Ask the Editors: .380 or smaller 9mm that is reliable and has a decent safety?
In this week's Ask the Editor, we tackle the best .380 ACP or compact 9mm with safety that is reliable and great for carry.
We review products independently. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission to help support our testing. Learn more.
Every Wednesday, we answer a question from you, our readers. Our editors weigh in with straight answers based on our testing and expertise.
Got a question of your own? Drop it in the comments below!
TL;DR: The Smith & Wesson CSX E-Series (9mm), Sig Sauer P365-XL Comp 380, Kimber CDS9 (9mm), Beretta 80X (.380 ACP), and the Sig P238 (.380 ACP) are our front runners.
Trending: Best AR-15s, Best AR-15 FRTs, & Daily Deals
Wyatt (Editor & Sr. Review Analyst)
The S&W CSX E-Series is small and concealable, but it has excellent capacity (12 rounds of 9mm with the smallest magazine). It is optics-ready and has an ambidextrous manual safety. (Read our S&W CSX E-Series Review -->)
The safety lever is a bit smaller than either the P238 or the 80X, but I still find it reasonably easy to actuate. It is definitely easier to hit than the ultra-small levers of the Bodyguard or Shield.

The Sig P365-XL 380 is a very thin, compensated .380 ACP variant of the Sig P365. It is slim, very concealable, and the compensator helps reduce the already mild .380 recoil even further. These guns are optics-ready, have a 12-round capacity, and they have a ton of holster options and a huge aftermarket.

Level up your gun knowledge
New reviews, guides and daily deals in your inbox.
The manual safety has a decent ledge and is pretty long. It isn’t the world’s most tactile safety, but it is still pretty good and very easy to use in my experience. This is my overall top pick for a .380 ACP gun with a manual safety.

Next up is the Kimber CDS9. This 9mm double-stack 1911-esque pistol will feel closest to the Staccato CS in overall feel, while still being thinner and easier to conceal.
The trigger is crisp, and the grip is a bit girthier, which might be beneficial if you feel that guns like the Bodyguard are too thin. The ambi safety is tactile, easy to hit, and will feel very familiar for anyone used to 1911/2011 pistols.
The Beretta 80X has the largest and easiest-to-actuate manual safety in my experience, but it is also the largest gun of the bunch.
Keep in mind that since it is direct-blowback, it’s harder to rack, and the recoil is a bit harsher (but not bad).
The Sig P238 is the oldest gun of the group, but feels like a scaled-down 1911-esque gun. It has the lowest capacity, but the safety is still easy to actuate, and it’s pleasant to shoot.
Our Most Popular Posts
Jacki (Editor-in-Chief)

Wyatt's recommendations are definitely solid, but I have to double down on the Sig P238. In my opinion, it's the best option.
It has a nice size and weight to it that makes it easy to carry, and all of its controls are easy to use. It's my favorite pistol for deep concealment or times when my outfits dictate the need for a smaller gun.

It's also reliable - I haven't had any issues with it during my time with it. Recoil is easy to manage, and it's not picky when it comes to ammo - which is great!
I bought one 6 or 7 years ago and still use it to this day. It's one of my favorite pistols in my own personal collection! I loved it so much I wrote the review on it for PPT, which you can jump to if you want more specifics.
Bottom Line
The Smith & Wesson CSX E-Series and Kimber CDS9 are the best options for a 9mm, while the Sig Sauer P365-XL Comp 380, Beretta 80X, and the Sig Sauer P238 are better for .380.
Have a question for the PPT team? Leave it in the comments below! We answer one reader question every Wednesday.
Meet the Team











