Are you looking to improve your AR-15 or build one from scratch with a piston gas system? You’re in the right place!
Switching to an AR-15 piston upper receiver is a great way to keep carbon buildup out of your bolt carrier group and chamber — and there are other benefits, too. But they’re expensive, and it can be hard to know which one to buy. Whew, it’s a good thing you have us.
We’ll highlight some of the bestpiston uppers and conversion kits we’ve used, point out key differences, and explain why you might pick one over another.
Are you ready to upgrade that AR of yours? Let’s go!
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Value
-
Best Premium
-
Best Conversion Kit
Table of Contents
Loading…
Best AR-15 Piston Upper & Conversion Kit Comparison Chart
| Caliber | Barrel Length | Handguard Length | Muzzle Device | Price | |
| Primary Weapons Systems MK116 MOD 2-M | .223 Wylde | 16.1″ | 15″ (M-LOK, Picatinny) | Compensator | $1,299 |
| Patriot Ordnance Factory P-415 Edge | 5.56 NATO | 16.5″ | 14.5″ (M-LOK) | Brake | $1,359 |
| LWRC IC-SPR | 5.56 NATO | 16.1″ | 12″ (user configurable rail system) | Flash Hider | $2,061 |
| Superlative Arms Adjustable Piston Kit | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | $260 |
How We Tested the Best AR-15 Piston Uppers & Conversion Kits
For this article, we gathered a bunch of AR-15 piston uppers we’ve personally shot, reviewed, and owned here at Pew Pew Tactical. The entire Pew Pew Tactical team, as well as freelance writers, contributed to this review to offer different opinions based on ergonomics, size, and experience.
Every review rifle undergoes 500 rounds of practice ammo and heavier match-grade ammo at 50 and 100 yards with a 5-25x scope (unless otherwise noted). We require all AR-15s to be tested with at least 3 magazines to assess compatibility, and we use a Lyman Digital Trigger Gauge to measure the average trigger pull for all guns.
Best AR-15 Piston Uppers
1. Primary Weapons Systems MK116 MOD 2-M – Best Overall
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Accurate and reliable
- three-position adjustable gas system
- Affordable
Cons
- Relatively heavy
Specs
- Caliber: .223 Wylde
- Barrel Length: 16.1″
- Handguard Length: 15″ (M-LOK, Picarinny)
- Muzzle Device: Compensator
When the apocalypse has come, and you’re digging through the local gun store to try and build something that will help you survive the wasteland that our world has become, the Primary Weapons Systems MK116 MOD 2-M is what you should be looking for.
All kidding aside, PWS has made what I consider one of the very best drop-in, no-fuss, shoot-all-day, piston-driven uppers on the market today. The company is an industry standard and a common recommendation for all the right reasons.
This upper has all the features I’d want, including the unabashedly cool PicLok System that allows you to use M-LOK and Picatinny attachments. It also features a 1:8 twist barrel that’s suitable for a wide range of bullet weights, a durable long-stroke piston, a Radian Raptor ambidextrous charging handle, and a muzzle brake.
The three-position adjustable gas system lets you fine-tune your AR, which is extra handy if you want to add a suppressor.
It also has a forged 7075 aluminum upper receiver, making it both stronger and lighter than a lot of billet receivers.
PWS rifles are known for their accuracy, quality, and reliability in the world of piston guns. If you are looking for a universal recommendation, this is about as close as you are gonna get — and it’s one heck of a shooter.
What do you think of PWS? Rate them below!
2. Patriot Ordnance Factory P415 Edge – Best Value
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Adjustable gas system
- Upgraded extractor design
- Reliable
Cons
- Picatinny rail isn't full-length
Specs
- Caliber: 5.56 NATO
- Barrel Length: 16.5″
- Handguard Length: 14.5″
- Muzzle Device: Brake
The Patriot Ordnance Factory P415 Edge delivers a ton of features at a surprisingly affordable price.
This piston upper sports a soft-shooting short-stroke piston, nitride heat-treated barrel, heat sink barrel nut, roller-cam pin bolt-carrier group, user-adjustable gas system, muzzle brake, 14.5-inch M-LOK rail with QD sling points, and POF’s patented E2 extraction technology. Those are all really nice upgrades that you won’t have to buy later on.
This animation shows how the E2 extraction design uses expanding gas to help dislodge the spent case. Bottom line: you’re less likely to experience a malfunction.
POF has been refining the Edge platform since 2002. The result is a rock-solid upper that’s loaded with high-end features out of the box.
3. LWRC IC-SPR – Best Premium
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Excellent build quality
- Accurate and smooth
- Durable
Cons
- Expensive
Specs
- Caliber: 5.56 NATO
- Barrel Length: 16.1″
- Handguard Length: 12″ (user configurable rail system)
- Muzzle Device: Flash Hider
Without a doubt, LWRC makes some of the best AR-15 piston uppers in the business, and the IC-SPR upper is a prime example of top-tier manufacturing.
The IC-SPR upper uses LWRC’s patented short-stroke piston for reduced recoil and unflinching reliability. The 16.1-inch heavy-contour barrel NiCorr-treated, cold-hammer forged, and fluted. A nickel-boron bolt carrier group, modular rail system, ambidextrous QD sling mounts, ambidextrous charging handle, and iron sights round out a complete package.
All of the materials used by LWRC are meant to survive the harshest conditions while reducing wear and tear. If you want an absolute top-of-the-line piston-upper (and have the cash to afford one), LWRC is hard to beat.
4. Superlative Arms Adjustable Piston Kit – Best Conversion Kit
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Pros
- Modify the AR upper receiver you already own
- Lots of options
- Affordable
Cons
- Requires assembly
Specs
- Caliber: N/A
- Barrel Length: N/A
- Handguard Length: N/A
- Muzzle Device: N/A
I love Superlative Arm’s adjustable gas block. In fact, it’s the only one that I use now.
While I haven’t tried out their entire piston system yet, I am eager to give it a shot due to it having the same rave reviews as their renowned direct impingement gas blocks.
I also appreciate how you can easily find the different gas lengths for the Superlative, as well as pencil barrel sizes in stock.
How to Pick the Best AR-15 Upper or Conversion Kit
In addition to choosing the best AR-15 piston upper for your needs, it’s also helpful to consider why you’d want a piston system instead of a more common direct impingement system in the first place.
Here are the basic advantages and disadvantages.
Where does that dirty gas go?
With a piston AR, you’ll get a small amount of powder fouling in a contained area around the piston face. As gas pushes the piston rearward, the bolt cycles with energy from a clean metal rod connected to the piston.
A direct impingement AR-15 sprays all that hot exhaust gas and powder residue straight back into the breech to force the bolt to cycle.
This means all that crud and junk from firing winds up all over your lower receiver, including the chamber and bolt carrier group, making for a much dirtier firearm. This means more frequent and tedious cleaning is required.
Heat Displacement
Every firearm gets hot, and that includes your AR-15.
You can actually mitigate some of that heat buildup with a piston system, though. It makes sense, right? Keeping all that hot gas out of the lower receiver will make everything run cooler.
Cost
Piston systems are more complicated than the simple tube of a DI system, so they’re naturally more expensive.
Some of these upper receivers cost as much as a fully-kitted direct impingement gun. But, for some people, that’s okay.
Compatibility
Sourcing parts for an AR-15 piston upper can be a bear. Piston systems aren’t necessarily standardized like direct impingement systems.
Weight Distribution
Since piston systems place more material above the barrel, a piston AR-15 can feel relatively front-heavy. I haven’t found this to be a meaningful hindrance, but it’s something to think about, especially if you want to build a lightweight AR-15.
Why Trust Pew Pew Tactical
Matthew Collins is a writer, editor, competitive shooter, hobby-level gunsmith, and general firearms enthusiast. He has a background in the entertainment industry and currently works as one of our awesome writers in the field.
Editing this article is Scott Murdock. Scott is a Marine Corps veteran who competed and qualified as a rifle and pistol expert while in service. In addition to shooting, Scott has written for a variety of publications, testing, researching, and evaluating guns and gear. He brings that knowledge and skillset to this article, editing and fact-checking for accuracy.
Editor-in-Chief Jacki Billings runs our experienced team of reviewers. She is a National Rifle Association Basic Pistol Instructor as well as a member of the Society of Professional Journalists, ACES: Society for Editing, and the Professional Outdoor Media Association. Jacki has a bachelor’s degree in journalism and has worked as a media professional for close to 20 years, specializing in gun media for almost 10 years. With 2,000+ articles to her name, she uses her professional journalism and editing experience to set testing protocols and editorial standards for Pew Pew Tactical.
Final Thoughts
If you don’t mind the inherent drawbacks, investing in an AR-15 piston upper can definitely mitigate heat buildup and make your post-range-session cleaning ritual significantly easier.
Is that worth the cost for one of these uppers? That’s up to you! If you decide to pull the trigger on a piston system, any of these will serve you well.
Do you have a favorite piston upper? Let us know in the comments! Want a direct impingement upper instead? We’ve got a few favorites in our Best AR-15 Upper Assemblies for the Money guide!
Latest Updates
January 2025: Removed the Adams Arms P2 AARS upper and Adams Arms P-Series Micro Block Piston Kit.
94 Leave a Reply
You should update this with PSAs JAKL offerings and even the Wolf A1 (although the Wolf seems to be harder to find. Plus, I would guess there are other piston uppers out there (Foxtrot Mike, etc)
are these mil spec?
Does anyone make a 20 gauge piston driven AR platform?
I run all of my ARs suppressed. Have an AA 308 12” pistol as my dedicated hog gun. It’s never jammed - suppressed or not. A few other AA conversions/builds and a Superlative build. All run great. I will never return to DI. Recommend running a piston build if shooting suppressed for sure. Great article..
Are there any piston kits for side charging AR uppers?
All of the Adams Arms kits support side chargers (I have them installed on 3 of my side-charging SBRs). The kits come with a bolt carrier that replaces the bolt carrier key with a flat block for the piston to push. If your side chargers are like mine, then the side charging handle uses a special bolt cam pin which fits in the AA bolt carriers fine.
Can you comment on the ADCOR Bear elite piston AR15?
Forgot to mention the t91 wolf upper unless it wasn't out at the time of this article
Probably worthy to at least mention that none of the POF offerings have a full-auto capable BCG, so not worth investing in a binary trigger solution. With that said, I own a POF Revolution 18" Gen 4 (.308) and it is by far the best AR I currently own and will likely take it with me to my grave!
Greetings,
We recently came across your website, is really amazing!
I’ve been looking at some products for a while now, and I found your guide on picking the right products very helpful.
I thought of reaching out to you as my website has a lot of information and products for people looking to find the right Ak 47 PISTOL and DRACO.
Could you possibly add a link to my content in your resource section? I will also add a link to your website on my resource page as well.
Let me know what you think and if this is something we can work with.”
we will be waiting on your responds regarding our request, THANKS FOR YOUR COOPRATION.
martinarmory.us
AK PISTOL FOR SALE
WHERE TO BUY AK PISTOL ONLINE
BUY AK PISTOL Online
AK Pistol for sale
Best Place To Buy AK Pistol Online
Where To Buy AK Pistol Online
Best Place To Buy AK Pistols Online
AK Pistols Online
AK pistol
AK pistol For Sale
Buy AK pistol online
AK pistol
AK 47 pistol for sale
Buy AK 47 Pistol online
Where to buy AK 47 pistol online
Buy AK Pistol Online
Micro Draco For Sale
Buy Micro Draco Online
Micro Draco AK pistol
Mini Draco For Sale
Best Place To Buy Mini Draco online
MINI DRACO FOR SALE
Hellpup AK Pistol
Pioneer Arms Hellpup
Hellpup Draco
Hellpup Ak Pistol
Buy AK Pistols Online
Where To Buy AK Pistols Online
AK Pistol For Sale
Psl 54 For Sale
Best Place To Buy AK Pistol Online
Hellpup Draco
Pioneer Arms Hellpup Problems
Polish Hellpup Problems
Custom Micro Draco
Hellpup Ak Pistol Grip
Hellpup Ak Pistol Review
You can look all this up yourself faster than you typed it here.
Do these piston conversion kits work with other calibers, such as 7.62x39? What about using one with a Gibbz side charging upper receiver?
I like this list, but I would say POF-USA P415 EDGE, and the LWRC IC-A5 are a toss up, as far as quality, and which one is best!
I was really surprised the Superlative Arms (SA) piston conversion kit was mentioned so late in the article. After much research, I chose the SA kit for the removal plug that allows for quick removal of the piston/rod assembly for cleaning without any further disassembly. I bought one SA kit, then two more, as I found the kit to be EXCELLENT, and more than met my needs! The BCG was cool to the touch after 50 rounds of .223 and the barrel & chamber were the only items that needed cleaning. I have several DI ARs, but when SHTF time comes, my piston kit ARs will be on duty! The provided carrier is also well made, and I whole heartedly recommend the SA piston conversion kit without hesitation!
Outstanding summary for a guy who has not handled a AR 16 platform since the 1980s. Trying to catch up.
I appreciate all of your comparison and review articles. It's worth noting that Superlative's piston kits are NOT rated for 300 BLK, however, Adams Arms does have one specifically for 300BLK. An SBR in 300BLK would benefit from being piston operated, if for no other reason than reducing internal fouling.
can i convert a ar 45 gas blowback system with no gas port in the barrel to a piston system
Looking to make a build with PWS reciver extension and either SA or AA piston conversion kit. Will this build function like the HK 416 during HK's SOCOM water test?
The water test is more than the piston kit. Their lower is where they shine. Only an HK will function like an HK. If you need an AR that will see service where immersing in water will be common , buy the HK. They are made for severe service. Every part is designed for hard service.
The PWS in the pic is MOD 1. The MOD 2 has no forward assist. Otherwise a fantastic article. I personally love piston guns. My 1st AR was an Adam's Arms 16 inch. Great gun insanely reliable. Now I have numerous AR's. My favorite is my PWS MK111 MOD 2. It is an absolute tac driver! I shot both of the Barret options and wasn't overly impressed to be honest. Plus the Barrets are noticeable heavier then the PWS. I run all my ARs suppressed so piston systems are the way to go. Please keep up the great work, I appreciate you articles. Thank you!
We're in the process of updating some of these older articles so they're more current and correct. So, thanks for pointing that out and for reading!
I have the mossberg mmr.
Could anyone tell me if, and what poston System will fit the 16 inch barrel model
Hi
Will the Adams Arms Piston Kit (P-Series) work with this
PSA 11.5" 5.56 1/7 PHOSPHATE 10.5" M-LOK UPPER - WITH BCG, CH, & MBUS SIGHT SET AND BUSHNELL TRS-26 RED DOT
Regards
Will this work in a left handed upper or do they make one for right handed
Any piston kit that comes with a bolt carrier assembly included in the price will be right-handed only. You can take that bad news to the bank. The ONLY after-market piston kit (that I’ve ever found) that can be fiddled with to work with a left-hand upper receiver is Adams Arms. And that’s been a while back; Adams Arms went “tits up” (bankrupt) a while back but someone bought them and trimmed the product line … and may have (permanently?) dropped a key component that makes the L.H. conversion possible, circa 10/2021: The FGAA-10053. This little item replaces the standard Gas Key on any AR-15 bolt carrier to give the piston op rod something to push against - and unlock the bolt. I bought two years ago, used one and have misplaced the other. But before that happened, I created my dream upper half from a Stag Arms L.H. stripped upper, Stag Arms L.H. Bolt Carrier Group - removing the standard gas key and replacing it with this FGAA-10053 - new mounting screws re-staked + Loc-Tite - and adapted the bolt per Adams Arms instructions. Went with the mid-length gas system and a super-duper 16” mid-length 416 st. stl. barrel from Black Hole Weaponry. It’s my dream-come-true rifle.
Could you use the superlative kit to convert an upper chambered in 7.62x39? Ammo prices are ridiculous but steel case Russian ammo is still dirt cheap. I hate running steel in my DI rifles.
Good luck finding a Superlative Arms Piston kit. Very back ordered from the vendors I’ve emailed. I own three .750 set screw 16” Mid-length precision PROOF .223 wylde, .625 set screw 11.5” Carbine 5.56 and 0.750 clamp on 16” Carbine 7.62x39. The latter is what I think you are asking about and while SA doesn’t say its tested with 300blk, much less 7.62x39. 7.62x39 with the SA kit works superb. Carbine length is really needed to cycle the BCG and get lock back at fully open. I have a fourth build waiting for another batch of SA kits. I’m kicking myself for not buying it when I saw it in stock. A week later it was gone. Good luck.
Noob here. Curious what you mean by "Carbine length is really needed to cycle the BCG and get lock back at fully open"? You mean if you went with a longer length you might not be able to cycle properly? Was thinking about longer lengths as I've read a bunch of articles about softer shooting with the longer length gas systems.
Looks like a few who are interested in shooting (cheap but dirty) 7.62x39 are here. On the SA kit would you recommend clamp or set screw, or is either one fine? Sounds like one will need to take whatever they can get but I was wondering anyway. Thanks.
2020 update? Adams P-series kit from 2017 has been discontinued. Thoughts on the Superlative Arms kit?
I'm a newbie and want to build an upper with piston kit from the get-go. Consider new article?
We have this article on the list for major update soon! The Superlative Arms kit is good to go! If you're looking for a piston upper that is ready out of the box, you might want to take a look at the Brownells BRN-180.
I was also wondering about this as this article mentions the SA adjustable gas block and mentions wanting to try their piston kit so would love to know the results of that.
Many of the parts on this list are discontinued. I would love to see an updated list.
Would these work for 300 black?
Super-sonic yes but not subs. Tried a superlative arms kit on a 16” rifle. Had a pistol length gas system and a tuneable jp scs and still wouldn’t cycle subs at all unless suppressed
I think this article needs to be updated because the best budget piston upper right now is the Wolf A1, which you can get for $449. It has been very well-reviewed and is essentially an import of the T91 upper used by several militaries around the world.
I got a Wolf A1 on sale for less than $449 on sale and its great. People who pay attention are always....'....hey, what upper is THAT?'
Would recommend, would buy again.
I run a Sig 516 on an AP lower with a Geissele FastFire (lighter trigger spring) and am pleased with this one. very accurate, clean running and smooth to shoot. I would like to swap out the handguard for a lighter M Loc.
I have both the Adam's (AA) and the Superlative (SA) mid, adjustable, lo pro kits mounted. They both work well. I prefer the Superlative kits for these reasons: 1) The SA kit allows for the removal and cleaning of the op rod and spring without dismounting the gas block. With the AA kit, one must take off the gas block to remove / replace the op rod and spring. The AA gas block requires a hydraulic press to install or remove it. 2) The SA kit will allow the use of many more different free float rail systems. There is no dependence on what is a highly customized barrel nut as in the AA kit. 3) The AA kit's dependence on the use of the milspec barrel nut, or their proprietary barrel nut, forces the selection of the AA free float rail system as the only "affordable" option. AA lists others on their website, but most us a GI barrel nut, or cost a bunch of money. My AA rail had alignment issues, I sent it back.
The AA system does have the op rod spring outside of the gas flow, and so is protected from it. The SA kit has the op rod spring in the high temp gas flow, so there's a question how many firing cycles it will withstand before needing replacement.
What? Need a hydraulic press to install/remove the AA gas block? Wouldn't that just about eliminate most people?
Your own admission: "Well, with a standard AR-15, you get exhaust gases and powder, and all that crud and gunk that comes from firing a gun dumped right back into the breech."
That Sir, was reason enough for my first three AR's to be piston-operated.
Don't drink soda, Ford sucks and wtf is a Goku?
The Adams Arms conversion works real good and I bought it from Midway before I read your review. Thank you
should i just get the LWRC piston gun and be done with it??
Lwrc or POF either one you will be very happy with, POF has some of the best customer service in the bussiness right now, and a really good lifetime of the GUN warranty, that follows the gun not the owner. LWRC Makes some really beautiful gun well made guns as well I personally own 3 POF's and one LWRC six8. I do t think you can go wrong either way, if your looking at piston guns the main four in my opinion are POF, LWRC, PWS, AND LMT.(lmt does some really cool stuff as well, a d they do have a pretty good piston option, BUT in my opinion, it is not their specialty like the three others.) Hope that helps. P.s. this article is extremely poorly written, and inaccurate so take what you learn from it with a grain of salt.
I also agree with Eric, I own a few POF’s and very happy with them (you get what you pay for).
I think they have to give a DGI operated rifles credit for something so, they selected accuracy. I say maybe - if it's tuned like a concert piano. Like you, I'm a piston guy owning 3 PWS and 1 Adams Arms.
They're outfitted with combat sights, i.e., Trijicon ACOGS with RMR's perched on top of 'em. They're nothing shy of combat accurate. Even the 7.62 x 39 PWS shoots phenomenally.
My advice, especially if you're new to this game, save up and purchase a piston-operated AR.
Rationale: The guys that purchase a DGI end-up dumping money into adjustable gas blocks, BCG's, ambi charging handles, and buffer springs and/or buffer weights. Now, you're at or very close in price to an entry level piston-operated rifle.
Neither piston-operated nor DGI-operated Mil-Spec rifles come with sub Mil-Spec trigger pull. So, IF accuracy is paramount, plan on adding an aftermarket trigger and trigger pin anti-walk kit. For the record, MIL-C-71186 states 5.5-8.5 pounds trigger pull. I'm not certain but for liability, I reckon manufacturers are reluctant to install a lower trigger pull on a semi-auto rifle?
I prefer shooting and cleaning the gas piston over the direct impingement. The gas piston has a little less recoil too.
I gotta say this article sucks! Its full of errors, one big one is that the PWS FULL RIFLE SHOWING IS THE MK1 MOD1, NOT MK1 MOD2. The MOD1, has a forward asisst the MOD2 does NOT. ALSO almost every RIFLE maker that makes a piston rifle WILL SELL THIER UPPERS SEPARATELY, So not sure where that came from. Also Barrets upper is not one of the most expensive out there, its on PAR with all the other HIGHEND piston systems, you have just picked it to compare to all the bottom end ones. PWS IS MIDDLE GROUND, BUT the rest are low entry level systems, the PRICE POINT for the Barret is similar to LWRC, LMT, And alittle higher then Sig, and POF, (which for me is probably the best bang for your buck piston rifle), but if you put the Barret next to lets say a H&K 416 upper, or even an MR5.56 the BARRET look positively cheap in comparison. So idk just my two cents. There was other errors as well but those are the most glaring. Idk you guys gotta know this stuff I am not some expert, so what up with that? Did those brands not send the monthly check or something???
Can anyone tell me if these conversion kits will work with my current free float rail system? Its a Leapers UTG super slim 13 inch
Both Superlative Arms and Adams Arms have a diagram for their block dimensions, so look that up and measure your rail. Also on the adams arms you might have to notch the barrel nut on the rail system for the recoil spring so it will sit at milspec length away from the receiver.
That being said I have shot both and the superlative is the easier to fit one, but the adams arms is more robust. If you are going to be doing fullauto or binary mag dumps, go with the adams. If you just want a piston for cleaning and ease of supressor use, get the superlative.
I got the same pencil barrel setup for a light weight build (coming from a 16" HBAR). I works great with an Griffin Opitmus on the end - with one huge downside. The 1 pound can causes the barrel to bend 0.006" (6 thousanths) at the gas block and equates to a 3" lower bullet strike at 25 yards. So I will run it unsupressed and get the 11.5" mid-length gas Faxon Gunner barrel that is stiff and designed for dedicated suppressor use.
I know this is a dead thread by now, but that Superlative piston system is the best IMO. I think in another year after it's been compared to the rest by all the gurus out there that it will rise to the top of the list. Several enlisted gear heads I know swear it's a much better designed system than the other piston kits like apples and oranges and I agree. Maybe others will pip in and add to that testimony ?
I did a 10 (30rd) mag dump through it with a binary trigger and a shot timer with around 670rpm per mag and ~2 sec mag changes on a shot timer, estimated because on mag 6 it seized. I melted the recoil spring inside the housing and mushroomed the bottom of the piston in the housing because of that, had to drive the piston out with a hammer after it was pulled off the barrel.
That being said, 99% of people will not torture their rifle like that. But if heat absorption is an issue. I would go adams arms over the superlative, even with the barrel nut fitment issues. But for general suppressor or range use the superlative will work fine. Also on my kit they packaged the wrong diameter block, and wouldn't get back to me. Luckily I bought it from brownells and explained the issue and they gladly swapped it for me. So another thing to keep in mind.
Your article is full of inaccuracies. It’s common knowledge the correct answers are Pepsi, Chevy, and Superman. Goku shouldn’t even be a choice, Batman for the win. As far as the gun stuff goes, good article. I enjoyed it.
Agree, agree, and you couldnt be more wrong about Goku. If you knew even the slightest amount of dragon ball super, you wouldn't go spouting off about a buff dude with a fat bank account and a utility belt lmao. Goku is basically a God and superman can be snuffed out with a wee lito bit of kryptonite. ..
I have experience with the Adams Arms mid-length upper and the Superlative Arms conversion kit. i both systems in operation. I use both AR15s in carbine and two-gun matches. Both options are reliable and keep the receiver clean. Both guns operate without malfunction or misfeed given good magazines.
The Adams Arms upper is durable. The upper has years of use and many thousands of rounds through it. In fact, I amreplacing the barrel. Yes, Melonite-treated barrels wear out after a respectable number of rounds. My only criticism is handguard heating. The Adams Arms gas block exhausts gases at the rear of the block. The handguard gets hot after 100 rounds. This is a small criticism. All guns get hot after enough rapid fire.
The Superlative Arms conversion kit is added to a Faxon mid-length 16 inch barrel and Faxon upper receiver. It was easy to assemble with the right tools. The instructions were clear and accurate. I have several hundred rounds through the Superlative Arms system.
There are no instructions regarding cleaning the Superlative Arms gas block and no mention of a requirement to clean the gas block. I have not cleaned or lubricated the gas block since it installation. It functions and feeds flawlessly. It is lighter than the Adams Arms, especially out front. The gas block exhausts gas out of the front toward the muzzle. The handguard stays cool a little longer. I need more rounds through the gun to determine the conversion kit durability and the need, if any, to clean or lubricate the gas block.
Swapping the carrier rather.
I’m interested in building a side charging piston driven 7.62x39 upper. Any input would be great. I’ve found side charging DI uppers but not the combo of side charging/piston. Would it just be a matter of swapping the gas key for its piston counterpart?
Haven't seen too much online about the Superlative arms kit. I know its compatible with quite a few more handguards as it doesn't need a standard milspec barrel nut. I'm building a 11.5" pistol with intentions to run it suppressed 90% of the time. Would you recommend the Superlative system over the AA? There just isn't too much 3rd party info out there on the superlative arms system. The review link for superlative isn't active btw.
So does the Adams Arms Piston Kit (P series) work with the Superlative Adjustable Gas Block?
I'm not sure. I'd pick up a P series gas block from AA, if one isn't included in the conversion kit.
You can't use the AA and Superlative parts together 2 different set ups. The AA has a different style of op rod with the spring against the barrel nut vs the Superlative being contained in the adjustable gas block.
So the 2 are different in that aspect.
As far as one being better than the other again is users choice, would you rather have a spring at the barrel nut or in the gas block..
I have the Superlative adjustable on a 14.7 Hanson profile BA barrel fitted to a Aero Precision upper with a Vltor Flash hider, I get zero gas back in my face and all the excess gas is adjusted out the front of the Superlative gas block.
This was my first build and I have a approximately 200 rounds through it so far, Once you set you the gas block per the directions and follow the adjustments you can dial in the gas venting to your desires=d style and preferences.
Well worth the $260 for the Superlative piston kit which included the bolt carrier minus bolt,
Coke, ford and goku...done. Go buy a noveske for my first plinkin rifle? Whatever you say
I have the Barrett Rec7 Gen2 piston and its my favorite AR I've had to date and I've had a LOT of top shelf AR's. I also own an LMT piston AR and its my second favorite. It's a close second! But I've owned POF (great gun too) LWRC (didn't like, not reliable) Sig 516 (decent) and a Ruger 556 piston (SUCKED).. Those are just the piston models I've owned. I definately love the Barrett Rec7 Gen2 the most! The LMT is for sure the second best I've ever used or owned. POF is great too (just couldn't get used to the damn gigantic and colossal handguard) but the rest are not worth the money. I've never shot a PWS piston AR but I've heard good things about them. Anybody that wants the best regardless of price should get the Barrett. And they now come with an M-Lok handguard (Damnit mine has keymod!). My DI guns I own are 2 Daniel Defense rifles and Knights Armament..... And its, Pepsi-Ford-Superman.
Currently at the moment I own two gas piston AR style guns. One is an LWRC M6 A2 SPR & a Hogan. Both are Fantastic but the Hogan just shoots like no other. There is virtually no recoil with the Hogan as it feels like you're shooting a .22 lr but on the other hand this thing is EXTREMLY loud. POF is another great manufacture of gas piston driven weapons... Just a FYI...
I have an Adam's Arms Tac Evo with a kryptex finish. It was my first AR and while I was going for a Sig M400, the Sig was out of my price range. The salesman showed me the AA TEvo saying it had just as good of components at a better price. I wanted to get a fully set up AR for under $1k. The AA came in at $950 (WA), felt great and seemed smooth. I put a Vortex Strike Eagle on it and am totally in love with the AA. It's lighter than the S&W MP (my other contender). and came with all of the extras.
I will probably build my next AR. And I would like to add a special "Thanks" to the Pew Crew for all of the invaluable information. Your research has answered a lot of questions and my education wouldn't be as complete without all of your insight. Again THANK YOU!!!
So glad we could help out, Matt. Let us know how your next AR build goes!
Great comparison I have a pws DI 14 inch upper only dont live in a free state.
just ordered a mk118 mod2 cant wait.
and its coke, chevy & superman.
Thanks Steve, let us know how it's running!
2 out of three not bad.... Chevy takes the lead with small blocks and LS series motors. Good info and well done.
Piston AR's and no mention of Patriot ordnance firearms? I feel they have really led the market in new innovations for piston ar's. One of few who did a 7.62x39 piston ar fully reliable out of the box too! Love my POF 300 Winchester Magnum AR10. They even make a ar15 .308 now. This has been on the cover of every gun magazine out lately.
308 means its an AR-10 not AR-15. but POF does make some great gear.
At one time I had an LWRC, short stroke piston, and a PWS, long stroke piston. Eventually I sold the LWRC as thej PWS(mk116) was more accurate
and overall more enjoyable to shoot. Customer service and tech support with piston guns is very important as mentioned in the article and let's just say one was top notch with the other was completely unresponsive. I know own the mk116 mod1, a mk114 mod2 and mk220 6.5creedmoor.
Just a quick, subjective, observation on how short stroke-tappet operation and long stroke piston systems compare: the stroke stroke has an abrupt snappy recoil where as long stroke has a smoother, albeit stronger than DI, push effect. Some, myself, include feels the recoil from Long Stroke allows for quicker more accurate follow up shots. The fact that PWS rifle can be seen used in 3 gun and other competitive circuits whereas I can't think of anyone using short stroke rifles competively would attest to that.
Has anyone built or reviewed a piston SBR? Can you run a piston on say an 8"-10.5" in .300 AAC with suppressor? Sounds like a research project for pew-pew...
Good idea, Andrew!
No mention of the HK MR556 upper? I heard it's required to use a tall hammer with the HK MR556 upper before it be works properly.
I love piston guns. They run super clean. The upper receiver isn't on fire after you rapid fire 50+ rounds. Bolt carrier almost never needs to be cleaned, just the bolt itself. The only tricky part is finding handguards that work with piston systems. They're all designed for DI. But some do work and some of the better uppers come with decent hand guards. I have a Black Rifle Arms piston upper and I love it. Comes with Troy M-lok rail. My next piston gun will be an Adcor side charging AR15.
RC, Jeep, and Sentry!
Okay for a pistol AR with 7.5 barrel. Piston is the way to go? especially if I want to suppress it...you know after eating roman and tuna for a year to save the money.
Do you need a different upper if your building a piston AR or will any direct impingement upper work as well?
The upper receiver can stay the same.
I think piston is the way to go , patriot ordnance or adam arms?....mmmnnn......
Another benefit to look at is avoiding all the exhaust blowback from the rifle. According to the diagram, the exhaust is going forward, instead in your face.....
Anyhow, I think piston is the way to go , patriot ordnance or adam arms?....mmmnnn......
I have a PWS MK216 in .308 with a long-stroke piston and it is an absolute dream to shoot. I would concur that the PWS is a top-notch AR platform in any caliber offered.
100% agree. I looked at everything for my .308, DD, POF, LaRue, Barrett, FN, and settled on the PWS long stroke piston, absolute phenomenal shooter. The only upgrades I will do is the stock and grip, l;ikely drop in a Geissle trigger, and add a TBAC can to the front. These are absolutely not required, put decent glass on it, run some quality handloads, and you will easily be sub-MOA. Love my PWS.
Coke Ford And Superman are the correct answers
I agree with the first 2 but, Goku > Superman. Haha.
When converting from D.I. to piston, have you noticed any impact on tuning or does the piston system run pretty comparable? Also, being that there are moving parts more forward in the rifle, is this noticed during shooting? It seems like the barrel would "dip" when the piston resets. Great article, but it's Coke, Ford, Superman, probably 'cuz I'm old!
Anderson RF85 treated uppers are a little cheaper and really work...
got an ospry piston and love it, much cheaper too
Great article. On the piston conversion kits, did you try the Superlative Arms conversion kit? If so, how does it stack up to your pick, the Adams Arms conversion kit?
Thanks.
I dig the superlative arms gas block but haven't had the chance to use their piston conversion kit yet.
I did t see LWRCI's piston rifles on this list. Do they under perform in comparison?
They are a great company we just haven't had that much experience with them.
Very interesting article. I already have a carbine so I'd like a longer length barrel for distance. Does the Adams Arms (or any other reputable manufacturer) make a piston upper with an 18" or 20" barrel?
Thanks!