet cost would be 8.48 cents for 1,000 rounds including shipping.

Xtreme lately has been running 5% off promotions for a different caliber almost each day.  You should see your wanted caliber if you check the site everyday for 2 weeks.  That promotion would bring 1,000 rounds of 124 gr 9mm to 8.01 cents each compared to Berry’s 9.345 cents.

Xtreme Bullets Deal of the Day
Xtreme Bullets Deal of the Day

Other reasons include slightly shiner bullets, better boxes, and a less annoying site.  Berry’s has shooting sounds when you first go to the homepage which can startle you.  Also, at least for 9mm bullets, it’s hard to find the 2nd page, which led me to think they didn’t carry 147 gr bullets in the first place.  They’ve since put up a warning though.

Berry's Page
Berry’s Page

Conclusion

We go with Xtreme for price and no glaring performance issues.

There’s nothing wrong with Berry’s but when you’re buying thousands at a time, each little penny adds up.  All we need to do is hit our A-zones and plates and Xtreme does that just fine.  6,000 rounds and counting!

Bunch of Xtreme Bullets
Bunch of Xtreme Bullets

Update Dec 2016: Even more for me to reload and shoot!  Looking for primers/powders?  Best Places to Buy Reloading Components.

9mm and .30 Bullets
9mm and .30 Bullets

16 Leave a Reply

  • Randy Weeks

    I've been a long time customer with Xtreme, but lately their customer service really is bad. I've had an order with them for two weeks now with no response! The bullets are in stock according to their site!! They used to be sooo good about filling and shipping my orders, till now!!! I've emailed them three times with only one response, to the first one of course! I've put a lot of my friends on to Xtreme for their reloading bullets and this is what I get in return, SAD!!!

    10 months ago
    • David

      Xtreme and Freedom Munitions is owned by the same company and the parent company has filed for bankruptcy. I would assume that is why the customer service has gone down. I'm having a similar problem with Freedom Munitions.

      10 months ago
  • jsl55

    I've used thousands of X-Treme bullets. They load well and are accurate. My favorite for my Glock 34 & 17 9 mm is the 124 grain RNFP. I just got a box of Berry's to try and find them to be oily, where the X-Treme are not. I'll test them next weekend at the range.

    1 year ago
  • Doug Dunlap

    X-terme 124 grn. RN are my go to bullet , Yes you have to plan ahead , but taking advantage of free shipping when it's offered saves a bunch. I use Rainier same deal if you find reduced or free shipping jump on it , they are equal to X-Treme in every way. I have not tried Rocky Mountain ,but sounds like a must check .

    2 years ago
    • John

      Doug, I'm sure by now you have tried Rocky Mountain Reloading. I had a bad experience with Xtreme bullets too and RMR went straight to my order and helped get it shipped quick. Great customer service.

      1 month ago
    • Eric Hung

      Hey Doug, thanks for your input...I haven't tried Rainier nor RMR yet.

      2 years ago
  • Dominick F

    Over the last year and a half I have reloaded about 20,000 rounds of 9mm, every one of those with plated bullets. I started with several thousand X-Treme bullets, then moved to Berry's which gave me slightly better accuracy and the plating was holding up better on test bullets I would recover from downrange. But then I came across RMR (Rocky Mountain Reloading) Hardcore plated bullets and have never considered going back to either of the others since. The bullets hold up excellently (absolutely no breaks in the plating when fired at max loads) and the best accuracy by far of any of the three. I have found RMR to be the best plated bullet yet, and at 7.8 cents each I don't see myself going back to Berry's or Extreme anytime soon.

    2 years ago
    • Eric Hung

      Hey Dominick, thanks for the rec!

      2 years ago
  • todd

    Not unusual for xtreme bullets to be back ordered a couple of weeks. If you need bullets NOW (talking to you milleniums) then don't go with Xtreme. If you can build up a little bit of a stockpile and just add to it as you use your bullets, then you can't beat Xtreme. Had a order of 4000 once that had one box of 500 busted along one side. I was missing 17 bullets from that one box. The sent me another box of 500 at no charge, just had to send them a picture of the busted box.

    2 years ago
  • Renae

    Just a heads up, if time is an issue, am now at 20 days and my order from xtreme has still not shipped. When we called a week in, one item was out of stock. Website said in stock for each of 3 items we ordered. No notification, just let us wait til we decided to look into hold up. Shipping label created (not shipped) 2 days ago. Called again. Another item out of stock now. Again, no notification. Also if it was in stock at first, then they sold our order to someone else. Supposed to be looking into it, and emailing me, but I'm not holding my breath. We will not go with them again. Few pennies not worth the disrespectful for my business.

    2 years ago
    • ehung

      Hi Renae...that sucks especially since you were calling in! I hope they make it right.

      2 years ago
      • Renae

        Thank you. They finally shipped, ground, would have thought with the trouble they ,might have upgraded shipping, but in all fairnes, it wouldn't have made a difference in my choice of suppliers next time. The bright side? Looking for a place to leave a review, I found this site! Will be back often, lots to learn.

        2 years ago
        • Tracy

          Same issue with myself. I ordered 12 days ago and still no word. This is my first order with them and probably my last. I will try Rocky Mountain next.

          2 years ago
        • ehung

          Glad it's finally on it's way and thanks for the review. And I'll be seeing you around on the site!

          2 years ago
  • lindseje

    Are you familiar with Everglades Bullets? How would you compare them to Xtreme bullets? I agree for the money I have found Xtreme to be the better buy.Id like to know what you know. And is there anyone out there carrying a great bullet to hand load for self defense carry?

    3 years ago
    • ehung

      Hi, thanks for your comment. I'm unfamiliar with Everlades Bullets. But it looks like their branded ammo are jacketed vs Extreme's plated which means they'll be more expensive. As for bullets to hand load for self defense carry...I would suggest using factory ammo for liability reasons.

      3 years ago
New to Guns ? Check out our beginners guns video course. Start Now